Cover image courtesy of Bronwen Healy
This week in TDN AusNZ, a number of farms went on the record about the unusual covering season they’ve experienced through the spring of 2022. There were others that spoke to us off-record, backing up a season of feedback we’ve had that things have been different this year.
For all of these farms and smaller breeders, ‘different’ hasn’t meant disastrous. It’s meant that statistics are reading slightly below previous good years, or mares have had to return to stallions two and three times. It has meant some pregnancies haven’t eventuated, but that would be no different to any other season.
So, what has made the 2022 covering season a point of conversation?
Firstly, there is a widespread number of breeders reporting that usually fertile stallions are revisiting mares with much more regularity this spring, and the same applies the other way around. Boutique breeders can’t explain why mares that have never had issues getting in foal are suddenly having trouble this year.
It’s been a year like no other in Australasia when it comes to weather and, for the valuable breeding industries on both sides of the Tasman, the consequences have been rippling | Image courtesy of Bronwen Healy
Larger farms are reporting perfect health records for stallions but no explainable reason why fertility is down, even slightly, and especially when thorough veterinary checks have been made across the board and all is looking perfectly normal.
Studmasters are therefore perfectly entitled to scratch their heads and wonder what is going on when nothing is seemingly amiss, because if all the boxes are ticked perfectly, which they are in professional outfits, why are the numbers not quite aligning with previous years?
These are the facts of the 2022 breeding season. They might not be industry-wide, but they’ve popped up with unusual regularity since September this year.
Talking about it is healthy because this is a valuable industry that is driven by statistics and knowing why fertility is even slightly down across a geographic spread from the Hunter Valley to the Waikato is important.
Mares and foals at Waikato Stud | Image courtesy of Waikato Stud
And, while it’s easy to assume that breeders who do go on record must be the only ones having issues, in fact, their voices are strongly representative of a much wider layer of feedback that we’ve had all spring.
Consequences of weather
With the symptoms of the 2022 covering season discussed, it’s important to consider what might have caused the slight shift in normality this spring. Overwhelmingly, each breeder we spoke to said the weather patterns of 2022 had to be at play because, in most cases, no one has experienced a year like it when it came to rain.
According to the Bureau of Meteorology, overall spring rainfall was up 112 per cent on average across the whole of Australia, making it the second-wettest spring on record behind 2010. The national mean temperature this spring was subsequently down, even further down when adjusted to area average.
According to the Bureau of Meteorology, overall spring rainfall was up 112 per cent on average across the whole of Australia, making it the second-wettest spring on record behind 2010.
Across the Murray-Darling region, rainfall clocked its highest on record and, for Australia overall, only small pockets of southwest Western Australia and southwest Tasmania hit below-average rainfall. And, remember, these are just spring statistics. They don’t take into account the rest of 2022’s wet weather.
In other words, most of Australia endured a drenching this year, and most of the industry’s breeding stock stood out in it. While horses posted common ailments like seedy toe, thrush, abscesses and white line disease, what’s harder to measure is whether prolonged exposure to wet ground and rainfall has affected fertility.
All horse owners acknowledge the depressing sight of horses with their backs to the rain, sodden in the mud and weeks, in some cases months, of dreadful grazing. Could this have impacted the fertility of breeding mares?
“I can’t argue against the weather being a factor,” said Dr Wendy Perriam, Arrowfield’s chief veterinarian. Perriam has been with Arrowfield for the last 12 years and in veterinary practice since 1992. She’s seen a lot.
Dr Wendy Perriam | Image courtesy of Arrowfield Stud
“The weather has been particularly interesting, and certainly early it was,” she said. “It’s back to being what I would consider fairly normal now, but that’s only in the last few days. We’ve been in jeans and jumpers for the entire season really.”
From Perriam’s perspective, the excessive rainfall has to be considered.
“Whether it’s created some leaching in the soils or a shift in the pastures, or whether it’s related to some runoff effect in relation to something like nitrates, it’s impossible to say right now,” she said. “It’s totally speculative, but what we can say was very physically apparent was the amount of water lying around.”
“Whether it’s (the weather) created some leaching in the soils or a shift in the pastures, or whether it’s related to some runoff effect in relation to something like nitrates, it’s impossible to say right now.” - Dr Wendy Perriam
The possibility of soil leaching is an important one.
Perriam admits she isn’t an agronomist, but a very recent soil study in the Upper Hunter by an agronomist suggested a ‘regional trend of leached nutrients, including nitrogen and sulphur and trace elements, coming through soil tests’. These tests were not conducted on Arrowfield pastures, but in Perriam’s own words, it’s not a stretch to consider that extreme wet weather may have, or have had, some impact in low-lying areas.
Very few breeding farms were spared the sheer volume of rainwater that settled on Australia this year. If higher paddocks managed well, lower paddocks were awash. As recently as last month, a number of Victorian farms were underwater with catastrophic floods.
What this prolonged rainfall might also have led to was long periods of time where horses were standing still. In blunt weather, stock often doesn’t move but stands with its hindquarters into the worst of things. In better years, horses would have been much more mobile, so could this have affected fertility?
“Again, it’s all speculative right now,” Perriam said.
The science
For Perriam, who is trained to understand the science of things, it’s been a baffling season but a fascinating one from a veterinary perspective. She’s interested in the measurable difference of this season to previous seasons, not hearsay.
“The statistical side of this conversation is really important,” she said. “In the fullness of time, we’ll go back through the season’s records, as we always do, to better understand season-on-season differences. At this point, we’re just waiting for a number of our wet mares to be tested.”
One of the interesting things about Arrowfield’s covering stats this season is that the farm’s dry mares have performed remarkably well.
Arrowfield's dry mare covering stats this season show they have performed remarkably well | Image courtesy of Arrowfield Stud
“We have looked at those already and they’re at 86 per cent seasonal pregnancy,” Perriam said. “So our dry and maiden mares have been absolutely fine, with the statistics on those being excellent. Where we’ve seen more of a concern, as a generalisation, is with our wet mares, which is a little bit fascinating because they’re managed in a very similar way and in a very similar environment.”
In line with this, is it worth questioning the brevity of opportunity to breed wet mares in this part of the world? These days, there are early sale pressures around foaling dates, which might subsequently have an effect on the pregnancy-rate cycle.
“For a dry mare or a maiden mare, there’s less concern because we can start breeding them in early September, and we will readily have two or three cycles without hesitation before we start looking at or predicting foaling dates,” Perriam said.
“Whereas a mare that’s set to foal in late September or early October, she’s may only have one or two cycles to a stallion before he's put away for the year, and if you look at the industry standard for pregnancy rate per cycle, we’re going to be missing mares, not because they’ve been overly problematic but because they’re just not afforded the right opportunity to conceive.”
“...if you look at the industry standard for pregnancy rate per cycle, we’re going to be missing mares, not because they’ve been overly problematic but because they’re just not afforded the right opportunity to conceive.” - Dr Wendy Perriam
There are broader, complicated terms at play here, things like the pregnancy rate per cycle being a true measure of fertility, and the seasonal pregnancy rate is what is widely talked about in the breeding industry because that is the figure that is settled upon at the end of the year.
“A seasonal pregnancy rate is very much impacted by how many cycles the mare is sent to the stallion,” Perriam said. “That’s easily demonstrated by using the example of a stallion with round figures of breeding 100 mares to a 50 per cent pregnancy rate per cycle; after the first cycle, half of them will be in foal and half of them not. After the second cycle, a further 25 per cent will be in foal, and 25 per cent not.”
If the remaining empty mares are provided an opportunity to be bred to that stallion again, his seasonal pregnancy rate could then statistically climb to 85 per cent.
For Perriam, it’s a good example of how loss of opportunity late in the season can readily impact seasonal-fertility numbers. Using this example, the seasonal pregnancy rate after two cycles is 75 per cent, but after three cycles it is a theoretical 86 to 87 per cent. This doesn’t necessarily explain some of the oddities of 2022, but it is a critical cog in the wider conversation.
It would be easy to assume that stallion fertility is down this spring, but that’s an almost-lazy presumption given all the balls that are in the air regarding fertility.
Large-scale studies on fertility that have been done in this part of the world in the past have also eventuated that the majority of variation on fertility is associated with mare factors, and not stallion or stud farm factors, and this is what vets like Perriam are poring through right now.
Large-scale studies on fertility that have been done in this part of the world in the past have also eventuated that the majority of variation on fertility is associated with mare factors, and not stallion or stud farm factors...
“When you are only looking at a small potential reduction in pregnancy rates across many different management systems, it’s always going to be hard to pinpoint a cause, or to be dogmatic about anything in particular,” she said. “Each season has its challenges and, over time, they tend to even out.
“It is interesting to note that there were outstanding fertility stats during the drought, which seems counterintuitive at face value but we had basically absolute control of mare nutrition due to sparse access to pasture.”
We don’t select on fertility
Understanding the science behind this spring’s challenges is important. Most breeders have been in the game long enough to accept that some seasons will be flawless and others challenging, but data on why certain seasons present problems is useful in both a present and future tense.
In the case of 2022, the enormity of rainfall has been a consistent conversation among all breeders, so isn’t it logical to land on the weather being a possible factor this breeding season? Whether that it is in the shape of wet ground or ‘depressed’ horses who have stood out in it for a long time, or in the shape of soil leaching, remains to be seen.
“I think it’s also important to be reminded in this conversation that in the equine game, we do not select for fertility,” Perriam said. “We have to be very mindful of being an industry that selects for athleticism and pedigree, and, perhaps to a smaller degree, type.”
“I think it’s also important to be reminded in this conversation that in the equine game, we do not select for fertility.” - Dr Wendy Perriam
For most farms across the breeding regions of Australia, it’s been a long, exhaustive season. Scrutiny about fertility can be unwelcome at this end of things, which is fair enough after months of careful process.
There are a lot of questions still remaining about what might have caused some of the unusual patterns experienced across the covering season this year, and those questions may or may not ever be answered, but raising them in the first place is an important discourse.
Do you have thoughts on this subject? We would love to hear from you, contact vicky@tdnausnz.com.au