Border restrictions preventing the presence of international buyers were always going to be the biggest issue confronting New Zealand Bloodstock ahead of this week, and the end of Book 1 stats backed that up, with investment from outside of the country almost half of what it was in 2020.
The overall spend by non-New Zealand buyers dropped from NZ$40.12 million in 2020, or around 62.7 per cent of overall gross, to NZ$20.9 million this year, a proportion of 40.9 per cent.
Local buyers seized the opportunity in a softer market to secure 257 of the 416 yearlings sold in Book 1, the highest volume of purchases by New Zealanders in the elite Sale in recent history. That number is 54 more than what New Zealand buyers picked up in what was a bigger catalogue last year.
"Local buyers seized the opportunity in a softer market to secure 257 of the 416 yearlings sold in Book 1, the highest volume of purchases by New Zealanders in the elite Sale in recent history."
One of the interesting aspects of this is that they did this without a substantial rise in overall investment. The aggregate of those 257 buys was NZ$30.155 million, only a slight increase on the NZ$27.9 million the locals spent in 2020, and largely on par with what they had spent in the previous two years before that.
Put simply, they shopped below the top line, with the average price of a New Zealand-purchased yearling at NZ$117,337, a substantial drop on an average of NZ$137,241 in 2020, NZ$133,624 in 2019 and NZ$147,678 in 2018.
The less competitive market - there were 207 total buyers compared to 238 in 2020 - made it much easier for locals to buy. The median of their purchases was NZ$85,000, NZ$10,000 down on 2020 and notably down NZ$25,000 on what it was in 2017.
| 2021 | 257 | 61.78% | $30,155,500 | 59.07% | 85,000 | $117,337 |
| 2020 | 203 | 40.68% | $27,860,000 | 44.16% | $95,000 | $137,241 |
| 2019 | 230 | 45.82% | $30,733,500 | 44.76% | $100,000 | $133,624 |
| 2018 | 212 | 38.55% | $31,301,500 | 37.24% | $100,000 | $147,678 |
| 2017 | 142 | 40.69% | $19,840,000 | 33.51% | $120,000 | $139,718 |
| 2016 | 143 | 42.94% | $21,729,500 | 38.20% | $110,000 | $151,955 |
Table: Local buying bench purchases from 2016 to 2021
* Currency New Zealand dollars
In a jurisdiction which hasn't had the boom in prizemoney to propel growth in the bloodstock markets like Australia, New Zealand buyers saw the opportunity to get more for less.
International buyers were still active at Karaka, either online, or through agents on the ground, and the average level of investment per purchase was similar to what it was last year. Across 159 purchases from those buyers (a drop from 296 in 2020), the average price was NZ$131,723, only a slight decline from what it was in 2020 (NZ$135,739).
Unsurprisingly, given the border restrictions, Australian investment in Book 1 dropped year-on-year from NZ$29.4 million across 224 yearlings in 2020, to NZ$13.36 million across 115 yearlings in 2021.
International investment has generally carried between 60-65 percent of the total aggregate spend for Book 1 at Karaka over the past five years, but, as mentioned earlier, fell to 40.9 per cent this week.
| 2021 | 159 | 38.22% | $20,897,500 | 40.93% | $100,000 | $131,123 |
| 2020 | 296 | 59.32% | $40,178,888 | 63.69% | $110,000 | $135,739 |
| 2019 | 276 | 54.98% | $37,935,500 | 55.24% | $110,000 | $137,447 |
| 2018 | 337 | 61.27% | $52,749,500 | 62.76% | $115,000 | $156,526 |
| 2017 | 207 | 59.31% | $39,362,500 | 66.49% | $150,000 | $190,157 |
| 2016 | 190 | 57.06% | $35,160,000 | 61.80% | $155,000 | $185,052 |
Table: Overseas buying bench purchases from 2016 to 2021
* Currency New Zealand dollars
Internationals missed at the pointy end
That absence of investment was particularly felt at the top end, where the volume of lots which sold for NZ$500,000 or more dropped from 12 in 2020 to five in 2021. Just two horses in that price bracket went to an overseas buyer, whereas last year that number was five.
The top 50 lots in Book 1 at Karaka this year averaged NZ$341,000, compared to NZ$403,100 for horses in that category last year, indicating a comparative weakness in the top end of the market.
The top lot of Book 1, Lot 94 - Zoustar x Scintillula (Ire) (filly) sold for NZ$800,000
Broadening that view, the Top 100 and the average for horses within it was NZ$266,350 in 2021, a reduction from NZ$314,800. That's a drop of around 15.4 per cent. As a note of comparison, the overall average dropped 10 per cent from 2020 from NZ$136,350 to NZ$122,724.
The format of the Karaka Sale has chopped and changed over the past few years, making like-for-like Book 1 comparisons on average a little hard to make. The table below sets out the averages every year since 2016, but it is worth noting that Book 1 was a smaller, more select sale in 2016 and 2017.
| 2021 | 416 | $122,724 | $51,053,000 |
| 2020 | 499 | $136,350 | $68,038,888 |
| 2019 | 506 | $135,709 | $68,669,000 |
| 2018 | 549 | $153,098 | $84,051,000 |
| 2017 | 349 | $169,635 | $59,202,500 |
| 2016 | 333 | $170,839 | $56,889,500 |
Table: Book 1 comparisons year-on-year
* Currency New Zealand dollars
Savabeel, Tavistock numbers reflect market
What we can ascertain is that it was the fewest number of yearlings sold in Book 1 in four years, and those fewer numbers flowed through into the volume of the progeny sold by major New Zealand stallions.
Savabeel, a winner of the Grosvenor Award as New Zealand's Champion Sire for the past six seasons, has been a powerhouse through this Sale over recent years. Book 1 2021 saw half the number of progeny sold through the Karaka ring on 2020. He had 29 sell this week for an average of NZ$216,724, compared to 58 for an average of NZ$247,241 last year.
It's a strategy by Waikato Stud in 2021 to spread Savabeel's progeny out across different Australian sales, reflected in the above numbers. That may prove a savvy move, and it also accounted for NZ$8 million less spent at Karaka Book 1 2021 when compared to last year on Savabeel yearlings alone.
Savabeel | Standing at Waikato Stud
Cambridge Stud's late sire Tavistock (NZ), another stallion who has been a dominant force of this Sale, also saw the numbers of horses sold through Book 1 drop from 52 last year to 30 this year. The result of a more select offering of his yearlings actually saw his average increase to NZ$141,500, meaning only a slight drop of overall investment in his stock.
Cambridge's first-season sensation Alamanzor (Fr) injected significant energy into the sales ring. His 42 first-crop yearlings averaged NZ$193,571, over six times his first-season service fee, and they grossed NZ$8.13 million, or nearly 16 per cent of the overall market.
That bright note, combined with the fact that the looming implementation of a COVID-19 vaccine should pave the way for international travel in the near future, and gives significant cause for optimism for the entire market heading towards Karaka in 2022.