The direct race record of a horse rarely provides a complete picture of its true ability. Not all stakes races are created equal; there are metropolitan races in certain cities that would rate higher than many stakes races in other locations.
Some horses are well-placed in weak races that flatter their record, while others are unlucky and seem to run into trouble where-ever they go, unable to break through at the level their ability suggests.
Thoroughly assessing a mare's performance using indicators beyond a race record summary can allow her progeny to be valued differently than the pedigree page might simply suggest.
We have all heard stories of fillies that had an exceptional amount of ability but sadly had to retire before that could be fully realised, only to go on and produce a very good horse.
Anders (Not A Single Doubt) is such an example, the fourth foal from unraced mare Madame Andree (War Emblem {USA}), who trainer Paul Messara said "was a horse that seemed to have unlimited ability... She did a couple of pieces of work with Ortensia, and she was an absolute freak of a thing." Arrowfield mated Madame Andree to their top stallions according to her potential, not her record on paper, and she has subsequently repaid that faith by leaving a very, very fast Group 3-winning colt.
Assessing the current Magic Millions catalogue, I have looked at certain aspects of dam race records to see how they can measure up as good producers. It can be used as one more tool to try find that elusive champion.
Lot 115 - Snitzel x Bonny O’Reilly (colt)
Bjorn Baker trained mare Bonny O'Reilly (NZ) (O'Reilly {NZ}) was a prolific winner of eight races from just 16 starts. The highlight win of her career was the Listed Coughlan over 1200 metres at Doomben.
At her fourth career start she ran into Group 1 winner, In Her Time (Time Thief) in a BM72 at Canterbury, beaten less than 1l. She would go on to be competitive at Group 2 level, then ran into bad luck in the G1 Tatts Tiara S. in 2017, behind Tycoon Tara (Written Tycoon). She mixed it with Group 1 winners Prompt Response (Beneteau), Daysee Doom (Domesday) and Impending.
Bonny O'Reilly also possessed good early speed, making her an attractive proposition as a broodmare. Despite only winning at Listed level, she could be considered to have proper Group 1 ability.
Lot 115 - Snitzel x Bonny O’Reilly (NZ) (colt)
Lot 447 - American Pharoah (USA) x Koonoomoo (filly)
A winner of five of 35 starts, Koonoomoo (Dubleo {USA}) was very talented. Her biggest career win was the G3 Herald Sun on Melbourne Cup Day in 2012, ultimately beating G1 Stradbroke H. winner Mid Summer Music (Oamaru Force). She went on to be competitive in the G1 Futurity S. over 1400 metres behind All Too Hard, before running second to dual Group 1 winner Red Tracer (Dane Shadow).
Most notably, Koonoomoo is the dam of Hinchinbrook filly All Too Sass, her third foal, who was unlucky to run into G2 Roman Consul runner-up On The Lead (I Am Invincible) on debut. All Too Sass is a pending winner and a significant pedigree upgrade for this American Pharoah (USA) filly is imminent.
Lot 447 - American Pharoah (USA) x Koonoomoo (filly)
Lot 534 - Astern x Merriest (filly)
Even though this Denman mare was only a Listed winner, Merriest's entire career was littered with Group 1 form.
At her 2-year-old debut, she accounted for future Group 1 winner I Am A Star (NZ) (I Am Invincible) and went on to beat Group 1 runner-up Oregon’s Day in the Listed Atlantic Jewel S. three starts later.
Merriest was then competitive against G1 Coolmore S. winner Flying Artie and not beaten far by Group 1 winner Prompt Response (Beneteau). Finishing her career as the winner of five from twenty starts with a strong on-speed pattern, Merriest has an abundance of talent to pass onto her progeny.
Lot 534 - Astern x Merriest (filly)
Lot 636 - I Am Invincible x Petition (colt)
If it wasn’t for bad luck, Petition (Foxwedge) wouldn’t have had any luck at all! She will go down as one of the unluckiest mares to hit a racetrack. Don’t let her record of two wins (a maiden and 3-year-old handicap) from 15 starts put you off, she was far better than it looks on paper.
Petition should have won at least three stakes races, if not for back luck or bad barriers. She also ran into numerous stakes winners in her career.
Petition was unlucky not to beat Group 1 winner Prompt Response in the Listed MRC Twilight Glow and also went very close to knocking off multiple Group 1 winner Global Glamour (Star Witness) in the G2 Tristarc S. In the process she beat home G1 Queen of the Turf winner Foxplay (Foxwedge).
It's fair to say this mare could be underrated based purely on her record, but once you scratch the surface, it's clear her progeny could offer great value for potential buyers. This I Am Invincible colt is her first foal.
Lot 636 - I Am Invincible x Petition (colt)