In March 1998, the first diagnosed case of Japanese encephalitis virus (JEV) occurred in Australia. It came from a man who worked off a boat on the west coast of Cape York, and it was the first confirmed outbreak of the mosquito-borne virus on the Australian mainland.
At the time, a number of cases were also discovered in pigs that were being monitored for infection, while a second case in the human population was reported in the same month in the Torres Strait.
Blood samples were taken from over 450 individuals in two Cape York communities and, with no infections detected, Australian authorities ruled out a need for vaccination.
That was in May 1998, nearly 25 years ago. The understanding was, and still is, that JEV is prevalent in tropical and subtropical climates of Asia and the Pacific Rim, that it affects wading birds like herons and egrets, and that domestic pigs are amplifying hosts.
The Japanese encephalitis virus transmission cycle | Image courtesy of DPI NSW
In humans, JEV is responsible for around 68,000 worldwide human cases annually, but of those, less than one per cent result in clinical disease. As such, humans are largely asymptomatic, but when it occurs otherwise, it can be very serious. In symptomatic cases, 20 to 30 per cent are known to be fatal and, among the survivors, up to half may suffer ongoing neurological problems.
From 1998 until recently, JEV has only been considered a concern for Australian travellers to endemic regions. Even with a significant outbreak in the Torres Strait in 1995, where two out of three confirmed human cases were fatal, it remained relatively contained until the first detection on the Australian mainland.
Scientists studied the movement of mosquitoes into Cape York in 1998. They looked at whether Tropical Cyclone Sid had a part to play in December 1997, along with a severe El Niño event that caused severe drought in western Papua New Guinea.
Either way, JEV had arrived in Australia and it was detected on the mainland once again in 2004. Continual testing had identified the virus in the Torres Strait in 10 out of 11 years between 1995 and 2005, either in mosquito, pig or human samples, after which mosquito trapping trials and sentinel pig populations (pigs contained for detection) were discontinued.
Fast forward to this year and the unprecedented emergence of JEV in mainland Australia has taken a lot of people by surprise. The eastern states, as far south as Victoria, have each been affected, representing ‘an outbreak of high clinical and public health significance’.
...the unprecedented emergence of JEV in mainland Australia has taken a lot of people by surprise. The eastern states, as far south as Victoria, have each been affected, representing ‘an outbreak of high clinical and public health significance’.
Human cases across multiple jurisdictions in early 2022 prompted the declaration of this outbreak as a Communicable Disease Incident of National Significance and, according to a pathology paper in July, with the possibility of JEV becoming endemic in Australia, a serious approach to animal, human and environmental health was urgently required.
What about horses?
As of March this year, JEV had been diagnosed in New South Wales, Victoria, South Australia and Queensland, and primarily in residents or visitors to the Murray River.
The current G4 genotype of the virus, which has traditionally been only found in Indonesia and Papua New Guinea up to this point, is suggesting it’s a new introduction, possibly by mosquitoes or migratory birds.
What is especially interesting to the current outbreak is that horses, not previously in the limelight, have been front and centre in headlines about JEV this year, and this is where the valuable bloodstock industry has had to sit up and take note.
On March 7, the federal Department of Agriculture, Water and the Environment issued an emergency animal disease alert for horse owners. It stated that JEV was spread by mosquitoes, that waterbirds acted as natural reservoirs for the virus and that, via mosquitoes, JEV was spreadable to people, horses, pigs and other animals.
Mosquito life cycle | Image courtesy of DPI NSW
In this instance, ‘other animals’ included livestock, dogs, cats, rodents, reptiles and birds, but signs of the disease were most common in pigs and horses. When it came to horses, most cases were subclinical, or asymptomatic, and horses, as are people, are ‘dead-end hosts’, meaning they’re unable to share the virus around.
Still, JEV did have the potential to be fatal, as it has since proven.
From March 7, notifications from the federal government came steadily. Most weren’t specific to horse owners, but webinars for equine vets started to spring up. In May, an equine health webinar occurred that addressed biosecurity risks from JEV and other horse sicknesses like Hendra.
Immediately, JEV was a nationally notifiable disease, which meant that any animal with suspected symptoms had to be reported to the Emergency Animal Disease Hotline. It has been reported that as many as 35 ‘highly probable’ cases of JEV have been detected in horses in New South Wales and Queensland, including three deaths and possibly more from unreported cases.
Immediately, JEV (Japanese encephalitis virus) was a nationally notifiable disease, which meant that any animal with suspected symptoms had to be reported to the Emergency Animal Disease Hotline.
In New South Wales, as of May, cases had been picked up in horses from the North Coast, Greater Sydney, Central West and Riverina. Because of JEV’s similarity to Hendra, the Department of Primary Industries (DPI) in New South Wales recommended extreme caution with any suspected cases.
Symptoms to watch out for include elevated temperature, yellowing around the eyes, mouth and nose (jaundice), lethargy, loss of appetite and anything unusual neurologically, including poor eyesight, difficulty swallowing and incoordination.
For everyday horse owners, not least those with 150 or more breeding thoroughbreds on site, these could be symptoms of many things. JEV’s incubation period in horses is between four and 14 days, and the usual precautions against it include fly rugs and masks, repellent and stabling with fans.
JEV’s incubation period in horses is between four and 14 days, and the usual precautions against it include fly rugs and masks, repellent and stabling with fans | Image courtesy of Bronwen Healy
While the DPI admitted the challenges of isolating JEV from other similar mosquito-borne viruses like Murray Valley encephalitis and West Nile/Kunjin virus, it was clear that JEV was escalating, not helped by unprecedented flooding the length of Australia’s east coast in 2022.
Lessons hard-learned
A fortnight ago, Thoroughbred Breeders Australia (TBA) announced that all staff working on farms in flood-affected regions were eligible for a free vaccination against JEV. It had taken the TBA just a few weeks of lobbying.
Tom Reilly, the TBA’s CEO, spoke to TDN AusNZ this week about the JE virus, and he said that the organisation was very conscious of the serious environmental factors.
“Previously, JEV was something that wasn’t broadly seen across Australia,” he said. “But now we’ve got this situation where something that was confined to Queensland up until very recently is being widely detected everywhere else, and we here at the TBA are very conscious of the issue of a changing environment.
“We’ve had floods this year, drought in other years and changing temperatures, and JEV is a classic example of a disease which was marginal, in terms of its spread, now becoming much more mainstream.”
“JEV is a classic example of a disease which was marginal, in terms of its spread, now becoming much more mainstream.” - Tom Reilly
TBA, via Agrifutures Australia, is regularly involved in research commissions, and when Foot and Mouth Disease (FMD) emerged earlier this year, it commissioned research from Dr Robert Hedlefs, an associate professor of state veterinary medicine at James Cook University and a former regional manager for the Queensland Government.
Initially, the research was directed at preparing the racing industry response to an outbreak of FMD in Australia and the associated problems with stock movement, but it has since been expanded to cover responses to other exotic diseases, including JEV.
TBA’s action on JEV has been front-footed, but when it came to the vaccination announcement a fortnight ago, things were double-edged. The human vaccine would be free but there was a shortage.
Tom Reilly | Image courtesy of Bronwen Healy
“That’s why people need to make an appointment to have it, and there are other restrictions in terms of you needing to work in agriculture, etc.,” Reilly said. “But anyone that fits the criteria will be able to get it, regardless of shortage.”
The flooding emergencies have exacerbated the JEV situation in 2022, but Reilly said that even before it, JEV was on the radar. Disease response was high on the agenda for TBA pre-flooding, and that is perhaps a legacy of the devastating equine influenza (EI) so many years ago.
“Disease surveillance in Australia is very good as a result of EI because we’ve experienced what the consequences can be,” Reilly said.
“Disease surveillance in Australia is very good as a result of EI (equine influenza) because we’ve experienced what the consequences can be.” - Tom Reilly
The EI outbreak of 2007/08 delivered Australia a lot of lessons.
For bloodstock breeders, it delivered lifelong memories of stress, impacted productivity and damaged finances. These are lessons hard-learned, but it’s made Australian breeders very receptive to anything that will stop a repeat of the same.
“Breeders know what EI did to the industry, and all its ramifications,” Reilly said. “They understand all the drama people went through and it’s made them aware of serious diseases and aware of the risk profile. As such, they were very supportive of getting this research up and going this year with Agrifutures.”
Cause for alarm?
Through June and July this year, the NSW State Government conducted a serosurvey on JEV in specific regions. It concentrated on people living in and around the townships of Balranald, Corowa, Dubbo, Griffith and Temora because there was evidence that infected mosquitoes had been present in these regions in the earlier months of the year.
All staff working on stud farms in flood-affected areas of Victoria are eligible to be vaccinated against the Japanese encephalitis virus | Image courtesy of the World Health Organisation
Of the 1048 blood samples that were provided, along with a completed questionnaire, one in 11 participants (or 8.7 per cent) had evidence of JEV infection. According to the NSW State Government, the results indicated that JEV was prevalent in these regions and may have affected a large number of people.
At the moment, and probably because of the floods in Victoria and New South Wales, it feels like JEV is on the rise. It probably is as the virus looks to become endemic, but words like ‘emergency’ and ‘outbreak’, while unsettling, aren’t meant to cause alarm, particularly among the horse population.
“I’m not sure anyone really knows how serious it is yet,” Reilly said. “Because it’s so hard to get a definitive positive result, we don’t know really if lots more horses have it, or have had it, that just don’t get seriously ill. We also don’t know if the mortality rate is definitively true to the number of horses that get it and die from it.”
“Because it’s so hard to get a definitive positive result, we don’t know really if lots more horses have it (JEV), or have had it, that just don’t get seriously ill. We also don’t know if the mortality rate is definitively true to the number of horses that get it and die from it.” - Tom Reilly
The window to get a positive test from JEV is very small in horses. Samples must be collected in the acute stages of the virus or, in the case of fatality, from an animal that has been dead less than 12 hours.
Among asymptomatic horses, it’s impossible to be prompted for testing, and even if symptoms are present, they might not be serious or they might be down to something entirely different. As a result, it could be an easy thing to miss.
“The question is, are people testing in a timely enough way to make sure they get a positive result?” Reilly said. “Is that process speedy enough?”
Trainers, breeders and wider horse owners are well-versed in equine diseases. Along with EI and Hendra, there is the everyday threat of strangles and tetanus, so largely, Reilly has every faith that the industry will act responsibly when it comes to JEV.
“I think JEV is something that we need to watch closely, and we need to consider it accordingly,” he said. “Yes, we are in peak summer conditions and there is a lot of stagnant water hanging around, and that raises the risk profile. But we need to consider it as part of a changing environment, and vector-borne diseases that were once limited in impacting the broader horse population, they’re changing now.
“I think JEV is something that we need to watch closely... we need to consider it as part of a changing environment, and vector-borne diseases that were once limited in impacting the broader horse population, they’re changing now.” - Tom Reilly
“We need to be thinking about JEV in that light, not as a seasonal one-off but as something that farms around the country are now going to have to take into regular consideration.”