The global breeding and racing powerhouse has received legal determination which proves its Kelvinside and Woodlands operations fit the land tax definition of ‘primary production’.
The ruling means that Godolphin Australia will be repaid over $1.4 million in land tax initially assessed by the New South Wales Chief Commissioner of State Revenue between 2014 and 2019, and also be exempt over the subsequent years and into the future.
Godolphin Kelvinside | Image courtesy of Godolphin
Godolphin also won costs on the ruling, having brought the action against the Chief Commissioner in 2019, challenging the Commissioner's assertion that the operations did not meet the exemption for land tax.
However, it is also likely to have much broader significance as a similar definition of 'primary production' largely applies across other contexts and possibly other jurisdictions, with the finding offering greater protection to thoroughbred breeders.
At the heart of a complex case which the Supreme Court's Justice Julie Ward heard was whether Godolphin Australia's business operations at Kelvinside and Woodlands was for the maintenance of animals … for the purpose of selling them or their natural increase or bodily produce.
At the heart of a complex case... was whether Godolphin Australia's business operations at Kelvinside and Woodlands was for the maintenance of animals … for the purpose of selling them or their natural increase or bodily produce.
That would qualify it for an exemption under section 10AA(3)(b) of the Land Tax Management Act 1956 (NSW) (Land Tax Management Act)'.
Godolphin challenged the determination that it was not eligible for an exemption, arguing that overall the integrated operation’s dominant use of the land was for
- the maintenance of stallions for the purpose of selling their bodily produce (specifically, their semen) or their natural increase;
- the maintenance of mares, foals and other horses for the purpose of selling those mares, foals, and other horses or their natural increase;
- and/or the maintenance of cattle for the purpose of selling cattle and their natural increase.
Godolphin Woodlands | Image courtesy of Godolphin
The Chief Commissioner's argument was that the dominant purpose of the land on Godolphin's properties was for breeding and training thoroughbred racehorses as well as spelling them.
While the case dealt with the specific nature of Godolphin Australia's business at its Kelvinside and Woodlands properties, there were wider implications for how thoroughbred breeding is classified.
Had the ruling not been successfully challenged then it could have seen thoroughbred breeding's classification as primary production put under review in a raft of other legislation in New South Wales, and see other states and even the federal government bodies review its status as primary production.
Had the ruling not been successfully challenged then it could have seen thoroughbred breeding's classification as primary production put under review in a raft of other legislation.
This could have extended beyond tax into areas as diverse as drought and flood assistance or other incentives.
The case did not involve Godolphin's designated racing properties at Crown Lodge and Osborne Park, given those properties conduct racing operations and do not qualify as primary production under the legislation.
The ruling
In what amounted to an argument over whether Godolphin was breeding horses at its properties for racing purposes or for the ongoing commercial value of the stock, Justice Ward ruled in favour of Godolphin.
The ruling states:
"The significance of this conclusion is that, if there were two distinct purposes for the activities carried on at the land, then the relevant question would be whether use for any one such purpose was the dominant use," it read.
"However, to my mind, the objectives of winning races and pursuit of stallion excellence are part of the overall objectives of increasing the value of Godolphin’s stud operations (being nomination fees in particular and sale of the majority of Godolphin’s progeny) at a time that does not compete with breeders and taking into account an assessment of racing potential but that the sales are sufficiently proximate – if that be a required element – to the maintenance of the animals on the Land."
Key to Justice Ward's findings were also that the racing operations of Godolphin and its economics should not be looked at in isolation as:
"… the evidence that racing prowess (of the horse and of its progeny in due course) is an important factor in the pricing able to be commanded for the sale of stallions’ semen, lead to the conclusion that this is indeed an integrated stud operation and that the dominant use of each of the parcels of land … was for the maintenance of animals for the purpose of selling their bodily produce or natural increase," the ruling read.
"The evidence that racing prowess (of the horse and of its progeny in due course) is an important factor in the pricing able to be commanded for the sale of stallions’ semen, lead to the conclusion that this is indeed an integrated stud operation." - Justice Ward
Justice Ward concluded that the ‘primary production’ exemption applied and that the existing Land Tax Assessments should be set aside.
The ruling is subject to appeal from the Chief Commissioner, but should it stand, then it shapes as an important precedent in retaining the status of thoroughbred breeding operations, especially those with racing arms, as 'primary production'.