A detailed study into the diversity of the Australian thoroughbred gene pool would be a minimum requirement before any consideration was given to caps of the numbers of mares a stallion can serve in a season, according to leading industry figures.
The announcement of The Jockey Club in the United States that it was considering capping a stallion's book of mares at 140 as a method of increasing the diversity of the thoroughbred gene pool has led to discussion into the desirability of such a solution in Australia.
Opinions on the issue have varied, but the one constant that has come through is the need for a proper study to determine if a diminishing gene pool is indeed an issue in Australia, and whether such a solution would have the desired effect.
Antony Thompson, Proprietor of Widden Stud, said he'd like to see more research and information before Australia thought about going down a similar path as what has been mooted in the US.
Antony Thompson (right) believes it should be a decision based on science and that further research needs to be undertaken
"It seems like it's a decision that is based on the science of the narrowing of the gene pool and I'd be interested to understand more about that and how it affects us here," he told TDN AusNZ.
"While there might be some concern about the Danehill-line being dominant, the busiest horses last year, seven of the top eight stallions in terms of books, were non-Danehill line sires and certainly this year, the outcross stallions are very popular again."
"I'm not sure by limiting the numbers, if it might be counterproductive in terms of what they are trying to achieve."
"I'm not sure by limiting the numbers, if it might be counterproductive in terms of what they are trying to achieve." - Antony Thompson
Thompson pointed to a recent University of Sydney study into the desirability and impacts of inbreeding in thoroughbreds as an example of the level of research required.
"You’d like to see if the narrowing of the gene pool is an issue, do some modelling around that and weigh up the consequences of introducing a cap," he said.
Thoroughbred Breeders Australia Chief Executive Tom Reilly said access to any research conducted in the US would also be of assistance, with the recognition that the two jurisdictions have significant differences.
Tom Reilly (right) "cannot remember a breeder raising the issue of genetic diversity with [him]"
“I’d be really interested to see the research The Jockey Club have done into this area, work showing how much more inbred thoroughbreds in America are now as opposed to 20, 30 years ago. Also the science showing the negative impact this is having in terms of horse health and performance. Anybody who is a breeder would be interested in that," he said.
“As for Australia, I think our industry is different in many ways from America. Firstly, and most importantly in terms of the gene pool, our breeders are fortunate in that they have access to the most diverse bloodlines of any stallion market in the world."
"Our breeders are fortunate in that they have access to the most diverse bloodlines of any stallion market in the world." - Tom Reilly
TBA doesn’t have a position on whether a cap should be introduced, but Reilly said it hadn't been an issue he had come across when talking to members of his organisation.
“I cannot remember a breeder raising the issue of genetic diversity with me, though people have raised the challenges that bigger stallion books present in terms of getting a mare served and number of progeny of a sire going to the sale ring. But breeders are familiar with these concerns and, obviously, are still willing to use those sires that will be most popular," he said.
The problem of big books
As a major breeder, Thompson believes massive stallion books present an issue, but it is as much operationally and commercially, as it is to do with genetics.
"I do agree there is an issue with covering too many mares. There are problems associated with that. Getting mares covered at the point of ovulation is a lot of pressure on both the mare farms and the stallion farms," he said.
"There is also a marketplace issue around over-production and the value of those lesser type horses from those stallions with bigger books."
"I'm not personally a fan of huge books of mares, but there is a lot of pressure from an economic point of view."
Thompson said a cap as low as 140 is unlikely to be practical in Australia, suggesting somewhere around 180 would more be workable if it was shown to be beneficial.
But he is wary about the unintended consequence of any change, including the possibility it may reduce the number of breeders in the industry.
"It would have a very large impact on the economics of the industry, bringing in such a cap and some of the consequences may be unintentional. All those things need a lot of discussion and careful consideration," he said.
That’s something that also concerns Reilly and the TBA.
“The consequences, intended or otherwise, of tinkering with a free market are very interesting. Will breeders who can’t get their horse in to the most popular stallions be happy to use other sires? Will there be fewer breeders that can gain access to those leading stallions, and what could this mean about control of the most sought after bloodlines?" he said.
“Then there’s the impact on the yearling market and the value of horses in training, which feeds into the overall ecosystem of the thoroughbred industry. I’m sure if The Jockey Club go ahead with the cap then there will be many people around the world watching closely.”
How would a change in the US impact Australia?
While all the speculation is hypothetical, what may become very real for Australia is the possibility that The Jockey Club will introduce regulation in the American market which could have a knock-on effect elsewhere in the world.
While the long term impacts are hard to quantify initially, Thompson believes the ripple effect would certainly be felt globally.
"If just the US introduce it, some of their better and more commercial stallions may actually leave to stand in other jurisdictions where there is no cap," he said.
"Some of their better and more commercial stallions may actually leave to stand in other jurisdictions where there is no cap." - Antony Thompson
"But each jurisdiction to their own and it's up to them how it fits in with their laws, and restrictions around trade and within the powers of their racing authorities and stud books."
Hamish Esplin (left) believes the cap would have an effect on the movement of investment
Tartan Fields' Hamish Esplin also expects that if there is going to be an impact, it may be where global players look to invest.
"I think it would have an effect on the movement of investment. Studmasters could look to make more money elsewhere, because they would be capped in what they make locally in one season by their stallions," he said.
"We are seeing that already, with international players coming here to Australia to try all different aspects of the market. Investment would move if you couldn’t make as much money locally."
"Investment would move if you couldn’t make as much money locally." - Hamish Esplin
Where that investment may flow to, whether it be in shuttle stallions, yearlings, or other aspects of the industry is difficult to assess.
Olly Tait
Twin Hills' Stud Owner Olly Tait agrees that any change in the global thoroughbred commercial ecosystem is hard to quantify.
"It is an international industry and the actions of one country do impact another, but I couldn’t give you an answer as to what those consequences would be," he said.
"The effect of any of this is that there are unforeseen consequences, which we wouldn't know. Each jurisdiction has the power to implement measures but I couldn't tell you what those consequences would be."
Who would the cap effect in Australia?
As a measure of how any cap would impact in Australia, TDN AusNZ examined the number of services for stallions in the 2018 season using the most recent data available through the Australian Stud Book.
The analysis revealed that there were 35 stallions who serviced 140 or more mares in 2018. Leading the way was Coolmore's Rubick, who served a book of 263 mares, 17 more than Merchant Navy and Newgate's Deep Field.
Of those 35 stallions, ten were in their first year, while 17 had Danehill (USA) in the past three generations of their pedigree, and 18 were from an 'outcross' pedigree.
Danehill is ever-present in Australian bloodlines
The proposed American cap of 140 is based on a slightly longer commercial breeding season (February 14 until July), with Arrowfield Chairman John Messara suggesting that a comparative cap in Australia would be around 120 (September 1 until December).
On the 2018 figures, dropping the cap to 120 would impact 51 stallions, or around 8 per cent of the population.
Shuttle stallions were noted, by several people we spoke to, in terms of adding diversity to the Australian gene pool but Racing Australia statistics indicate the number of mares covered by shuttle stallions in Australia has fallen in recent years.
The latest data available is from the 2016/17 season, which shows the percentage of mares covered by shuttle stallions has dropped to 15.03%. This the lowest since the Equine Influenza year of 2007.
The average books of shuttle stallions fell from a peak of 118 in 2014/15, to 86 two years later.
These figures tend to ebb and flow, but the statistics indicate the influence of shuttle stallions in Australia is no more than what it was ten years ago, and significantly less than it was in the years before EI.