Locals do the heavy lifting as Karaka market rebounds

7 min read
New Zealand Bloodstock emerged from Book 1 at its National Yearling Sale at Karaka this week understandably pleased with the strength of the market, but statistics reveal that it was the local buyers that again did much of the heavy lifting, continuing the trend of 2021 when the Karaka buying bench flipped on its head.

Cover image courtesy of NZ Racing Desk

The slight loosening of New Zealand border restrictions to allow Kiwi ex-pats to return to attend Karaka justified NZB's initial decision to delay the Sale from its traditional January date and undoubtedly added to the buying bench, although a major flow of international investment did not eventuate as a result.

The Book 1 aggregate grew impressively from NZ$51 million at the heavily COVID-impacted 2021 Sale to NZ$63 million at the less restricted 2022 edition, up 24 per cent. Book 1 was slightly larger this year but resulted in just an additional 15 horses being sold.

Lot 161 - Savabeel x Chandelier (NZ) (colt), the Book 1 Sale-topper purchased by Tony Fung Investments and Annabel Neasham Racing for NZ$1 million | Image courtesy of NZB

One of the drivers behind that growth was that New Zealand buyers purchased exactly the same amount of horses as they did in 2021, 257, but were willing to pay considerably more for them.

New Zealand25759.63%$36,170,000 57.19%$100,000 $140,739
Australia13030.16%$20,212,500 31.96%$100,000 $155,480
Others4410.21%$6,865,000 10.85%$150,000 $156,023

Table: NZB Karaka Book 1 buyer breakdown by location (NZ$)

In 2021, the average price of a Book 1 horse purchased by a New Zealand buyer was NZ$117,337 where this year, they went to NZ$140,739, a jump of 20 per cent. That means that the total investment from New Zealand buyers in Book 1 reached a record level of NZ$36.2 million, a NZ$6 million increase on last year.

An argument could be made that it was a slightly better catalogue this year and that there was more competition in the market, but the additional confidence garnered from the world emerging from the worst economic impacts of the COVID pandemic would have also played its part.

Australian investment also jumped, from NZ$13.4 million to NZ$20.2 million, in a very positive sign and one which reflects the confidence of the Australian buying bench in all markets.

202225759.63%$36,170,000 57.19%$100,000 $140,739
202125761.78%$30,155,500 59.07%85,000$117,337
202020340.68%$27,860,000 44.16%$95,000 $137,241
201923045.82%$30,733,500 44.76%$100,000 $133,624
201821238.55%$31,301,500 37.24%$100,000 $147,678
201714240.69%$19,840,000 33.51%$120,000 $139,718
201614342.94%$21,729,500 38.20%$110,000 $151,955

Table: New Zealand buyers at NZB Karaka Book 1 (NZ$)

The presence of the Aussie-based Kiwis was undoubtedly a factor in that. The biggest Australian registered buyer of the week, Tony Fung, was likely emboldened by the fact he could have one of his most trusted bloodstock judges, ex-pat Kacy Fogden, ringside at Karaka.

Similarly, Cranbourne-based Busuttin Racing, with Trent Busuttin and Natalie Young able to attend, nearly tripled their spend this year to NZ$2.14 million, buying 12 horses, five more than last year.

An unclear international picture

In what is sure sign of the impact of closed borders, international investment in Book 1 beyond Australia actually fell year-on-year, from NZ$7.4 million in 2021 to NZ$6.87 million this year. That is just 10.9 per cent of the Book 1 market, whereas in 2020, pre-COVID, it was 15.8 per cent.

A packed New Zealand Bloodstock Karaka auditorium pre-COVID

The total international spend (inc Australians) on Book 1 this year was NZ$27.1 million, which while it is up on the NZ$20.9 million of last year, is a big drop from the average of NZ$41 million spent across the five sales from 2016-2020.

The reality is that this year, the New Zealand buying bench spent 57.2 per cent on the money in Book 1 and purchased 59.6 per cent of the horses. This is not a major change from last year, where NZ buyers spent 59.1 per cent of the money and 61.8 per cent of the horses.

That split is completely the opposite to 2020 and prior, where the visiting buying bench drove between 55 and 65 per cent of trade, powering competition and driving returns to New Zealand breeders.

202217440.37%$27,077,500 42.81%$100,000 $155,618
202115938.22%$20,897,500 40.93%$100,000 $131,123
202029659.32%$40,178,888 63.69%$110,000 $135,739
201927654.98%$37,935,500 55.24%$110,000 $137,447
201833761.27%$52,749,500 62.76%$115,000 $156,526
201720759.31%$39,362,500 66.49%$150,000 $190,157
201619057.06%$35,160,000 61.80%$155,000 $185,052

Table: International buyers at NZB Karaka Book 1 (NZ$)

Te Akau leads local spending spree

The Kiwi buyers do need to be given credit for stepping up. When you consider that in 2017, they spent less that NZ$20 million in Book 1 at their home yearling sale, and that has now grown to NZ$36 million, it does speak to the increased confidence.

Te Akau's David Ellis can take a lot of credit for that. He purchased 32 horses in Book 1, nearly 7.5 per cent of the catalogue, and spent NZ$8.1 million, or 12.8 per cent of the gross.

David Ellis of Te Akau Racing was leading buyer at the conclusion of NZB Karaka - Book 1 | Image courtesy of NZ Racing Desk

He virtually carried the Sale last year with his 38 buys for NZ$7.42 million, but backed up and even increased that investment, in dollar terms, in 2022. Given the success he has had, it is little wonder.

But that confidence flowed right through to the likes of Roger James and Robert Wellwood, who increased their Book 1 investment from NZ$860,000 last year to NZ$2.2 million this year, highlighted by the NZ$900,000 they paid for a colt by The Autumn Sun, the biggest price James has paid for a yearling in his fabled 35-year career.

Syndicator Go Racing also made a big splash, spending NZ$2.12 million across 13 purchases in Book 1, nearly NZ$1 million more than it spent last year.

Albert Bosma, Stephen Marsh and Matt Allnutt inspecting yearlings at Karaka | Image courtesy of NZ Racing Desk

In terms of those who were rewarded, the big farms were able to bank considerable returns form their yearling harvest. Waikato Stud grossed NZ$7.86 million as opposed to NZ$4.3 million last year, while Cambridge Stud also grew its gross from NZ$5.7 million to NZ$6.1 million. The smaller farms also did well, with the likes of Landsdowne Stud, Milan Park, White Robe Lodge and Beaufort Downs achieving record results.

Waikato Stud39$7,860,000 $201,538 $1,000,000
Cambridge Stud34$6,105,000 $179,559 $850,000
Curraghmore19$3,745,000 $197,105 $850,000
Wentwood Grange31$3,425,000 $110,484 $450,000
Westbury Stud28$3,390,000 $121,071 $300,000
Haunui Farm17$3,235,000 $190,294 $625,000
Pencarrow Stud22$3,190,000 $145,000 $600,000
Landsdowne Park17$2,932,500 $172,500 $900,000
Phoenix Park16$2,452,500 $153,281 $475,000
Little Avondale Stud16$2,400,000 $150,000 $340,000

Table: Leading NZB Karaka Book 1 vendors 2022 (NZ$)

Top-end strength

The Sale itself was particularly kind on those selling top-quality stock. The amount of lots which sold for NZ$500,000 or more grew from five last year to 13 in 2022. That number was 12 in 2020.

The average price of the top 50 lots in Book 1 jumped to NZ$441,100 this year, up from NZ$341,000 last year and NZ$403,100 in 2020.

However, tolerance for those yearlings which buyers didn't feel represented the best product was low. The clearance rate lifted its way towards 77 per cent by the end of Book 1, but it was down on previous years, and well down compared to the Australian sales, where the market for horses at all levels has been pretty much insatiable.

A fundamental reason for that is the restricted buyers' bench and what that points to is a huge upside in the New Zealand market when all buyers can get back to Karaka, whether that be through the NZB Ready to Run Sale later this year or in 2023 at the National Yearling Sale.

Exactly when that 2023 Sale will be held is yet to be confirmed, but the later schedule this year has certainly given the entire New Zealand industry plenty of food for thought. The overwhelming feedback was that the horses themselves benefitted greatly by the extra six weeks and buyers felt more confidence investing in something that was closer to the finished product.

To put a number on this, one vendor confirmed to TDN AusNZ that his yearlings gained about 10 per cent of body weight between January and March.

The challenge of any move would be fitting the Sale into a very busy buyers' schedule. Australian trainers, who you would think would drive much of that expected growth in 2023, are currently right in the heart of the autumn carnivals in Sydney and Melbourne. If a March date proved a disincentive to them attending Karaka, then it would impact competition among the buying bench.

It’s a delicate balance and one which New Zealand Bloodstock will undoubtedly put their minds to in the coming months as they plot the future prosperity of the bloodstock industry in one of the world's great thoroughbred nurseries.

New Zealand Bloodstock
National Yearling Sale
Analysis