Cover image courtesy of Inglis
With the introduction in August last year of the $30,000 VOBIS Sires Boost Vouchers, it was expected that at least some impact might be seen as the sales show rolled into Melbourne this year.
Early influence negligible
The vouchers are obtained by winning any one of the VOBIS Gold bonus races run throughout Victoria, and entitle the winning owners to spend the amount on progeny of a VOBIS-nominated sire at the major yearling sales (including via syndicators), or they can use it towards a nomination to a VOBIS Sires service fee.
Alongside the longer-standing VOBIS Sires race series, it all sounds quite appealing. However, pedigree pages stamped with VOBIS Sires have for the last five years, barring 2019, sold for a discount on average against those that aren’t.
Representing anywhere between 21.9 and 25.1 per cent of the horses sold in that time, the ‘penalty’ against VOBIS Sires’ eligible yearlings is not straightforward. It may be explained by some simple geography though. If you take it that a Victorian breeder is more likely to take a yearling to a local sale than travel to the likes of Inglis Easter or the Gold Coast in January with their mid to lower-tier stock, then it makes sense that this would distort the average. Or, you could argue that it reflects an historical weakness in the Victorian stallion ranks. Either way, it’s inconclusive.
What is conclusive, though, is that the introduction of VOBIS Sires Boost vouchers has had no discernible effect on the Premier sale just yet. The premium paid for a non-VOBIS Sires eligible horse was 16.6 per cent in 2022, a figure which in fact grew to 17.3 this year. Hopefully though, as awareness of the generous scheme grows and more vouchers are awarded, it will ensure greater demand for VOBIS yearlings.
Strength in the middle
One metric that matched the exceptionally high median and average of the Premier sale in 2022 was the number of top-end buyers - that is, the number of different entities that signed for the most expensive 25 per cent of horses. It jumped to 102 that year, though Inglis will be pleased to see that figure sit at 84 after this year’s sale, higher than the pre-COVID levels.
That the average at the top quarter was able to jump up by nearly $50,000 from 2020 to 2021 whilst the median dropped by $5000, suggesting that the strength of the Premier sale is in its middle market. The lower-end average supports this too; it rose by around $2000 from 2020 to 2021, then jumped nearly $10,000 into 2022, whilst the median rose by $35,000 in the same time and the top-end average actually dropped by nearly $2000.
This all points to the weight of the middle market affecting results, and makes sense when you consider that the Premier sale doesn’t tend to feature the volume of expensive lots that hold up the top-end of sales such as the Magic Millions Gold Coast Yearling Sale in January. Inglis’ own Easter Yearling Sale, then, will be informative.
Chart: The average price amongst the top 25 per cent of horses sold at the past five Inglis Premier Yearling Sales
Average Hong Kong and NZ spend down
Whilst the average spend of purchasers from the three largest racing states, New South Wales, Victoria and Queensland followed the market trend this year, and bought at a rate slightly lower than the 2022 average, there were some notable anomalies amongst others.
Buyers from Hong Kong bought more than ever this year, a total of 36 yearlings, up from 25 last year and a previous high of 32 in 2020. However, their average spend was the lowest it’s been in the last five years at $141,667. It’s interesting to note that their total spend was a healthy $5.1 million though, compared to a high of $5.53 million last year.
Chart: The average price paid by Hong Kong-based buyers at the past five Inglis Premier Yearling Sales
The average spend from New Zealand buyers dropped significantly too ($95,357), dipping to below six figures for the first time since 2018. At eight apiece, fewer horses were purchased by Kiwi-based buyers in the two COVID-affected years, and the average for those shot up to over $120,000.
Colts vs fillies
The top 10 lots this year at Premier were dominated by eight colts against two fillies, though those two fillies (both by I Am Invincible) also filled the top two spots in the sale overall. The trend, with a significant 10 per cent premium, however, was that colts were more expensive - commanding an average of $140,747.
Whilst the 2019 sale saw an even higher colts’ premium of 14.9 per cent, it dropped suddenly the following year and has been climbing steadily up again ever since.
Colts' premium
Chart: The premium paid for colts at the past five Inglis Premier Yearling Sales