Cover image courtesy of Racing Photos
Two-year-old colt Butch Cassidy was an interesting winner at Mornington on Tuesday for the James Harron Bloodstock Colts syndicate, winning the opening event over 1200 metres by 2l.
He was lining up for the second time in his career after a debut second at Flemington on March 4 in the Listed Furphy Plate, and he led home Arizona Activist (Written Tycoon) for Lindsay Park and the Roll The Dice Racing colt, Tymon (Rubick).
Butch Cassidy is trained at the Flemington base of Gai Waterhouse and Adrian Bott, and in a previous preparation in Sydney he’d won both his trials. He had a very good record ahead of his maiden win therefore, and he won like the short-priced favourite that he was.
Surprising all round
Butch Cassidy was co-bred by breeder Rob Chapman from the Dream Ahead (USA) mare Rose Ahead. She, herself, was a $52,000 yearling in 2015 at the Magic Millions Adelaide Yearling Sale when selling to Mark Kavanagh Racing from a Mill Park draft.
The pedigree isn’t especially obvious, and when Butch Cassidy was purchased by Harron at the 2022 Magic Millions Gold Coast Yearling Sale for $750,000, it surprised his vendor, Milburn Creek, the most.
“He was foaled and reared here with us from a client mare,” said Scott Holcombe, the manager at John Muir’s Milburn Creek. “He well-outsold his pedigree. We were thinking he might have sold for $300,000 or $350,000, and that would have been really good money for him, so he doubled our expectations.”
“He (Butch Cassidy) well-outsold his pedigree. We were thinking he might have sold for $300,000 or $350,000, and that would have been really good money for him, so he doubled our expectations.” - Scott Holcombe
According to Holcombe, Butch Cassidy was a fine stamp of a colt. There was nothing wrong with him physically; it was just that his page was a little light.
He was the first foal from Rose Ahead, who was a winner and a half-sister to the stakes-winners Daytona Grey (Artie Schiller {USA}) and Mail It In (Reset), but apart from that there wasn’t a lot going on in the immediate family.
So how does Holcombe explain it?
Butch Cassidy as a yearling | Image courtesy of Magic Millions
“James Harron loves a good type, and this colt was that,” he said. “He was on a number of the stallion lists at the sale and he was a ripping type. He had a great brain and looked really early, and he was the right colour. He got a couple of people really keen on him, which is all it takes.”
Butch Cassidy is that copper-coloured, sorrel chestnut colour. Coat colour isn’t a definite science when it comes to performance, but this shade is less common these days, apparently.
“He had that deep, liver chestnut going on,” Holcombe said. “It’s an old-school, beautiful colour that you don’t tend to get much anymore. It’s like an old Star Kingdom colour, but Written Tycoon has got a couple of those. He also walked like a machine, he moved just beautifully. He was pretty faultless and I didn’t hear a bad word about him.”
“He (Butch Cassidy) had that deep, liver chestnut going on. It’s an old-school, beautiful colour that you don’t tend to get much anymore. It’s like an old Star Kingdom colour...” - Scott Holcombe
When Butch Cassidy crossed the line on Tuesday, Holcombe wasn’t watching but he got a quick text from bloodstock agent Suman Hedge, who manages Rose Ahead for breeder Rob Chapman.
“He was always a very nice colt, and a surprising colt from the time he was foaled,” Hedge said, chatting with TDN AusNZ about Butch Cassidy. “His mother is a fairly moderate type. She’s no oil painting, and when we sent her to Written Tycoon for this mating there was a business relationship between her owner, Rob Chapman, and Sheriff Iskander.
“Sheriff wanted to do something with Rob and there was an element in that, doing the foal share. But we were a little bit nervous about what it might produce because both Written Tycoon and Rose Ahead are fairly long through the back.”
In the end, the resultant foal was just about perfect.
Written Tycoon | Standing at Yulong
“We were pleasantly surprised,” Hedge said. “He was a beautifully balanced horse and it worked out so much better than we expected.”
Hedge said Butch Cassidy would have qualified for any of the sales last year, but they knew the page was a bit light and, like the crew at Milburn Creek, he and Chapman were expecting a sale-average price-tag.
“When he sold for what he did, it was incredible,” Hedge said. “It was such a great result and it was a real tribute to what Scott and his team did at Milburn in the way they managed the horse and developed him, and to have him bought by one of the most preeminent judges in the country in James Harron.”
Suman Hedge | Image courtesy of Magic Millions
Good times Ahead
Rose Ahead is located these days at Middlebrook Valley Lodge in the Hunter Valley. After Butch Cassidy, she missed a season and foaled a Star Turn filly in the spring.
“It’s a very, very nice filly,” Hedge said. “We’re not sure what we’ll do with her, whether they retain to race or sell her. Rose Ahead is doing a nice job now and I’m confident this Star Turn filly will qualify for Magic Millions. She’s a forward, strong type of filly and he’s obviously a stallion that is going along nicely.
“So there’s a chance that she’ll go through the ring, but my recommendation to the breeders was to hold onto her. With the mare starting out well, it’s hard to buy into families when there are stakes performers in it. So when you’ve got one under your nose, and Rob likes racing, they might be better off hanging onto her.”
“With the mare (Rose Ahead) starting out well, it’s hard to buy into families when there are stakes performers in it. So when you’ve got one under your nose, and Rob (Chapman) likes racing, they might be better off hanging onto her (Butch Cassidy's half-sister).” - Suman Hedge
The Star Turn filly was an early September foaling, and Rose Ahead went for a pair of unsuccessful coverings before getting in foal to Zoustar on a December 3 cover. It’s a late one but, like with Butch Cassidy, it’s a foal-share arrangement.
“We figured on the back of the first one that she leaves good types, and this was all before Butch had raced,” Hedge said. “The reports coming from the stable on him were very favourable though, and James (Harron) had said to me they had a good opinion of him. So on the back of that we negotiated a foal share with Zoustar.”
Where to next for Butch?
Hedge thought Butch Cassidy was very good on Tuesday, comparably so to the horse's first performance at stakes level.
Butch Cassidy after winning at Mornington | Image courtesy of Racing Photos
“I thought he was very unlucky on debut,” he said. “It was unfortunate circumstances for the jockey and it can happen with these babies. When he got out that day, he motored home and it was a shame that he couldn’t win that stakes race early.
“But it looked like a winnable race today and it was a fairly arrogant victory. He sat behind them and you could see that the jockey was really relaxed while the others were hard at it. Then he put them away, so he’s a horse with a really progressive future.”
“... it looked like a winnable race today (Tuesday) and it was a fairly arrogant victory. He (Butch Cassidy) sat behind them and you could see that the jockey was really relaxed while the others were hard at it. Then he put them away, so he’s a horse with a really progressive future.” - Suman Hedge
Hedge is unsure what immediate targets are in store for Butch Cassidy. It will be up to Harron and Tulloch Lodge.
“Trips away always seem to help these kinds of animals,” he said. “It seasons them up and set them up for the spring. There’s not a big break between the carnivals any more, and after the winter they can often have only two or three weeks off ahead of the spring.
“Without knowing what the plans are for Butch, many a good horse has come through the winter carnival and turned out to be a nice horse in the spring. That would be a logical progression for him.”