Cover image courtesy of Bronwen Healy
For Hole, Saturday’s win was the climax of an experiment in which she translated an eye finely tuned from years of experience with non-thoroughbreds, evidently with remarkable success.
Having for many years produced and judged a variety of sport horses, in 2008 Blenheim-based breeder Hole decided she was going to take a more commercial approach and turned to thoroughbreds. Armed with an astute advisor in Bruce Perry, she returned from a trip to Sydney with the Encosta De Lago broodmare Femme Britannia, a $95,000 purchase from the Inglis Sydney Broodmare Sale.
Choice (NZ) and Manzoice as a foal at Bhima Thoroughbreds | Image courtesy of Stephanie Hole
Fourteen years of careful cultivation of the family and it’s now one that’s able to boast Classic glory. Reflecting on her biggest day yet as a breeder, Hole told TDN AusNZ:
“I was excited about the fact that I had a horse in a Group 1 race. I knew Chris had a high opinion of him, but that was past my wildest expectations.
“I was excited about the fact that I had a horse (Manzoice) in a Group 1 race. I knew Chris (Waller) had a high opinion of him, but that was past my wildest expectations.” - Stephanie Hole
“I’ve always thought he was special, he just had that look about him as a baby - it was jaw-dropping to look at him. You know when something’s special, and you pick it when they know too.”
With her small and select band of broodmares, you might pass off Hole’s adoration for a young Manzoice as typical and understandable sentimentality of a small owner/breeder. The truth, however, is that her judgement of the horse as having ‘that look’ is informed by 40 years of breeding and judging sport horses, and extends to her whole approach now that she’s selecting and breeding thoroughbreds.
If Saturday’s victory wasn’t conviction enough, consider the story of how she landed on her foundation mare back in 2008.
“I went with Bruce Perry (to Sydney), he’s helped me on and off for years with upgrading my mares. That was my first venture into wanting a commercial mare. I went there with my own list, but of course, that was quite different to Bruce’s list.
Bruce Perry and Mark Chittick | Image courtesy of Bronwen Healy
“She (Femme Britannia) wasn’t on Bruce’s list, but he knew quite a bit of the background on the horse. I saw her in the ring and pulled his arm off, saying: ‘I want her!’
“He was frantically trying to go through the pedigree and started hesitantly putting up his hand hoping somebody would outbid him, but I wouldn’t let him stop.
“I’ve judged horses for a lot of years and somehow I just had to have her.”
Diving into how exactly she judges horses, apart from the ones that jump out at her, Hole says it starts with conformation.
“It’s definitely conformation. If the conformation’s not right, I don’t give a hoot about the pedigree but, of course, I want both.
“It’s definitely conformation. If the conformation’s not right, I don’t give a hoot about the pedigree but, of course, I want both.” - Stephanie Hole
“How can you go wrong with an Encosta De Lago mare in foal to Fastnet Rock? Apart from the fact that she slipped the Fastnet Rock foal at 10-and-a-half months… so you can go wrong.”
Fortunately, that stark introduction to breeding thoroughbreds wasn’t enough to put Hole off the game, though she admitted it certainly affected her.
“I snivelled for a while, then my husband told me that if it’s too hot in the kitchen it’s time to get out so I thought I’d better buck my ideas up.”
European bloodlines
With her well-established eye for a horse in her armoury and a determination to breed the type of horse that New Zealand has historically been so successful with, there was one style of stallion that piqued Hole’s interest as she began cultivating matings to Femme Britannia.
“I love the European type, and I particularly loved Mastercraftsman when I saw him. When I see something I like I’m pretty hard to sway. It was really hard that first year to get into Mastercraftsman, I had to work pretty hard to get past Steve (Till) at Windsor to get my mare in but we made that hurdle.”
Mastercraftsman (Ire)
Those at Windsor Park Stud will be glad in the end that they relented to Hole’s persistence because the result was Femme Britannia’s third foal and dam of Manzoice, Choice (NZ).
Raced by Hole, Choice flew the flag for the nascent family. In her own Classic year she placed second in the Listed Soliloquy S. before taking out the G3 Eulogy S., racing a total of 17 times for three victories.
However, for all that Hole remembers that achievement with a touch of fondness, Choice didn’t escape her commercial tendency.
“Choice I did put through the sales, but she didn’t meet her reserve and I was quite happy to carry on with her. I was happy with a second in the Soliloquy and then a win in the Eulogy, that was the epitome for me then, never even dreaming of something like a Victoria Derby.”
Repeat business
Choice was bred back to Almanzor (Fr) last year and there was some impeccable timing at play with the arrival of a sister to Manzoice on Saturday afternoon.
Almanzor (Fr) | Standing at Cambridge Stud
“She had the filly (foal) an hour before the race. All my horses live at Wentwood Grange, and of course, all the Hawkins boys were over for She’s Licketysplit’s run, and so it was left to Des (Hawkins) to foal her.
“When he talked to me after the race he said: ‘Thank goodness she foaled before the race - it would have been far too big a responsibility afterwards.’
“Wentwood Grange are amazing how they look after me, I’m absolutely blessed to be, well… it feels like you’re part of the family.”
“Wentwood Grange are amazing how they look after me, I’m absolutely blessed to be, well… it feels like you’re part of the family.” - Stephanie Hole
This year Choice won’t be returning to Almanzor, as Hole has identified an alternative mating that she’s keen to try. And, with her keen eye so far providing an enviable track record, it could be worth taking note of her selection.
“I’ve actually committed to Tarzino. I just think it suits her, he’s started to put his hand up with some nice Group winners for a young horse.
“New Zealand horses are stayers as far as I’m concerned. How can we compete with Australia to breed sprinters? So, let’s try to do that well, and I think he’s going to do that.”
“New Zealand horses are stayers as far as I’m concerned. How can we compete with Australia to breed sprinters? So, let’s try to do that well, and I think he’s (Tarzino) going to do that.” - Stephanie Hole
Hole admitted that her “non-horsey husband” might be a little worried about how things could escalate following such a significant victory on Saturday, but promised that her focus is on quality not quantity.
“At the moment I think he’s basking in a bit of rubbed-off glory, but I don’t think I’ve got plans to get bigger. I think the only thing is to get better, there’s always something that can come off the bottom and hopefully something that can come in at the top.
“I’m not sure Choice was at the top of my broodmare band before yesterday but she sure is now.”
Patience rewarded
For Henry Plumptre of Cambridge Stud, Saturday’s victory came as something of a testament to the faith breeders have placed in Almanzor. Despite that his first two crops of yearlings have rewarded supporters at the sales, there’s nothing quite like a first-crop Classic winner for a stallion who promised to excel with exactly that type.
Henry Plumptre | Image courtesy of Cambridge Stud
“It’s what a studmaster who’s got a staying-type of stallion says, that they’re going to produce Classic 3-year-olds,” Plumptre noted in his typically jovial manner.
“Going into the race we thought our best chance was the horse which went to the paddock, Virtuous Circle…but Liam Howley has been very sensible with him and put him away as he thinks he’s got a really nice horse on his hands.”
That omission still left Almanzor double-handed heading into Saturday’s feature, with the Danny O’Brien-trained King’s Crossing (NZ) also being by the Cambridge shuttler. With Manzoice having run eighth in the G1 Spring Champion S. only seven days prior, Plumptre admitted that he wasn’t overly confident at how he’d handle the assignment, and paid tribute to trainer Chris Waller for a remarkable turnaround.
“You just cannot underestimate Chris Waller’s capacity to produce a horse right on a big day,” he said. “I thought that was the most phenomenal training effort to get that horse to win yesterday - running a week ago, coming down to Melbourne, putting a new jockey on him, it was just phenomenal really.”
“You just cannot underestimate Chris Waller’s capacity to produce a horse right on a big day.” - Henry Plumptre
A string of firsts
Pointing out the adroitness of Manzoice’s breeder, Plumptre said: “Stephanie is a great lady… I think she was pretty much the first person to book a mare to Almanzor when we brought him out. So, when Choice came to us she was just about the first mare on the register.”
Now the provider of Almanzor's first Group 1, Manzoice was also the first yearling by Almanzor to sell in the Southern Hemisphere, when he realised $340,000 to the bid of Waller Racing and Mulcaster Bloodstock at the 2021 Magic Millions Gold Coast Yearling Sale from the draft of Bhima Thoroughbreds.
Manzoice as a yearling | Image courtesy of Magic Millions
Almanzor’s sale-topper made $800,000 on the Gold Coast, also sold by Bhima, and, with his progeny generally performing very well in subsequent sales across Australia, Plumptre has every reason to be positive that Manzoice is far from a one-off for the stallion.
“We’ve got fairly solid feedback about probably eight or 10 of them in Australia that are going well, and the ones that have got exposed form… we know that they go well. It does bode well for the future, as long as they’re not pushed too hard.”
Turning the tide
The Australian contingent made a big impact at last week’s Tattersalls Autumn Horses In Training Sale and, with the ever-increasing prizemoney levels in Australia offering a boon for top-class staying prospects, one might wonder how much this will translate to a boost for New Zealand breeders. However, with all his experience, Plumptre won’t draw any conclusions too soon.
“It’s a very fashion-driven industry. The exodus to the UK to start buying stayers to bring down here happened because the consensus was, rightly or wrongly, that New Zealand had stopped producing decent stayers.
“It’s a very fashion-driven industry. The exodus to the UK to start buying stayers to bring down here happened because the consensus was, rightly or wrongly, that New Zealand had stopped producing decent stayers.” - Henry Plumptre
“Even though they had a stallion of Savabeel’s calibre and Tavistock was winning Classics, there was this perception that they weren’t breeding the sort of stayers that the Australian market wanted.
“You only have to have a couple of English stayers to come down and perform well for that whole marketplace to take off. And it’s not only about bringing about an English stayer down - for a lot of people in Australia it’s a great trip to Tattersalls, an enjoyable way to spend a week.”
Whilst Plumptre pointed out that Australia’s premier trainers take a particularly professional approach to sourcing imports, he also noted that trends have long been a feature in a game beholden to subjectivity.
“Once a trend starts in our industry it tends to be followed for a while… if the Australians want to come, they’ll come, and it won’t be through pushing and prodding, because there’s no shortage of information about stallions in New Zealand.
Manzoice winning the G1 Victoria Derby | Image courtesy of Bronwe Healy
“It’s all performance-related. If we’re not performing in Australia, there will be a lack of interest. But, I think the New Zealand-breds have had a pretty amazing two years in terms of competitiveness.”
For all that he won’t be pushed into marking a renaissance of Kiwi breeding, Plumptre is understandably delighted that Almanzor has gained a first Group 1 winner, and is looking forward to him covering a full book of mares this year, one of excellent quality too.
“If you consider that he has mares like Probabeel and Amarelinha at the top of his list, those are the sort of calibre of mares he’s got in his top 25 or 30.
“Those sorts of mares are the future for us… It keeps us all going,” Plumptre concluded.