Cover image courtesy of Keeneland
At A Glance
Andrew Cary made the session’s most expensive purchase, going to US$500,000 (AU$687,280) to acquire the mare Contributing (USA) (Medaglia D’Oro {USA}).
393 horses sold in Book 2 for US$52,753,000 (AU$72.51 million) down from the 448 which grossed US$66,257,000 (AU$91.07 million) last year.
The Book 2 average was US$134,232 (AU$184,508), down 9.2 per cent from 2019.
The Book 2 median was US$100,000 (AU$137,460), down 16.7 per cent.
Weanlings held six of seven top prices of the session.
For the third straight day of the Sale, Justify was responsible for the top-priced foal.
Energy flows in sale ring
Coolmore's Justify was joined by other first-crop sires Mastery (USA), City Of Light (USA) and Good Magic (USA) with weanlings to sell for US$360,000 (AU$494,840) and over.
“The energy was really good and there was a lot of competition for the foals,” said Keeneland’s President Elect Shannon Arvin. “We saw some new buyers and some of the same buyers from the first few days of the Sale who continued to participate. I think overall, it was a really good session today.
“I think the market is pretty strong,” Baccari said. “For the mares, it’s been really strong. I think the foals are strong, but you have to sift through a lot of them to find the ones you want. When you find the ones you want, you have to pay for them.”
Consignor Stuart Morris said, “The market for weanlings is a little spotty, with the ones at the top being very well-received. Overall, it has been pretty fair. For where we are in the world right now, I am very happy with the results.”
"Overall, it has been pretty fair. For where we are in the world right now, I am very happy with the results.” - Stuart Morris
The November sale’s Book 3 session opens Thursday, with bidding beginning at 10am GMT (2am AEDT).
“I would hope that what has happened in the first two books will continue on,” Keeneland’s Director of Sales Operations Geoffrey Russell said of expectations for Book 3. “It’s going to be a different level of the market, but if we can capture the vibrancy of today and bring it on to tomorrow and the next day, that will be great.”
Arvin added, “We would love to see the continued stability in the market that we saw in the September sale.”
Pricey Justify headed to the yearling sales
A well-related colt (Hip 829) from the first crop of undefeated Triple Crown winner Justify is destined to return to the auction ring at next term’s yearling sales after being purchased by Baccari for US$435,000 (AU$597,930).
“For me, I’ve been looking for a really good Justify and he has a lot of female pedigree, plenty of size and plenty of strength,” said Baccari. “Anybody that looks at him when he goes to be resold will see he looks like he has plenty of bone and looks like he can take a lot of training.”
Hip 829 - Justify (USA) x Stayclassysandiego (USA) (colt) | Image courtesy of Keeneland
Breeder Nancy Shuford purchased the grey colt’s dam Stayclassysandiego (USA) (Rockport Harbor {USA}) – a half-sister to Grade 1 winner Sean Avery (USA) (Cherokee Run {USA}) – for US$120,000 (AU$164,950) at the 2012 Keeneland November Sale carrying her first foal by Scat Daddy (USA).
The resulting filly was purchased by Watson, Weitman and Pegram, aka the Three Amigos, for US$160,000 (AU$219,930) at Keeneland September and named Pretty N Cool (USA). Campaigned by Justify’s trainer Bob Baffert, she won three Graded stakes races and was Grade 2-placed.
Members of unbeaten Horse of the Year and 2018 Triple Crown hero Justify’s first crop have been very popular at Keeneland November with his foals topping or co-topping the weanling portion of each of the three sessions. A total of five have sold so far for a gross of US$2.135 million (AU$2.93 million) and average of US$427,000 (AU$586,933).
“I think the Justifys are very good,” Baccari said. “I think the public is going to support him now and his yearlings. He was a very good racehorse and I’m a big fan. I think I have four homebreds by him.”
Justify (USA) | Standing at Coolmore
The horseman continued, “(Hip 829) reminds me of his sire. He has a lot of raw strength like he did. The mare is a good producer and that is what I’m looking for. That is what determines the value to me. He had a good physical, but he has the pedigree to go with it.”
The second highest-priced Justify weanling of the day came late in the Sale when Hip 987 brought US$375,000 (AU$515,460) from internet bidder Michael Fowler, who bred the colt in partnership with Jumping Jack Racing. Like Baccari, this colt’s consignor Stuart Morris said he also liked what he was seeing in Justify’s offspring.
“I am very impressed with the Justifys,” Morris said. “All the ones I have been around have had very good minds. They are very forward, very athletic, very progressive. They are simple and uncomplicated, acting like professional racehorses."
Contributing takes unconventional route to the top
Contributing had an unconventional journey from the racetrack to the sales ring, but taking the road less travelled proved successful when she topped the third session of Keeneland November at US$500,000 (AU$687,280). Offered in foal to Speightstown (USA), Hip 958 was purchased by Andrew Cary’s Cary Bloodstock for Coteau Grove Farm.
“I bought a Medaglia mare in foal to Speightstown earlier (Hip 645), so I thought why not make it a double,” said Cary, who has been quite active buying mares on behalf of Coteau Grove all week. “She has an awesome pedigree. Speightstown is showing everyone again this year how awesome he is with Nashville. Medaglia D’Oro should be a leading broodmare sire for years. She has a huge pedigree. Her sister produced an Oaks winner. She is gorgeous, she can run and to me she’s the whole package.”
Hip 958 - Contributing (USA)
Purchased by Heider Family Stable for US$220,000 (AU$302,400) at the 2015 Keeneland September Sale, Contributing raced for trainer Tom Proctor from 2016 to 2018, winning three times and placing in multiple stakes. She was sent to the breeding shed, but did not catch and was sent back to the racetrack, this time under the care of Brad Cox.
That twist of fate proved lucky as Contributing scored that black-type win in her 2019 season, capturing the Pan Zareta S. at Fair Grounds.
Cary continues quest to upgrade Coteau Grove band
Cary Bloodstock’s Andrew Cary has been particularly active this November bidding on behalf of Keith and Ginger Myers’s Louisiana-based Coteau Grove Farms.
After purchasing a pair of mares at Fasig-Tipton November for a combined US$800,000 (AU$1.1 million), Coteau Grove has acquired another nine through three sessions at Keeneland November for gross receipts of US$2,880,000 (AU$3.95 million), making them the current fifth-leading buyer.
“They changed the breed-back rules in Louisiana, and that kind of frees us up to treat it more like the New York-bred program,” said Cary midway through Wednesday’s session.
“You still have resident mares, but you can go out of state, so it gives license to upgrade the broodmare band a bit. We thought this would be a good opportunity to do that this year. The market’s still strong for young, commercial mares–which is good to see for the market and long-term players. We’ve been outbid quite a bit, but we’ve been really happy with the ones we’ve gotten, for sure.
“There’s a lot to be excited about: we’ve got two mares in foal to Justify, one in foal to American Pharoah, and we bought one in foal to Nyquist today,” said Cary after buying Hip 645 but before grabbing Hip 958. “We’re trying to breed more Classic types. We bought a really well-bred Medaglia D’Oro mare today – a half to Miss Temple City. The half to Swiss Skydiver might be at the top. She was a queen, and we’re really excited to see Swiss Skydiver back in training next year.”
Despite a noticeable and expected drop off in prices after Monday’s Book 1 session, Cary still found competition in Book 2 to be stiff.
“Yesterday we bought three, and I probably got outbid another 10 or 12 times,” he said. “There are still a ton of really sharp people here who are all thinking the same thing. It’s just a matter of following them up. Sometimes you’re there, and sometimes you’re not. I think it’s a very healthy market for those long-term investments.”
Veronique rewards Holmes once more
Tony Holmes and a long-time employee partnered up on the mare Veronique (USA) (Mizzen Mast {USA}), purchasing her privately and, thanks to the exploits of her unbeaten colt Nashville (USA) (Speightstown {USA}), enjoyed a standout result Monday when they resold the 9-year-old for US$800,000 (AU$1.1 million). The partners continued to reap the benefits of last year’s purchase when selling the mare’s weanling filly by Mastery (USA) (Hip 885) for US$400,000 (AU$549,820) to Stonestreet Stables Wednesday at Keeneland. The foal was consigned by Warrendale Sales.
“I didn’t plan on putting either of them in the Sale,” Holmes admitted after the weanling went through the ring. “It was all Nashville.”
The speedy Nashville is now three-for-three following his track-record setting win in the Perryville S. at Keeneland last Saturday.
“She was a lovely filly and a lovely mover,” Holmes said of the weanling. “You have to be careful setting your reserves when you get a horse of this calibre. So, we had a reasonable enough reserve on her and she took care of the rest herself.”