Opinions on the Cap

4 min read

Courtesy of TDN America

The Jockey Club in America has asked for public comment on their proposal to cap at 140 the number of mares a stallion can breed annually. In this ongoing TDN America series, the perspectives of breeders, stallion farms and others on the proposal have been published.

Tanya Gunther, Glennwood Farm

"I think we have bigger problems to worry about than capping mares to a stallion.

"I think our current PR issues, the public perception of horse racing and the survival of horse racing as an industry is more important. I’d like the industry to be focusing on that and trying to solve these issues rather, than shifting focus to something secondary such as capping the number of mares in a stallion’s book."

"In terms of capping the number of mares, I’d rather supply and demand determine stud fees and the number of mares in a book, rather than us instituting an artificial ceiling."

"I believe the value of a colt as a stallion prospect will be negatively impacted by a ceiling. It’s important to the market for that potential value to be there and the number of mares to a stallion is part of that value calculation."

John and Tanya Gunther | Photo credit: Glennwood Farm

Antony Beck, Gainesway Farm

"We should welcome this challenge as an opportunity. Farms should recognise that greater equilibrium will ultimately bring commercial benefits to their stallion rosters–quite apart from the manifest benefits to the breed, in terms of genetic diversity."

"Because the bottom line is always that whatever serves the interests of the Thoroughbred, in the long term, will ultimately serve our interests as well."

Antony Beck | Photo credit: Jonathon Palmer

Greg Goodman, Mt Brilliant Farm

"It’s kind of a Catch 22, but I would say that it’s up to the stallion owners and the breeders. You have the choice of breeding to a stallion who breeds 200 horses, or you don’t have to breed to them."

"I don’t think The Jockey Club should limit people who own something as to what they can do with it."

Barbara Banke, Stonestreet Farm

"The health and welfare of the Thoroughbred breed should always be our number one concern. As a member of the Board of Stewards, I believe the proposal is a way to address a concern held broadly in the industry and look forward to the feedback from our invitation for comments."

Barbara Banke | Photo credit: Keeneland

Gerry Dilger, Dromoland Farm

"Some horses have very large books and it’s hard to compete, but on the other side, if the farms put up their money for these stallions, and they have to get out in two, two-and-a-half years, you have to consider those guys as well."

"They’re paying millions and millions for stallions and some of them, as we know, don’t make it. They have to have a shot to get their money back to reinvest. I don’t think 140 is the number. I’d say 150, 160, maybe?"

"Give the breeders or the farms a chance to get their investment back if they can or get most of it back and then they can go out there and look for the next prospect."

Arthur Hancock, Stone Farm

"I think the stallion people would be a lot better off instead of breeding 200 mares to breed 100 to 130 and charge double or one-and-a-half times the current stud fee, and you can make your money back that way."

"I don’t know how stallions can breed that many mares. In the old days, my dad wouldn’t double a stallion two days in a row. Now, they breed four mares a day, every day."

"If you’ve got 100,000 Cadillacs to sell, each one is going to be worth less money than if you only had 1,000. It’s the old law of supply and demand. So we’re saturating the supply and it’s costing us all, I think, in the long run."

"We’d all be better off if we did this. The industry would, the breeders would, the people who buy would. I think it’s a win-win situation across the board."

Arthur Hancock | Photo credit: Stone Farm