Messara and Magnier reflect on rich Easter harvest

8 min read
At the end of a record-breaking Inglis Easter Yearling Sale, two of the Australian thoroughbred industry's most powerful men, Arrowfield Stud Chairman John Messara and Coolmore Australia Principal Tom Magnier had a host of reasons to be happy about the health the industry finds itself in commercially.

This week's Sale broke the Easter aggregate record, which has stood since 2008 and set new marks for both average and median. Among a market with record heat in it, Arrowfield broke new ground, selling $30 million worth of yearlings, a mark $9 million more than anything it had achieved before.

Meanwhile, fellow powerhouse Coolmore was the second biggest vendor on aggregate with $10.7 million worth of sales and Magnier ended as the Sale's biggest spender, signing for six colts worth a combined $10.3 million.

Significantly two of those colts, both by four-time Champion Sire Snitzel, were purchased from Arrowfield, the first time Magnier has gone to seven figures for a horse from the iconic stud.

Gallery: Tom Magnier's top colt purchases at the Inglis Easter Yearling Sale, images courtesy of Inglis

In what is a market rich on both investment and confidence, Magnier and his Coolmore colts group, also emboldened by the success of dual Group 1-winning colt Home Affairs (I Am Invincible) , are happy to shop wherever they can find the best stallion prospects, purchasing a total of 10 seven-figure colts across all sales in 2022.

"The Australian market is the strongest in the world. When you have got the prizemoney and all the various things like that, you have to go out and get them (colts). We're very lucky like that," Magnier said.

"The Australian market is the strongest in the world. When you have got the prizemoney and all the various things like that, you have to go out and get them (colts)." - Tom Magnier

With the appetite for horse ownership at such a high level, the demand for bloodstock, particularly yearlings, has just risen and risen over recent years, with the only blip coming in the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020.

At the top end, that has meant Magnier having to pay that much more for colts, but it has also meant that Coolmore, as a commercial breeder, are getting a much better return as well. It sold 37 yearlings this week, with the total return eclipsing the money spent by Magnier on colts.

Charlie and Tom Magnier | Image courtesy of Inglis

Coolmore may be a global behemoth, but there is no fiercer advocate for the prosperity of the Australian industry than Magnier, who is relishing being in the heart of the current wave of investment.

"It's (the health of the industry) a credit to everybody, from the people who are in charge of making the prizemoney very good, right through. We are just delighted to be a part of the Australian racing and breeding industry. It gives us the confidence to try and get the horses we have this week," he said.

"When you go to the races, the day Home Affairs won the Coolmore or the Lightning, you just don’t get days like that anywhere in the world.

"The way this marketplace is going, it's young, it’s healthy, it's vibrant and it’s on the upward curve. Dad (John Magnier) and Michael (Tabor) and Derek (Smith) and all the team are very passionate about getting behind it."

Arrowfield's Easter success

Messara and his Arrowfield operation looked a certainty to be leading vendor at this Sale for the seventh time in eight years and the Chairman had set a 'stretch' target of $30 million in aggregate sales across the week.

It took until just about the final lot of the draft to get there, but the final total stood at $30.36 million. Among the 59 lots sold, seven fetched $1 million or more.

Gallery: Arrowfeild's $1 million-plus yearlings at the Inglis Easter Yearling Sale, images courtesy of Inglis

It was undoubtedly an extraordinary draft, although Messara was not convinced it was his best on quality, going back 33 years to recall the quality the farm offered at Easter back then.

"It’s probably the biggest and best draft. It was very big and there were a lot of good horses in there. I have had some very good drafts in the past. In 1989, which is a damned year, because it was the year that no one settled, we had a great draft of horses that year, great fillies too," Messara recalled.

"We try and improve every year. We improve our broodmares and we try and improve on our matings. You can always keep improving."

"We try and improve every year. We improve our broodmares and we try and improve on our matings. You can always keep improving." - John Messara

With that in mind, what does Messara think is possible with the 2023 Easter draft?

"We have got plenty of good stuff for next year. We have got some unbelievable babies. We've got something like 30 Written Tycoons to come through, which we needed for out-crossing," he said.

"You'll find he will have a big season next year. By then we will see runners for The Autumn Sun, the Dundeel runners off this strong crop will come out. Next year could be a very good year for us too."

The colts funds kick in

As mentioned, the top-end growth at Easter has been powered by demand by colts funds or stallions syndicates. As well as Magnier, the likes of Kia Ora/TFI, James Harron and Go Bloodstock invested in $1 million-plus colts over the two days.

It’s a phenomenon Messara and Arrowfield have reaped the benefit from, albeit the Arrowfield chairman does see a ceiling to that investment in the future.

Sal Gordon and Paul Messara | Image courtesy of Inglis

"There has been all these sires syndicates established and that has certainly fired things up, those people will end up making sires out of those horses and maybe the edge will come out of that. It certainly had a very major impact, competition between sire syndicates attached to various farms," he said.

"We haven't played a big role in that ourselves. Our model has been we sell our yearlings and we try to buy the ones we really want. It might be hard to buy them now, because we are sending them to people who want to stand them, where in the past we were selling them to racehorse owners."

"Our model has been we sell our yearlings and we try to buy the ones we really want. It might be hard to buy them now, because we are sending them to people who want to stand them, where in the past we were selling them to racehorse owners." - John Messara

The colts syndicate model may not be a major part of Arrowfield's strategy at the moment, although Messara will keep both an eye on the market and an open mind.

"We’ve considered it, the blood that is available here through the yearling market, we have already got quite a bit of," he said.

"We haven't had that sense of urgency. We're looking for other bloodlines, locally and overseas, that aren't readily available in the market here. We are on a slightly different track, we might have to get back on that track at some stage though."

Staffing challenges sees Arrowfield scale back

While yearling prices are at historic highs, and we can expect the upcoming breeding sales to follow the same pattern, one aspect of concern that Messara did raise was staffing.

Throughout the current boom in prizemoney and investment, the challenge of finding people to work in the thoroughbred industry has persisted and while there are a host of measures in place to address this, the COVID pandemic has compounded problems, even for the big players, such as Arrowfield.

The Arrowfield Inglis Easter Yearling Sale team | Image courtesy of Arrowfield

"As a result (of staffing shortages) we will sell 80-odd mares in the next few weeks through Inglis Digital, which hasn't been announced fully yet. We are reducing our broodmare band to accommodate the difficulty in finding staff. That's an immediate impact of the paucity of staff and availability," he said.

"There is nothing else we can do. We can't look after those horses in the manner we like to look after them, because we can't find the staff."

"There is nothing else we can do. We can't look after those horses in the manner we like to look after them, because we can't find the staff." - John Messara

Messara doesn't expect the staffing crisis to be resolved quickly but does see some hope as international travel returns towards pre-pandemic levels.

"I don’t think it will be quick, otherwise we would hang on. I think it will take time, the border will open up some more and there will be more immigration and more students and the like will come, but this is taking a long time, because of COVID," he said.

"We have taken the view that we will tighten it up a bit to enable our existing staff to manage things."

John Messara
Arrowfield Stud
Coolmore
Tom Magnier