Like Danehill (USA) and Zabeel (NZ) before them, these two great stallions have built a legacy and a rivalry that is set to power Australian bloodlines for years to come.
Comparison of statistics can often be reductive when it comes to champions of any ilk, but in this case, it is easy to argue that putting one's amazing record in parallel to another elevates the argument for the legacy that both have left.
In 2020/21, Encosta De Lago is set to gain posthumous bragging rights over Redoute's Choice.
As it stands, Encosta De Lago holds a lead of $1.8 million in the damsire category and is set to end the late Arrowfield Stud resident's two-season hold on the honour of being Australia's leading broodmare sire.
The late Encosta De Lago
It will be Encosta De Lago's fourth Champion Broodmare Sire title and his first since 2017/18 when he completed a hat-trick of victories in that category. In that season, he also edged out Redoute's Choice, who would subsequently relegate him to second in the past two seasons.
The contests they have had in recent years as broodmare sires extends the rivalry they built as sires, where on three occasions they both finished as the top two on the Australian Sires' Table.
"The contests they (Encosta De Lago and Redoute's Choice) have had in recent years as broodmare sires extends the rivalry they built as sires, where on three occasions they both finished as the top two on the Australian Sires' Table."
Redoute's Choice's first Champion title in 2005/06, in what was just his third season with runners to the track, came over Encosta De Lago, who by that point had five crops racing. Three seasons later, when Encosta De Lago secured his second Champion Sire title, it was Redoute's Choice in second place, just over $400,000 behind him.
In 2009/10, Redoute's Choice regained the ascendancy, winning his second of three Champion Sire titles, by just over $360,000 from Encosta De Lago.
2014/15 | 3 | 230 | 10 | $9,881,866 |
2015/16 | 1 | 248 | 15 | $16,760,239 |
2016/17 | 1 | 286 | 15 | $18,921,539 |
2017/18 | 2 | 325 | 10 | $23,090,582 |
2018/19 | 2 | 345 | 15 | $21,927,923 |
2019/20 | 2 | 334 | 17 | $24,629,558 |
2020/21 | 1 | 309 | 12 | $28,572,416 |
Table: Encosta De Lago's broodmare sire record in Australia
2014/15 | 6 | 141 | 8 | $7,523,904 |
2015/16 | 5 | 178 | 13 | $10,124,749 |
2016/17 | 4 | 213 | 10 | $12,131,189 |
2017/18 | 2 | 233 | 13 | $18,509,297 |
2018/19 | 1 | 259 | 19 | $23,235,952 |
2019/20 | 1 | 287 | 20 | $27,486,767 |
2020/21 | 2 | 290 | 19 | $26,739,289 |
Table: Redoute's Choice's broodmare sire record in Australia
All in all, there were eight seasons where the pair were adjacent to each other on the Champion Sires' Table. In four of those seasons it was Encosta De Lago on top and in four of those, bragging rights went to Redoute's Choice.
Overall, Redoute's Choice only recently surpassed Encosta De Lago for total Australian winners, 977 to 963, and he should have no issues breaking through the 1000 Australian winners milestone given his final crop are yet to turn two. He also leads Encosta De Lago in terms of the number of Australian stakes winners he has produced, 143 to 90, and total progeny earnings, $140 million to $125 million.
Encosta De Lago | 963 | 90 | $124,716,481 |
Redoute's Choice | 977 | 143 | $140,401,607 |
Table: Australian career statistics as a sire
Daughters carry the legacy
Given their respective success, it should be no surprise that the pair are now dominant broodmare sires in Australia.
And their current rivalry at the top of the Australian broodmare sires' standings is likely to continue for some time, with both Encosta De Lago (767) and Redoute's Choice (622) having more runners from their daughters this season than in any previous season.
Their stats this season are quite interesting in comparison, with Encosta De Lago having had more Australian winners as a damsire (309 to 290), but Redoute's Choice claiming the honour of having had more stakes winners from his daughters, with 19 as compared to 12.
The late Redoute's Choice claims the honour of having had more stakes winners from his daughters, with 19 as compared to 12 for Encosta De Lago
Encosta De Lago's total Australian prizemoney earnings as a broodmare sire this season of $28,572,416 is a new record, helped along by The Everest victory of his grandson, Classique Legend (Not A Single Doubt), who is out of his daughter Pinocchio.
Meanwhile, Adelong's (Medaglia D'Oro {USA}) recent victory in the Listed June S. saw her damsire Redoute's Choice edge past Encosta De Lago when it comes to total Australian stakes winners from their daughters, with 96 to 95.
Their overall Australian head-to-head broodmare sire record sees Encosta De Lago, who was foaled three years before Redoute's Choice, leading on overall Australian winners, 1502 to 1076, and overall earnings, $170 million to $147 million, but Redoute's Choice is ahead on winners-to-runners (67.9 per cent to 64.5 per cent) and, as mentioned, stakes winners.
Encosta De Lago | 1502 | 95 | $169,929,940 |
Redoute's Choice | 1076 | 96 | $146,727,382 |
Table: Australian career statistics as a broodmare sire
Sires Of Sires
Of course, a substantial legacy is also left through their sire sons. In the case of Redoute's Choice, he has produced upwards of 40 stallions in their own right, headed by Arrowfield Stud's Snitzel, who has been Australia's Champion Sire the past four seasons, and his former barnmate Not A Single Doubt, who sits second on the 2020/21 Australian Sires' Table.
According to Arion, Redoute's Choice features in the pedigree of 72 individual stallions which will stand at stud in Australia in 2021.
"According to Arion, Redoute's Choice features in the pedigree of 72 individual stallions which will stand at stud in Australia in 2021."
Encosta De Lago's influence is also extensive, with nine of his sons at stud in Australia in 2021, while the impact of his late son Northern Meteor is growing significantly. All in all, there are 29 stallions on Australian rosters in 2021 which feature Encosta De Lago in their pedigree.
There are eight current Australian-based stallions which feature both Encosta De Lago and Redoute's Choice in their pedigree, Zoustar, Alabama Express, Invader, Lean Mean Machine, Maschino, My Admiration, Sun City and Zousain.
Gallery: Some of the current Australian-based stallions which feature both Encosta De Lago and Redoute's Choice in their pedigree
Cut from the same cloth
Going back through their own pedigrees, Encosta De Lago and Redoute's Choice share a similar profile. Both were by American-bred shuttle stallions from the Northern Dancer (Can)-line in Fairy King (USA) and Danehill respectively. They were also both from Australian-bred mares, Shoal Creek (Star Way {GB}) and Shantha's Choice (Canny Lad), which were in turn out of American-bred mares in Dancing Show (USA) (Nijinsky II {Can}) and Rolls (USA) (Mr Prospector {USA}).
As racehorses, both forged their racing reputations in the fire of the 1990s Melbourne racing scene. The Emirates Park-bred Encosta De Lago graduated from being a stakes-placed 2-year-old to a Group 1-winning 3-year-old in the 1996 Vic Health Cup (now the Sir Rupert Clarke S.) under the guidance of Lee Freedman before his career was ended after just eight starts.
Bred by Muzaffar Ali Yaseen, Redoute's Choice's racetrack career for trainer Rick Hore-Lacy was similarly brief, lasting just 54 weeks from when he won the Listed Veuve Clicquot S. in February 1999 until when he finished third in the G1 Futurity S. in March 2000.
In between, he won a G1 Blue Diamond S., just seven days after his debut, was famously scratched on the morning of a Golden Slipper S. for which he was favourite, then came back in the spring to win the G1 Manikato S. and the G1 Caulfield Guineas. Further Group 1 glory would follow in the autumn in his 3-year-old season against the older horses in the CF Orr S.
Encosta De Lago entered stud in Australia in 1997, where he initially stood at Blue Gum Farm in Victoria, with his first progeny hitting the track in the 2000/01 season. He was secured by Coolmore Australia in 2003, where he continued his remarkable career until he was pensioned in 2014. He also shuttled one season to Coolmore Ireland in 2007.
On his passing in 2018, Coolmore Australia Principal Tom Magnier reflected on his amazing legacy.
"Encosta will be greatly missed by all who dealt with him at Coolmore over the last 14 years," he said.
"He was a horse with a beautiful nature and we were incredibly lucky to have him. His legacy will live on through his sireline descendants like Zoustar and Rubick, as well as through his daughters, who have already made him Champion Broodmare Sire.”
"He (Encosta De Lago) was a horse with a beautiful nature and we were incredibly lucky to have him. His legacy will live on through his sireline descendants like Zoustar and Rubick." - Tom Magnier
Redoute's Choice's stallion career began at Arrowfield Stud in 2000, with his first crop hitting the track in 2003/04. He would serve 19 seasons in Australia, as well as two seasons in France at Haras de Bonneval, before he died age 22 in March 2019. He was remembered as a horse of enormous significance by Arrowfield.
"Redoute’s Choice is such a big part of all our lives, and right now it’s hard to imagine Arrowfield without him," Arrowfield Chairman, John Messara, said at the time.
“He has given us so much, Arrowfield has been built on his back and he’s allowed all of us and many, many other people to fulfil our dreams and ambitions."
The late Redoute's Choice with Paul and John Messara | Image courtesy of Bronwen Healy
* all stats sourced from Arion and accurate as of July 6, 2021