Acknowledging the part a quality mare plays

5 min read
Selecting the right stallion for your mare is one of the most important aspects of breeding thoroughbred racehorses. If you get it wrong, then no amount of attention to rearing and training can make up for the lack of inherent ability. John Boyce takes a look at the role mare quality plays on stallion success.

Choose the right stallion and you are in with a fighting chance. Assuming your intent is to produce a racehorse rather than a sales horse, there are myriad of methods to help you make an informed decision. But there are always barriers to the most important answer. How do I assess a stallion’s true ability at siring good racehorses? It is not as easy as it sounds!

As a breeder, I could do worse than rely on last season’s leading sires list. The top ten sires in the premiership ought to be able to sire top horses more frequently than the rest. Well, we can do better than that, and to illustrate this point, I would like to take the top five active Australian sires by percentage of Stakes winners to runners and present them in a different light.

"It’s a well-known fact that if two parents are talented, rather than just one, the offspring are likely to be more successful." - John Boyce

It’s a well-known fact that if two parents are talented, rather than just one, the offspring are likely to be more successful, regardless of the endeavor. Well, the same applies to racehorses. We also know that good mares make up only a tiny proportion of the total broodmare band. Stallions who earn the right to attract the best mares are hugely advantaged. It takes an exceptional stallion to prove his worth with poor mares.

I recently calculated that the odds of making it to the very top in Europe are approximately 150 to 1 if mares are from the bottom half of the population. In fact, if the mares are from the top 15% of the population then a stallion has a one in ten chance of becoming a Galileo or Dubawi.

Yet these 1-in-10 or 1-in-12 odds are often mistakenly quoted for all stallions. Top-class stallions invariably share two characteristics: they can sire a greater ratio of top-class horses and they tend to be able to outscore the ratios achieved by all other stallions that serve their mares.

Levelling the playing field

I have often wondered if we could level the playing field – all stallions get access to the same quality of mare. What then would we see?

The tables included here gives us an insight and also helps explain the careers of some of the stallions included. Ranked by Stakes winners to runners, Redoute’s Choice is predictably the best of this bunch, scoring 12.0% and it is also no surprise to see his output increase when we restrict his runners to those from elite mares.

Table 1: Total career statistics

Redoute's Choice 1,246 15012.0%
Snitzel 829 8510.3%
Exceed And Excel 939 869.2%
Fastnet Rock 1,201 1089.0%
I Am Invincible 486 408.2%
Not A Single Doubt 792 617.7%
Sebring 690 517.4%

Table 2: Career statistics from elite mares

Redoute's Choice75210714.2%
Snitzel2784014.4%
Exceed And Excel4344610.6%
Fastnet Rock6477111.0%
I Am Invincible6957.2%
Not A Single Doubt1471812.2%
Sebring2222410.8%

Table 3: Career statistics from non-elite mares

Redoute's Choice494438.7%
Snitzel551458.2%
Exceed And Excel505407.9%
Fastnet Rock554376.7%
I Am Invincible417358.4%
Not A Single Doubt645436.7%
Sebring468275.8%

So, if we break Redoute’s Choice’s mares into two groups – elite mares and non-elite mares – we get scores of 8.7% Stakes winners for the non-elite mares and 14.2% for elite mares. For the purposes of this study, an elite mare is one that belongs in the top 15% of the broodmare population.

And to be perfectly even handed, the mares are graded at the time of covering. We would see an even more striking difference if we included the dams’ of Stakes winners by this group of sires as elite mares, which of course they are.

Like father like son

Another interesting case is the current Champion sire Snitzel, who built his reputation from humbler beginnings than his sire, covering large numbers of non-elite mares. With the non-elites, he has succeeded in siring 8.2% Stakes winners to runners, which is way below the 14.4% he gets from his elite mares.

"What these scores demonstrate is that Snitzel was always as good as his sire. He was just never given the same opportunities." - John Boyce

It is easy to understand why Snitzel’s star is set to rise even further as most of his young racehorses and the majority those still in the pipeline are from top-class mares. What these scores demonstrate is that Snitzel was always as good as his sire. He was just never given the same opportunities. Even his stud companion Not A Single Doubt – again with top mares – is not that far adrift of his sire, certainly not as far as their career scores of 12.0% and 7.7% might suggest.

Snitzel

With a comparatively smaller pool of elite mares in Australia, compared to Europe and America, it is not surprising that many top-class sires are discovered from among the lower ranks.

Such is the case with I Am Invincible. This son of Invincible Spirit doesn’t yet have that many runners out of elite mares. That’s about to change drastically. But it’s interesting to note that when assessed with non-elite mares, he’s the second best on our list behind Redoute’s Choice. And it’s a fair bet that Redoute’s Choice’s non-elites were of a higher calibre that those covered by I Am Invincible.

"This son of Invincible Spirit doesn’t yet have that many runners out of elite mares. That’s about to change drastically." - John Boyce

Nearly all of the sires in the group benefit from covering good mares and there is no surprise in that. However, as our opinions are all too easily arrived at when assessing stallions, we must always acknowledge the part played by mare quality.

I Am Invincible