Generation Next puts credentials on the line

10 min read
With the most exciting 3-year-old crop in a generation returning to racetracks in Sydney and Melbourne, we ask some key industry figures whether the quality measures up to the depth and who will come out on top?

They line-up like Hollywood stars on a movie poster, a 3-year-old crop of such depth and diversity that they have become the star attraction of the upcoming autumn features in Melbourne and Sydney.

There are 16 individual Australian Group 1 winners from the current crop of 3-year-olds which when you consider that they have only been racing in the top-flight for less than 12 months, is quite remarkable.

What is also intriguing is that none of those 16 horses have been multiple Group 1 winners.

Alabama Express CF Orr S.
BivoaucGolden Rose S.
CastelvecchioChampagne S.
ExceedanceCoolmore Stud S.
Flit Thousand Guineas
Funstar Flight S.
Kay Cee Kingston Town Classic
Kiamichi Golden Slipper S.
Loving GabyManikato S.
Lyre Blue Diamond S.
Miami Bound VRC Oaks
Microphone Inglis Sires'
Prince Fawaz JJ Atkins S.
Shadow Hero Spring Champion S.
Super Seth Caulfield Guineas
Warning VRC Derby

Table: 3-year-old Group 1 winners

That list does not include horses such as New Zealand's best 3-year-old prospect, Catalyst (NZ) (Darci Brahma {NZ}), a Group 1 winner in his homeland, boom galloper Alligator Blood (All Too Hard), whose only defeat in nine starts was when second in the G1 Caulfield Guineas, and leading prospects Standout (Exceed And Excel), Libertini (I Am Invincible) and Dalasan (Dalakhani {Ire}).

It also doesn't include recently retired The Everest winner Yes Yes Yes (Rubick), perhaps the best case study for how the top 3-year-olds of this crop measure up to the older horses.

Recently retired The Everest winner Yes Yes Yes is perhaps the best case study as to how the top 3-year-olds measure up in older company

There are a trio of 3-year-olds who have won Group 1 races at open age so far this season, Loving Gaby (I Am Invincible) in the Manikato S., Kay Cee (Playing God) in the Kingston Town Classic, and most recently Alabama Express (Redoute's Choice) in the CF Orr S.

For Arrowfield chairman John Messara those results against the older horses are the best guide to where the quality of the current crop sits.

"The answer at face value is that we seem to have a very good crop," he told TDN AusNZ. "This year they are taking on the older horses and seem to be able to cope with that which is always a good sign.

"The answer at face value is that we seem to have a very good crop." - John Messara

"I’d want to see a bit more, and maybe some continuity of form. I'd love to see Super Seth come out and win the G1 Futurity and Alabama Express frank that form again."

Arrowfield bred and sold G1 Caulfield Guineas winner Super Seth (Dundeel {NZ}), while it holds part ownership in the emerging Alabama Express and recently took a controlling interest in G1 Champagne S. winner Castelvecchio (NZ) (Dundeel {NZ}).

It is also well-placed to assess the comparative merits of the past two crops of 3-year-olds as it bred, part owned and now stands the Champion 3-year-old Colt of last season The Autumn Sun (Redoute's Choice).

In that case, The Autumn Sun stood out as the clear benchmark colt, with Sunlight (Zoustar) the clear top filly. Both had established their dominance in the spring and franked that in the autumn. This year is very different, which is why Messara is prepared to reserve his judgement.

Gallery: The Autumn Sun and Sunlight were the clear standouts of last year's 3-year-old crop

"Before being categorical about anything to do with a crop, there are so many of them in a clutch that I kind of worry," he said. "It's like the finish of a race where you have four or five within a length and a half. You start to think how good are they?

"They might all be good, or we might have a weaker older brigade of horses as well. It could be a mixture of both. It’s a waiting game. We need to let the Championships go by until we get categorical about anything."

Track provides the true test

It’s true that the track will be the ultimate test, as it should be, and this weekend's racing at Randwick and Flemington are set to provide a substantial early pointer.

Loving Gaby again tackles the open-age horses at weight-for-age in the G1 Black Caviar Lightning, while the G3 CS Hayes S. for the colts at Flemington and the G2 Light Fingers S. for the fillies at Randwick shape as crucial early autumn contests.

The CS Hayes sees Catalyst tackle Alligator Blood, arguably the two horses with the biggest x-factor of the 3-year-old colts, in a race that also contains Dalasan as well as untapped Godolphin colt Chenier (Medaglia d'Oro {USA}) and the Lindsay Park-trained Yourdeel (NZ) (Dundeel {NZ}) a dual Group 1 winner in New Zealand as a 2-year-old.

The talented Alligator Blood lines up in the CS Hayes S. on Saturday

Where Catalyst fits into the picture of the Australian 3-year-olds is hard to assess, but experienced handicapper and Racing Victoria's EGM - Racing, Greg Carpenter, expects him to measure up well.

"Catalyst looked outstanding in New Zealand, his Guineas win last year and his first-up win in the Mr Tiz was sensational," Carpenter said.

"Catalyst looked outstanding in New Zealand." - Greg Carpenter

"Every which way you look, there seems to be a very good group of 3-year-olds, but there is a lot to play out over the autumn here in Melbourne and into The Championships in Sydney."

The Light Fingers S. features three Group 1 winning Godolphin fillies, Lyre (Lonhro), Kiamichi (Sidestep) and Flit (Medaglia d'Oro {USA}) up against the highly-rated Anthony Cummings-trained Libertini (I Am Invincible), who loomed as the top seed of the fillies early last campaign.

Blue Army holds many cards

Unsurprisingly of all those top quality 3-year-olds, it is Godolphin which holds the deepest hand in terms of numbers, with its top band of fillies joined by a pair of elite colts in reigning Champion 2-year-old Microphone (Exceed And Excel) and G1 Golden Rose S. winner Bivouac (Exceed And Excel) as well as a host of contenders to the throne.

"You never anticipate, you always hope," Godolphin Australia Managing Director Vin Cox said. "We have got a very strong hand obviously.

"We are very excited with the Bivouacs and Microphones of the world, from an ongoing stallion point of view, but even horses like Pandemic and our other Group 1 winners, Flit, Lyre and Kiamichi, it’s an extraordinary crop," he said.

"You never anticipate, you always hope. " - Vin Cox

“To put this season’s 3-year-old crop into context, if it was a football team with one standout player you wouldn’t have a champion team,” Cox said. “However, a group of superior athletes will deliver a premiership. This is likely a group of superior athletes.”

In terms of runs on the board, Cox said Microphone, who won the G1 Inglis Sires' last year and claimed the G2 Autumn S. at Caulfield last weekend, probably deserved to be its top seed, but that there was so much water to flow under the bridge in the coming months.

While Godolphin, and in particular head trainer James Cummings, has both the quantity and quality, it is interesting to note that of the Top 20 prospects we looked at, they were prepared by 15 different trainers and were by 16 different stallions.

Godolphin head trainer, James Cummings

"The depth of our racing is outstanding," Cox said. "It’s a great thing to see that not only are a number of breeders breeding top class horses, but a number of owners have got top class horses and so too, have a number of stables.

"It’s all about having a lot of participants in the business, and while there is a cross section of owners, trainers, jockeys and breeders, it keeps it all very vibrant and viable."

So who will emerge on top?

As mentioned, Cox believes the colts Microphone and Bivouac can add further to the runs they have on the board, while emerging stars such as Pandemic (Sepoy) and Chenier can take giant leaps forward.

Messara has understandably a huge wrap for Alabama Express' win in the CF Orr S. and thinks there is more to come from the Michael Moroney-trained colt.

"He won that the hard way on Saturday. It was a strong finishing burst and he was wide all the way. But it was a very good effort. That didn’t look like any sort of fluke," he said.

The Arrowfield chairman is also eagerly anticipating the return of the Richard Litt-trained Castelvecchio.

"We are going to see Castelvecchio emerge in the next couple of weeks and I think he might take a step forward. He doesn't have to go far forward. He is at the top of the crew at the moment, but we are pretty hopeful with how he is going," he said.

John Messara is eagerly anticipating the return of Castelvecchio

Carpenter doesn't a have a vested interest in any camp, but he too is excited to see Castelvecchio back on the track in the autumn after he was beaten only by the highly-rated Japanese mare Lys Gracieux (Heart's Cry {Jpn}) in the G1 Cox Plate.

He is also anticipating a big autumn from G1 Victoria Derby winner Warning (Declaration Of War {USA}).

"His win in the Derby was a stunning victory. He's headed directly to Sydney and we should be very alive to his prospects in the staying contests," he said.

The Team Hawkes-trained Exceedance (Exceed And Excel), the winner of the G1 Coolmore Stud S. in the spring, is also nearing a racetrack return, with a goal of targeting the G1 TJ Smith S.

A Coolmore in the Autumn?

There are 10 Group 1 races remaining in Australia this season which are specifically for the 3-year-olds, while there are a host of races at open age handicap or weight-for-age level which are also likely to fall onto the radar of many of these rising stars.

Interestingly, of those 10 3-year-old specific races, only three are staged at below 2000 metres, and none below the 1400 metres of the G1 Surround S.

What that means is that unlike the spring, where the G1 Coolmore Stud S. represents a sprint championships for the 3-year-olds, there is no autumn sprint 3-year-old 'grand final'.

Messara believes Racing NSW wants to address this with its desire to have the G2 Arrowfield 3YO Sprint, held on the second day of The Championships in April, upgraded.

John Messara believes the G2 Arrowfield 3YO Sprint to be a worthy sprint 'grand final'

"We've got the Arrowfield during The Championships which is now worth $1 million. You would hope that would develop into it," he said.

"The Arrowfield is the race that I know Racing NSW are trying to turn into the equivalent of the Coolmore in the autumn, as the autumn championship for 3-year-old sprinters."

Cox believes the quality of 3-year-olds later in the season is best-measured against the open age horses, where he said there are plenty of races to test their mettle.

"There's a lot of options. Does it need to be a 3-year-old race? There's the Arrowfield during The Championships. It’s a nice race, but I think to get real credibility for your 3-year-old colt, you need to be performing at weight-for-age level in the latter part of your 3-year-old year.

"Whether it be Oakleigh Plates, Newmarkets, Futuritys, TJ Smiths, George Ryders, there are lots of options."

Vin Cox believes 3-year-olds should perform at weight-for-age level

Carpenter also feels the true test of those 3-year-olds is against the big boys and girls in the elite open-aged races towards the end of the season.

"I relish seeing the 3-year-olds run against the older horses. The 3-year-olds have exposed the older horses already this season and on our own ratings, we measure our 3-year-olds when they do take on that challenge," he said,

"I think protecting them and giving them more opportunities within their own age group is fine for the spring, but whether it is Europe or here, the pattern tells us that the expectation is they take on the older horses later in the year."