Second-season sire showcase highlights sophomore dominance

6 min read
Saturday's G1 Coolmore Stud S. is set to be a showcase not only for Australia's best 3-year-old sprinting talent, but also for the virtues of the array of second-season sires which have made such a major imprint, just 13 months after their first runners hit the track.

Cover image courtesy of Newgate Farm

Six of the 17 runners in Saturday's C1 Coolmore Stud S. at Flemington are from the first crop of their sires, including the favourite Extreme Warrior, who is one of two runners by Extreme Choice, the other being Extreme Flight.

Completing the list is G1 Blue Diamond S. winner Artorius (Flying Artie), R. Listed Magic Millions 2YO Classic winner Shaquero (Shalaa {Ire}), multiple Group 1 placegetter Ingratiating (Frosted {USA}) and emerging colt Marine One (Capitalist).

Artorius

It should not surprise that this crop of sires should be a dominant force in a Group 1 race, after all, last season their progeny won three of the five 2-year-old Group 1 races on the calendar as well as the major two 'sales' races staged by Magic Millions and Inglis.

But while it was the Newgate star trio of Extreme Choice, Capitalist and Flying Artie who courted headlines through 2020/21, what has become apparent in the results so far this season is the extraordinary depth in that crop of stallions, 14 of which have already produced stakes winners.

While Capitalist leads the Second Season Sires' Table in terms of progeny earnings and Extreme Choice has continued his remarkable return from his small first crop, with three stakes winners this season, it is a pair of Arrowfield shuttlers who to this point of the season have produced the most winners.

Maurice13
Shalaa13
Capitalist12
Star Turn12
Flying Artie11

Table: Leading second-season sires by Australian winners - 2021/22

Shalaa, Maurice lead the way

As of October 26, Shalaa (Ire) and Maurice (Jpn) have both had 13 Australian winners this season, one clear of Newgate's Capitalist and Vinery Stud's Star Turn, despite a numerical disadvantage in terms of runners.

Shalaa produced his first stakes winner of the season last weekend, with Semillion's win in the R. Listed Inglis Banner. It’s his second Australian stakes winner, after Shaquero, and he becomes the first sire of his class to get a 2-year-old winner from his second crop, something he also did with his first crop.

Semillion as a yearling | Image courtesy of Inglis

Maurice's return to Arrowfield Stud this season was much-anticipated after he missed the 2020 season due to COVID-related transportation issues. Breeders have been keen to get back and support him off some very positive results from his first crop.

Last Saturday, Maurice, who has had three stakes winners including a Group 1 winner in Japan, was rewarded with his first Australian stakes winner when Mazu was successful in the Listed Brian Crowley S. That success came after a run of six stakes placegetters for the sire, who has his 13 Australian winners this season from just 34 runners.

Maurice is the 14th stallion of that crop to have already produced stakes winners, with 10 of those getting stakes winners this season.

Maurice is the 14th stallion of that crop to have already produced stakes winners, with 10 of those getting stakes winners this season.

Joining the Arrowfield Stud pair and the Newgate pair Extreme Choice and Flying Artie on that list of 10 are Waikato Stud's Tivaci, who had Never Been Kissed (NZ) claim the G1 Flight S., Darley's Astern and Frosted (USA), Coolmore's American Pharoah (USA), Newhaven Park's Xtravagant (NZ) and Gold Front's Awesome Rock.

Gallery: Second-season sires with stakes winners this season

In a strong sign of the vibrancy and diversity of the Australian market, those ten stakes-producing stallions are themselves by 10 separate sires. That stretches right down the depth chart, with the 44 second-season stallions to have sired a winner in Australia this season by 34 different sires.

A historic dominance

A snapshot of the past few seasons reveals how dominant these second stallions have been relative to previous classes. At this point of last season, there were five, or half the number of sophomore stallions with stakes winners, while in 2019/20 that number was six, and in 2018/19, by the final week in October, there were just three stakes-producing second season stallions.

2021/2210
2020/215
2019/206
2018/193

Table: Number of stakes-producing second-season sires to October 26 of that season

Looking at recent history by volume of winners confirms that it is not just in the big races where this crop of stallions is getting the results. As it stands, there are five second-season stallions who have 10 winners or more. A comparison at this point of the previous two seasons, saw just three with 10 or more, while in 2018/19, it was two.

While an argument could be made about the numerical advantages of sires with big books, it is noteworthy that four current second-season stallions have produced stakes winners this season off fewer than 20 runners.

While an argument could be made about the numerical advantages of sires with big books, it is noteworthy that four current second-season stallions have produced stakes winners this season off fewer than 20 runners.

Extreme Choice has backed up his extraordinary first season by producing three stakes winners from just 16 runners this season. Tivaci, also has had only 16 Australian runners, while Xtravagant has had 18 seasonal runners (for eight winners) and Awesome Rock just eight.

In terms of their performance against the older, more experienced sires, this crop are also batting well above average. In their first season with runners to the track in 2020/21, they won 19 of the 72 2-year-old Australian stakes races, or 26.3 per cent, while that pattern has continued this season where they have won 11 of 48 3-year-old stakes races (23 per cent) and one of five 2-year-old stakes races already staged.

A stage for second-season success

The Coolmore Stud S. has proven a showcase for second-season sires before, notably in 2018, when the sophomore crop of Widden Stud stallion Zoustar filled the trifecta, headed by star filly Sunlight.

In 2014, I Am Invincible's first-crop son, Brazen Beau, won the race, while the year prior it was Zoustar himself successful for his late sire Northern Meteor.

Gallery: Stallions who have sire G1 Coolmore S. winners

In 2010, Star Witness, who was from the first crop of Starcraft (NZ), won the Coolmore Stud S., while in 2009, it was the filly Headway getting the job done for Charge Forward. In 2007, the first year the race was run under the current moniker, the winner Weekend Hussler was from the first Australian crop of Hussonet (USA).

It's quite a rich history and one which the current amazing collection of second-season sires are well-poised to add to in Saturday's much-anticipated race.

Beyond that, Maurice has three representatives in the G1 VRC Derby, while American Pharoah has one.

Second-season sires
Coolmore Stud S
Extreme Choice
Capitalist
Flying Artie
Shalaa
Maurice
Tivaci
Awesome Rock
American Pharoah
Xtravagant
Astern
Frosted