Cover image courtesy of The Image Is Everything
Late in 2019, Australian racing had what might be coined a ‘reality check’, a moment when the foundations of the sport shook so violently that things changed forever.
It arrived via the ABC and its 7.30 program, which broadcasted unsettling treatment of racehorses in a Queensland abattoir and implied that the racing industry was washing its hands of its welfare obligations.
The ramifications were massive across the sport. Were the majority of Australian thoroughbreds ending up in slaughter houses, and if any were ending up there, whose fault was it? Was it the industry’s for failing to claim responsibility for the animals it was breeding, or was it the fault of private owners who had taken off-track horses for second careers?
Yearlings roaming in a paddock | Image courtesy of The Image Is Everything
Were things really as bad as the ABC depicted? Probably not, but the horse had bolted by then. The 7.30 program did irreparable damage to the image of racing in Australia and, ever since, the sport has been rebuilding its social licence.
There has been a huge shift in racing’s welfare agenda, with even the RSPCA paying attention. In 2020, the charity stated that ‘finally, as a result of the ABC program, racing authorities around the country have stepped up their retirement programs for horses leaving the industry’.
In truth, welfare initiatives existed long before the ABC got involved. But also in truth, they were given a second wind in the wake of the television program.
Australia’s Principal Racing Authorities (PRAs) have now established tireless reschooling and rehoming projects, and their success has been outstanding. In short, the work that has been done since has been remarkable, albeit with a way still to go.
However, one of the lingering legacies of 7.30 is the issue of traceability. Whose responsibility is it when a horse departs the racing industry and goes into private ownership? Is racing still responsible for that animal after its exit, despite the PRAs lacking the ‘jurisdiction, visibility or control over what happens after that point’?
And, is it fair to assume a responsibility by the PRAs to track the life of every racehorse long after they’ve left racing?
“It’s what we do, not just how we appear, that has to be right if we are to remain relevant,” said John Messara when we spoke to him about this issue two years ago. “Traceability rules are absolutely essential if we truly care about our horses, our sport and our industry. We must be able to demonstrate to the wider world that the status of every Australian thoroughbred is known and updated whenever it changes.”
“It’s what we do, not just how we appear, that has to be right if we (the racing industry) are to remain relevant.” - John Messara
In early 2019, months before 7.30 aired, the feasibility of a National Horse Traceability Register was deliberated by the Senate. But, as these things tend to do, red tape and obstacles were everywhere. Were horses livestock or companion animals? How many horses were we dealing with in the first place?
Since the Senate report was published in November 2019, very little movement on the issue has occurred at a national level, but at an industry level, things moved along.
In May 2021, Racing Australia instigated new traceability rules that affected breeding stock, racing stock, retired stock and unnamed horses not registered to race. They also affected property access and penalties for breach of traceability regulation.
The new rules introduced very specific timelines on things like breeders notifying the Australian Stud Book of a horse’s death, and trainers lodging stable returns for named horses entering and leaving yards or retiring.
John Messara | Image courtesy of The Image Is Everything
The idea was to provide effective tracking of Australian thoroughbreds, even beyond the realm of their racing careers.
“As I understand it, this new traceability extends the reporting rules beyond retirement, and introduces stricter penalties for people who don’t meet their traceability obligations,” Messara said at the time. “They are logical extensions of the original rules.”
Who is responsible?
Another two years on, traceability remains a conversation in horse racing.
The welfare landscape is vastly improved, with chunks of funding dedicated to welfare initiatives within the industry, and retraining programs are dotted the length and breadth of the nation. They probably were before, but their respective reach is much greater these days.
However, traceability remains the elephant in the room. There is no sign of a national register in Australia, and opinions are still divided as to whether such a national register should be industry- or federally controlled.
Also, opinions on culpability still vary.
Should the racing industry be responsible years later for racehorses that have exited the sport? And, if that horse’s future is unfortunate and it’s revealed that it was slaughtered in an abattoir years after being responsibly rehomed, who's fault is it?
Any racehorse that ends up in an abattoir will rain down negative press on the racing industry, even if the racing industry had handed over care of that horse a decade before. So is the industry on a hiding to nothing?
‘A simple but brilliant idea’
In Britain, the traceability conversation is burning just as bright, with the same realities affecting the industry as those affecting it in Australia.
“When you ask that question of whose responsibility is it, we’re of the belief that if a horse is bred for racing, anyone that touches that horse has a collective responsibility,” said Helena Flynn, programme director for the UK’s Horse Welfare Board. “That horse will always be, in the eyes of the public, an ex-racehorse.”
“When you ask that question of whose responsibility is it, we’re (the Horse Welfare Board) of the belief that if a horse is bred for racing, anyone that touches that horse has a collective responsibility. That horse will always be, in the eyes of the public, an ex-racehorse.” - Helena Flynn
The Horse Welfare Board is an independently chaired organisation in Britain that exists to push welfare initiatives in British racing, in its own words to ‘produce a strategy that unites the whole industry and drives continuous improvement’.
In early 2020, the Horse Welfare Board published its welfare bible. A Life Well Lived outlined a five-year strategic plan for the welfare of horses bred for racing, and one of the major elements of the document was traceability.
‘There are significant gaps in the industry’s knowledge of the whereabouts of thoroughbreds bred for racing,’ the document states. ‘Until those gaps are filled, we have only a partial picture of welfare standards.’
A Life Well Lived is unequivocal about the impacts to racing of negative outcomes.
‘Another view, which we partially agree with, is that racing cannot be responsible for horses that fall into difficulties several steps down the line after leaving the sport, or which are sold to, or imported from, overseas. While there is some truth in this at a practical level, it is nonetheless the high-profile sport of horseracing that would absorb the reputation risk, with any media story likely to explain that a horse was trained by this trainer, or raced at that racecourse.’
Retraining of Racehorses | Image courtesy of the Horse Welfare Board
As such, the Horse Welfare Board is motivated in the approach that racing must be able to demonstrate it had effectively looked after a horse with traced evidence of such. Racing needs to be able to prove that its former horses falling into unfortunate circumstances are the exception, not the rule, with evidence of positive outcomes, and that all reasonable efforts to ensure correct outcomes were taken.
However, it admits readily that the barriers to achieving this include lack of awareness of responsibility, lack of communication between industries, lack of effective enforcement of the rules, and other such challenges.
Helena Flynn said the Horse Welfare Board is working on a number of strategies to try and counter the problems facing thoroughbred traceability. One of them is a horse assessment process, which would ideally occur any time a current or former racehorse changes hands.
Helena Flynn | Image courtesy of the British Horseracing Authority
Flynn said the horse assessment could be a vital cog in the wider wheel of traceability.
“The horse assessment is a simple but brilliant idea,” she said. “It means that a trainer will pass the horse on to a new career, and at that point, the horse will be assessed and there will be a record of the horse’s condition at the time, supported by an image and veterinary-condition documentation. We ask then of the next person that takes that horse to do the same, and the expectation at that time is that another horse assessment is done.
“God forbid a scenario comes about like what that program aired in Australia, where one of these amazing animals ends up in a horrendous situation. If it does, you can trace back exactly through that ownership accountability what the condition of the horse was when it left this person or that person. At what point did it break down and why? This could be answered with that level of traceability.”
“The horse assessment is a simple but brilliant idea. It means that a trainer will pass the horse on to a new career, and at that point, the horse will be assessed and there will be a record of the horse’s condition at the time, supported by an image and veterinary-condition documentation.” - Helena Flynn
The horse assessment is just one of the aftercare recommendations that the Horse Welfare Board is proposing.
Another is official accreditation of aftercare centres. Like in Australia, there are countless retraining organisations that are doing good work, but also making money from rehabilitating, reschooling and selling off-the-track racehorses.
“They do amazing work but there are a lot of them,” Flynn said. “If you’re an owner of a racehorse, how do you decide which aftercare centre to go to? We want to look at the accreditation of those centres and that’s one of the things we’ll be introducing in the coming year.”
The horse passport
Very recently, the Horse Welfare Board, in partnership with Hartpury University just north of Gloucester, launched a thoroughbred census, the first of its kind in British racing.
Unlike a citizen census, the thoroughbred census will be live from June 28 to December 31, during which time owners of former racehorses are encouraged to log in online and submit answers. It is hoped the resultant data will fill knowledge gaps of what ex-racehorses do after racing and the kind of lives they lead.
In theory, these gaps in knowledge shouldn’t exist in the UK. It is law for every horse owner to own a ‘horse passport’, which is to be kept with the horse at all points of ownership and is to be handed over during veterinary examinations and when a horse is sold or rehomed.
However, the uptake of the passport is very low in the UK, as low as 20 per cent, and for many reasons.
People don’t realise they need to have one, or it’s been lost or misplaced through multiple owners. People are often wary of any sort of governmental involvement or bureaucratic red tape, but in reality, the horse passport would assist much of the traceability efforts by the Horse Welfare Board.
“The responsibility in the change of passport sits with the new owner,” said Stephen Wensley, who is the project lead at the Horse Welfare Board when it comes to welfare data. “If that new owner doesn’t update it there and then, they can often put it in a drawer and forget about it. It’s just human nature to oversee these things and the enforcement of it isn’t very effective.”
Wensley said there is an ongoing consultation for a digital passport, which will include concepts that Weatherbys has proposed. Among such concepts are a two-part ownership changeover, much like what is required when a car is sold; the old and new owner must fill out the ‘paperwork’.
“That would make a dramatic difference,” Wensley said. “It’s not finalised yet exactly what’s going to come into that proposal, but it should be coming through within the next year.”
“That (a digital horse passport) would make a dramatic difference. It’s not finalised yet exactly what’s going to come into that proposal, but it should be coming through within the next year.” - Stephen Wensley
Traceability is one of the 26 projects that the Horse Welfare Board is spearheading, and its scope is well-beyond just a thoroughbred’s racing days. It goes into the horse’s aftercare days too. This is the area that Wensley is heading up for the Horse Welfare Board.
As part of the traceability agenda, the census has been unique in that it is calling for distinct co-operation between horse industries to achieve a result, from the in-industry trainers, breeders and staff, for example, to riding schools, pony clubs, livery yards and veterinarians.
“Now, more than ever, with the questions around racing’s social licence and the welfare of the animal, it’s important to close the gap on lifetime traceability,” Flynn said. “We’ve been supported in terms of this census by World Horse Welfare, Hartpury University and Retraining of Racehorses (RoR), which is the industry’s appointed aftercare provider, along with Weatherbys.”
Horses galloping at Newmarket | Image courtesy of Emma Berry
RoR accounts for about 27 per cent of retrained racehorses in Britain. It’s a huge figure and one that the Horse Welfare Board is anxious to grow, which goes back to the importance of accreditation among aftercare organisations.
“When we were looking at how we might close the traceability gap, one of the things that we looked at was a thoroughbred census,” Flynn said. “What we’re hoping it will achieve is, obviously, improvement in the traceability of horses post-racing, but also a better support for owners of thoroughbreds through the life of that thoroughbred.”
The collective responsibility
The target audience of the census is thoroughbred owners of ex-racehorses. They are encouraged to log into the census platform in the next six months with a one-time sitdown. There is no ongoing commitment and all data is privy to confidentiality.
“There are about a dozen questions and they’re not complicated,” Wensley said. “We’ve tried to make it as easy as possible with the bare minimum of information needed to confirm the ownership of a horse, as well as getting some idea of where the horse came from and the education requirements going forward for RoR.
“The most complicated part will be the identification information that we need to verify against the stud book, things like microchip number and passport. They will need those documents readily at hand and that will be our biggest challenge, getting participants to have that information so they can share it.”
Uptake of the census has already started and feedback has been positive. It varies from ‘why wasn’t something like this done before now’ to ‘this is such a good idea’.
“One of the aspects of the census is general responsible ownership,” Wensley said. “What is it to be a responsible owner of a thoroughbred? It’s keeping things up-to-date like the passport when changing ownership, and reporting a horse has died. Those are the two big gaps at the moment.”
“What is it to be a responsible owner of a thoroughbred? It’s keeping things up-to-date like the passport when changing ownership, and reporting a horse has died. Those are the two big gaps at the moment.” - Stephen Wensley
The census is free, as is registering any British ex-racehorse with RoR. Participants must be aged over 18 and own or be the registered keeper of a thoroughbred horse that is not actively in racing.
The horse must be registered in the General Stud Book with Weatherbys, or a registered thoroughbred with an alternative racing stud book in another country. The horse must be alive and in the owner’s possession.
“We are trying to speak to every man and woman from vets to farriers to feed suppliers, just to get the message out,” Flynn said. “We want everyone to share the census far and wide. It’s that collective responsibility that if we all share it, there’s more chance of closing this gap on traceability with important intel on where these animals go and where they end up.”