There is no question that colonial stallions are proving more popular with breeders these days. The 2018 mare returns record indicate that only a single shuttle sire made the top 20 by mares covered. And the sire in question – Toronado (Ire) – was 19th of 20. It’s a marginally brighter picture when we rank stallions by elite mares.
Although no shuttler makes the top 10, the Coolmore trio of American Pharoah (USA), Churchill (Ire) and Caravaggio (USA), plus Arrowfield’s Shalaa (Ire), are among the top 20. This state of play may suit breeders’ and yearling buyers’ pockets in the short term, but is it best for the future health of Australian racing?
Conventional wisdom dictates that the racing ability of both parents is of paramount importance when producing a racehorse. But breeders – as they follow the money – can understandably overlook this key fact from time to time.
The racing class gap
Of the 61 stallions that served 100 or more mares in 2018, only eight were shuttlers, but their average Timeform rating is 126 compared to the 121 of 53 colonial stallions that served 100-plus mares. This gap in racing class has always been there.
After all, if Australia brings in shuttle sires, they ought to be the best of the best. Since 1990, 74 per cent of shuttlers that went on to have 200-plus runners have been Group 1 winners, compared to the 49 per cent among locals.
Santa Ana Lane is by shuttle sire Lope De Vega (Ire)
Yet more evidence of Australia’s shift away from shuttlers can be found by comparing book sizes. Among the 100-plus mare book stallions the average book size in 2018 was 132 for the visitors, compared to the 153 for local stallions.
"While the average number of elite mares was also lower for the visitors. And all this despite stallion masters offering the shuttle sires at a comparative discount." - John Boyce
While the average number of elite mares was also lower for the visitors. And all this despite stallion masters offering the shuttle sires at a comparative discount: their average service fee was $28,000, compared to $36,000 for the locals.
Danehill (USA) underpinned the shuttling practice
Historically, shuttle sires have led the way. The outstanding Danehill (USA) may have underpinned the practice, but there have been many success stories since. The accompanying tables of top-rated racehorses illustrates the point perfectly.
There are many more horses by shuttle sires rated 128-plus, than those by local sires, which is a commendable achievement, given that shuttle sires have accounted for only 14 per cent of all sires that retired to stud since 1990. Even if we restrict our study to popular stallions with 200 or more runners, shuttle sires still only make up 35 per cent of the stallion population.
TOP-RATED HORSES SINCE 1995 BY SHUTTLE SIRES
| Winx | Street Cry (Ire) | 134 |
| So You Think (NZ) | High Chaparral (Ire) | 133 |
| Hay List | Statue Of Liberty (USA) | 132 |
| Santa Ana Lane | Lope De Vega (Ire) | 130 |
| Dundeel (NZ) | High Chaparral (Ire) | 129 |
| Happy Clapper | Teofilo (Ire) | 129 |
| Humidor | Teofilo (Ire) | 129 |
| Makybe Diva (GB) | Desert King (Ire) | 129 |
| Sepoy | Elusive Quality (USA) | 129 |
| Sunline (NZ) | Desert Sun (USA) | 129 |
| Testa Rossa | Perugino (USA) | 129 |
| Grand Armee | Hennessy (Ire) | 128 |
| More Joyous | More Than Ready (USA) | 128 |
| Takeover Target | Celtic Swing (GB) | 128 |
| Terravista | Captain Rio (USA) | 128 |
| Whobegotyou | Street Cry (Ire) | 128 |
TOP-RATED HORSES SINCE 1995 BY ANZ SIRES
| Black Caviar | Bel Esprit | 136 |
| Might And Power | Zabeel | 133 |
| Lankan Rupee | Redoute's Choice | 132 |
| Weekend Hussler | Hussonet | 130 |
| Northerly | Serheed | 129 |
| All To Hard | Casino Prince | 128 |
| Atlantic Jewel | Fastnet Rock | 128 |
| Filante | Star Way | 128 |
| Foxwedge | Fastnet Rock | 128 |
| Lonhro | Octagonal | 128 |
| Pierro | Lonhro | 128 |
For the record, the 314 shuttlers retired since 1990 have sired 1,654 stakes winners at a rate of 3.47 per cent. The colonial sires meanwhile managed 2,256 or 1.47 per cent of their runners. Applying our 200-runner benchmark shows that 74 shuttle sires produced 1,126 stakes winners at a rate of 4.18 per cent, which is closer to the 3.34 per cent of the locals, albeit still significantly adrift.
Before we conclude that the shuttle sires since Danehill have generally fared better than the locals, we need to take a look at opportunity. And yes it’s true that, on average, the visiting stallions have covered better mares. Overall, the mares that produced the 48,000 runners by shuttle sires since 1990 were 37 per cent better than the 153,000 mares visiting local stallions.
Winx, by the shuttle stallion Street Cry (Ire)
The gap is only 17 per cent in favour of the shuttlers when we focus on popular commercial stallions. That said, neither figure fully accounts for the shortfall in the percentage of stakes winners produced by each group. That gap stands at 58 per cent for all stallions and 20 percent for those that ended up with 200-plus runners.
"Shuttle stallions are not just a luxury, but essential to the continued international development of the Australian thoroughbred." - John Boyce
All of this suggests that shuttle stallions are not just a luxury, but essential to the continued international development of the Australian thoroughbred. Australian racing and breeding is thriving due to record investment. If this continues – and there is no reason to think that it won’t – there is every likelihood that racehorse production will increase.
Therefore, it makes absolute sense to bring in the best sires from America and Europe to augment the outstanding local stallions. The facts suggest they are worth their weight in gold.