Quickfire: X-rays and Yearlings

4 min read

Written by Bren O'Brien

Cover image courtesy of Bronwen Healy

In the first of our regular series 'Quickfire', TDN AusNZ speaks to a range of people seeking responses to a key question of importance to the thoroughbred industry.

In the past decade, the use of x-rays by buyers to assess the physical suitability of a yearling to the rigours of life as a racehorse has become common place. Sales companies now provide x-rays repositories and buyers have more information than ever when deciding whether or not to bid on a horse.

We spoke to trainers, bloodstock agents and syndicators and asked them one simple question.

How forgiving are you on a yearling with x-ray issues?

Henry Field - Yearling purchaser - Managing Director of Newgate Farm

HF: “Nowadays, vets are far more practical and a smaller group of better vets are doing the majority of the yearling sales work. As such, far more horses are now rightly 'passing' the x-ray on the sales ground.”

Henry Field

HF: “There used to be a great opportunity a couple of years ago to get massive discounts on yearlings with what we would consider to have fairly insignificant x-ray issues. However, with the maturity of the market these discount opportunities are far less frequent.”

Suman Hedge - Bloodstock Agent - Suman Hedge Bloodstock

SH: “Clearly, if there is an issue which elevates risk we have to consider how that may compromise the horse in terms of racing soundness and also how aggressively we pursue the purchase. As we are often looking at earlier types we need to consider if racing earlier may exacerbate the x-ray issue or if the time required to resolve may make the physical maturity advantage of the given horse redundant.

“In the case where an x-ray is low to moderate or moderate we always consult with our client and inform them or the potentially elevated risk and see if they still want to pursue the horse. Different clients have different views on this, some won’t consider the horse whilst others may see it as an opportunity and potential discount.”

Suman Hedge

SH: “Having a good, practical racing vet is a big advantage as they see the potential issues and are best placed to appraise genuine risk. It’s not perfect but it’s the best we can hope for and ultimately with the costs involved we have to try to mitigate risk as much as we can.”

Will Bourne - Bloodstock Manager- Ciaron Maher Racing

WB: “Knees are very big for us. Overall we are very forgiving on x-rays, but knees are one thing we look at closely.”

William Bourne, Gabrielle Nutt and Ciaron Maher | Image courtesy of Magic Millions

James Moss - Syndicator - Tricolours Syndications

JM: “With x-rays, our policy is low-risk only. I’m trying to stack all the odds in the favour of my owners. Vetting horses is a hugely important part of the process. We try not to leave any stone unturned. For that reason, we only tolerate low-risk x-rays.”

Brett Howard - Bloodstock Agent - Randwick Bloodstock

BH: “I would say 99 per cent of the time it comes down to the client and how they approach the x-rays and the risk that they are willing to take.

“Often, once you tell them that the x-rays aren't low risk, then they tell you to forget about it and let’s find one which has clear x-rays. A lot of the time, these are people who are only buying one horse for the year, so they take the view that surely there are other horses out there that are low risk.”

Brett Howard | Image courtesy of Bronwen Healy

BH: “Those who are looking to buy a few more horses might be more happy to play in the low to moderate risk areas.

“Over the years, it's cost us buying a future Golden Slipper winner and a future Blue Diamond winner. These were horses we had vetted and they came back with moderate or high-risk x-rays and those horses went on to win those big races. If the client had had been prepared to take those x-ray risks, they might have had the same result.”

Cameron Bennett- Syndicator - Flying Start Syndications

CB: “Depends on the issue and what my vet thinks on the matter. We are not real forgiving and would rather purchase horses with clean x-rays as we have had better success with these horses and less injuries to date.”

Quckfire
Yearling
x-rays
Henry Field
Brett Howard
Suman Hedge
Cameron Bennett
James Moss
Will Bourne