A buoyant yearling market is essential for commercial breeders to continue supplying Australia’s racecourses with quality racehorses – don’t forget 65% of all Stakes horses are sourced from the yearling sales.
But rising markets often lead to price inflation. Are service fees now getting to levels where they are likely to reduce profitability at the yearling sales in two years’ time?
The bare facts show that 2019 fees are higher than the previous year. The stallions that had published fees in 2018 already announced for 2019 show an average increase from $23,660 to $25,600 this year. And there have been some notable hikes: Zoustar up to $154,000 from $60,500; I Am Invincible up to $247,500 from 192,500 and Dundeel up to $66,000 from $27,500.
Zoustar's service fee has risen from $60,500 to $154,000 in 2019
In all 24 stallions announced so far have had fee increases while 37 have reduced fees – the biggest reduction by only an $11,000 margin – leaving 90 unchanged.
There are 29 stallions listed at $30,000 or higher, four fewer than last year, but three more than the year before. But it’s very much a case of the rich getting richer at the elite end of the market: the average service fee above $30,000 has gone from $60,000 to $77,000 in the past three years.
Yearling market must carry increases
But can the yearling market carry such increases? A sire’s yearling returns are the most important piece of information when setting stud fees for established sires. After Sydney’s Easter sale, everyone has the necessary information on which to base next season’s proposition to breeders. Naturally enough, stallion farms need to make money too, not least for future investment in new stallions.
"A sire’s yearling returns are the most important piece of information when setting stud fees for established sires." - John Boyce
It’s not surprising, therefore, that stud fees tend to track the rise and fall of the yearling market. It’s also true that many sires will rise on the back of excellent results on the racecourse, in the reasonable anticipation of greater demand for nominations, crucially with better-bred mares that were not present to bolster 2019 yearling averages. Even so, the yearling market still provides the context against which service fee levels can be judged.
The yearling market still provides the context against which service fee levels can be judged
Excluding all sires without published fees and those that had fewer than 25 yearlings sold at the sales, we can get a handle on fee movements in recent years. In 2019, the top 30 Australian sires by yearling average (25 or more sold) with published fees for the new season are listed below.
They have a combined average fee of $63,379, compared to $56,510 last year. That’s a high average and one that must also be viewed in context with the $45,448 in 2017, the $38,922 in 2016 and the $40,847 in 2015. Moreover, mapping the number and cost of $30k-plus stallions among this group, there is further evidence that we are in a new uncharted era in 2019. After the yearling sales in 2015, 13 fees were set higher than $30,000.
That number was stable for the next two years – 11 in 2016 and 14 in 2017, but has been on the rise ever since with 17 last year and 18 this time around. And whilst the changes in the numbers of stallions may not be startling, it is again the nature of the increases that grabs our attention. The average fee for this group in 2019 is $91,000 – an all-time high.
| I Am Invincible | 2019 | 104 | $410,480 | $247,500 | 60% |
| Fastnet Rock | 2019 | 51 | $400,204 | $165,000 | 41% |
| Snitzel | 2019 | 66 | $399,824 | $220,000 | 55% |
| Not A Single Doubt | 2019 | 56 | $314,082 | $110,000 | 35% |
| Exceed And Excel | 2019 | 39 | $291,744 | $88,000 | 30% |
| Zoustar | 2019 | 81 | $273,115 | $154,000 | 56% |
| Brazen Beau | 2019 | 43 | $252,128 | $49,500 | 20% |
| Written Tycoon | 2019 | 108 | $223,062 | $110,000 | 49% |
| Pierro | 2019 | 47 | $206,310 | $88,000 | 43% |
| Vancouver | 2019 | 71 | $183,782 | $44,000 | 24% |
| More Than Ready | 2019 | 54 | $161,697 | $66,000 | 41% |
| Dundeel | 2019 | 67 | $152,513 | $66,000 | 43% |
| So You Think | 2019 | 64 | $126,372 | $38,500 | 30% |
| Deep Field | 2019 | 92 | $118,277 | $44,000 | 37% |
| Rubick | 2019 | 53 | $113,931 | $38,500 | 34% |
| Pride of Dubai | 2019 | 66 | $113,011 | $38,500 | 34% |
| Spirit of Boom | 2019 | 52 | $103,519 | $44,000 | 43% |
| Kermadec | 2019 | 51 | $96,936 | $16,500 | 17% |
| Dissident | 2019 | 89 | $94,018 | $27,500 | 29% |
| Exosphere | 2019 | 52 | $92,293 | $22,000 | 24% |
| All Too Hard | 2019 | 64 | $86,418 | $27,500 | 32% |
| Rich Enuff | 2019 | 38 | $79,378 | $12,100 | 15% |
| Street Boss | 2019 | 27 | $77,704 | $27,500 | 35% |
| Choisir | 2019 | 54 | $75,549 | $27,500 | 36% |
| Nicconi | 2019 | 72 | $75,063 | $38,500 | 51% |
| Press Statement | 2019 | 44 | $73,230 | $16,500 | 23% |
| Star Witness | 2019 | 67 | $73,125 | $27,500 | 38% |
| Akeed Mofeed | 2019 | 26 | $69,654 | $16,500 | 24% |
| Toronado | 2019 | 47 | $69,014 | $27,500 | 40% |
Table: Active Australian sires with 25+ yearlings sold in 2019 ranked by average price
Higher fees a global phenomenon
However, it’s not all bad news for commercial breeders. The comparative strength of the yearling market will cushion most of these increases. A simple index, comparing the yearling average and fee, shows that on average 2019 fees make up only 35% of individual average yearling prices.
In 2018, new fees accounted for 33% of yearling averages. In 2017, that number was 33%, and 31% in 2016 but as high as 37% in 2015. So, 2019 is not the worst year on record for yearling average/service fee ratios.
"The comparative strength of the yearling market will cushion most of these increases." - John Boyce
Higher fees are a global phenomenon. In Europe the top 30 commercial sires saw their fees rise from an average of £51k to £60k in 2019, whilst in America the top 30 rose from $75k to $85k. The current fees in America represent 33% of the sires’ average yearling sale price, but in Europe, that number is as high as 42%.
In America fees for the top 30 commercial sires rose from $75k to $85k
Of course, the trends among sires with yearlings are not the whole story and don’t take into account the young stallions in the pipeline or the new intake this year. So far, there are seven new sires due to stand for more than $20,000 in Australia – Trapeze Artist, The Autumn Sun, Kementari, Saxon Warrior (Jpn), Written By, Brave Smash (Jpn) and Harry Angel.
This will heap even more downward pressure on stallion books and ultimately on bloodstock prices. It will be interesting to see if the $30k-plus group of stallions can maintain their record 144-mare average book size, set last year.
The yearling market may be thriving, but it will need to continue growing in order make financial sense of current service fee levels in Australia. And if there is an oversupply of expensive nominations in the market this spring, you can bet that the downward pressure will first manifest itself with breeders seeking to buy discounted nominations.