Cover: Kermadec Standing at Darley Australia | Image Courtesy Darley Australia
Some stallions waste no time in making a commercial impact, drawing huge demand for their first weanlings and then carrying on in the same vein with their yearlings. For other stallions, however, that first crop of yearlings marks a major step up from the prices that had been paid for their weanlings.
A notable example of the latter is Kermadec (NZ) (Teofilo {Ire}), the G1 Doncaster Mile and George Main S. winner who retired to Darley Kelvinside in 2016 at a fee of $22,000.
He made only a moderate impact last year with his first crop of weanlings, selling 16 of them for a total of $564,500. His average price was $35,281, and the median was $36,250. The highest price paid for a Kermadec weanling was $75,000 for a filly during the Magic Millions National Weanling Sale on the Gold Coast. Accordingly, in his third season at stud off the back of these results, Kermadec covered a significantly smaller book than in his first two seasons.
While fellow first season sires Vancouver (Medaglia d’Oro {USA}), Pride of Dubai (Street Cry {Ire}) and Exosphere (Lonhro) all ranked near the top in the sires’ tables at that Gold Coast sale, Kermadec finished well down the list. His average price of $41,313 was a long way adrift of Vancouver’s $140,000, Pride of Dubai’s $112,000 and Exosphere’s $64,265.
Fast-forward to 2019, which has been a very different story. A total of 55 Kermadec yearlings have been sold in Australia and New Zealand this year for $5.25 million, averaging $95,472 - over double his weanling average - with a median of $80,000. His yearlings have sold all the way up to $520,000 – a colt bought by Upper Bloodstock at the Inglis Melbourne Premier Sale.
In that Melbourne sale, Kermadec’s average price of $152,667 was the highest among first season sires with four or more yearlings sold – beating his Gold Coast conquerors the previous season, Vancouver (whose average was $134,412), Pride of Dubai ($118,571) and Exosphere ($62,500).
Vancouver finished ahead of Kermadec again at the Magic Millions yearling sale earlier in the year, averaging $185,714, but Kermadec was close behind him with an average of $147,000.
From his first weanlings to his first yearlings, Kermadec’s overall average price has increased by a remarkable 171%.
Kermadec (NZ) x Promenades (colt) - purchased for $520,000 from the Melbourne Premier Yearling Sale
Price increase as percentage
Super One (I Am Invincible) fetched $21,791 for his first crop of 24 weanlings, which increased by 159% to $56,524 for his first yearlings, where 61 have been sold. There was also a 136% increase for Rich Enuff (Written Tycoon), whose average was $35,538 from 13 sold. This year he has sold 41 yearlings for an average of $83,975.
Press Statement (Hinchinbrook) has been another improver. His first weanlings fetched an average of $33,906 from 16, then 53 of his yearlings sold for $67,500 – a 99% increase.
The price increases for other stallions who entered stud in 2016 include 56.87% for Vancouver ($115,863 to $181,760), 45.29% for Exosphere ($61,595 to $89,490), 43.71% for Pride of Dubai ($79,361 to $114,050), and 33.6% for Headwater (Exceed and Excel) ($42,782 from 23 weanlings, then $57,158 from 63 yearlings).
The lower percentage increases for the likes of Vancouver and Pride of Dubai can be explained by the significantly higher starting point of their weanling averages.
Vancouver and Pride of Dubai also had strength in numbers behind them. They both stand at Coolmore Stud, renowned as a strong weanling vendor, and both young stallions lived up to that reputation with their initial offerings.
Vancouver had 22 weanlings sold in his first crop, including five from Coolmore’s own draft who sold for an average of $230,000. That impressive start was followed up the next year by 75 yearlings. Pride of Dubai’s numbers were 18 and 70 respectively.
In contrast, Kermadec and Exosphere stand at Darley, who do not take weanlings to the market. As a result, they did not enjoy the same quality control over the 16 Kermadec and 21 Exosphere weanlings sold during 2018.
First crop fortunes
In the past few seasons, a number of other young stallions have turned their fortunes around impressively between their first crops of weanlings and yearlings.
Olympic Glory (Ire) (Choisir) had a 197% increase last year, fetching an average of $29,833 with his first weanlings and $88,683 for his yearlings.
Another notable stallion who enjoyed a big increase was Sebring (More Than Ready {USA}), whose weanling average of $47,800 in 2011 went up by 143% the following season to a yearling average of $116,362.
Hinchinbrook (Fastnet Rock) averaged $21,812 for his first weanlings in 2013, then $66,465 for his yearlings – an increase of 205%. Sepoy (Elusive Quality {USA}) had a 175% increase from $90,714 for his first weanlings to $249,026 for his yearlings.
Gallery: Some of the top price yearlings for 2019
A couple of stallions in recent seasons have gone in the opposite direction, but they had very small initial offerings of weanlings and much bigger samples of yearlings.
Brazen Beau (I Am Invincible) averaged $192,142 from a first crop of seven weanlings, then $153,396 from 53 yearlings the following season. Animal Kingdom (USA) (Leroidesanimaux {BRZ}) averaged $84,666 from three weanlings in his first year, then $84,014 from 34 yearlings.
Third season impact
First crop weanling prices often have a strong influence on stallion nomination popularity for that tricky third season. Yearling prices tend to have a similar impact on a stallion's fourth season mare numbers.
An increase in price from first weanlings to first yearlings is to be expected, given the premium position that yearling sales have always held in the thoroughbred industry. But the different rate of increases for stallions’ progeny, before they have been tested on racetracks, likely comes down to a combination of physical development of the individuals and access the market has to the top bracket of bloodstock.
Stallion farms who sell have a strong weanling draft can play a powerful hand in terms of selling quality bloodstock a year earlier than those who concentrate exclusively on yearlings. This early market confidence helps give breeders an additional boost to breed to the stallion in the high risk third season.
But a direct weanling-price to yearling-price correlation is not always simple, and there is an opportunity for a top commercial yearling sire to emerge from the behind the weanling-sale pack.
Among the stallions who took up stud duties in 2017, Newgate Farm’s Golden Slipper winner Capitalist (Written Tycoon) made a particularly strong start in the weanling market. He has sold 21 weanlings this year for an average of $121,333. Another of Newgate’s youngsters, Extreme Choice (Not a Single Doubt), has also performed strongly with an average of $79,250 from 16 weanlings.
Divine Prophet (Choisir) has had 18 weanlings sell for an average of $75,444, while Shalaa (Ire) (Invincible Spirit {Ire}) returned an average of $74,461 from 13 weanlings.
Astern (Medaglia d’Oro {USA}) has made a quieter start with an average of $42,666 from 15 weanlings. But, like Kermadec and Exosphere before him, he may be one to follow an upward trajectory as his first yearlings begin to go under the hammer next year.
Gallery: Some of the top price first crop weanlings for 2019