Cover image courtesy of The Image Is Everything
Amongst the serious trade that goes on at any major yearling sale there are the occasional outbursts of joy. Whilst many sellers and buyers simply nod in recognition of a good result, there will be someone who chooses to instead express their satisfaction in a more vocal way.
As was the case at the 1994 Inglis Premier Yearling Sale when a new owner on the scene - determined to take home the sale's prized youngster no matter what the cost - put in the sale-topping winning bid of $220,000 for a filly from the debut crop of the G1 Golden Slipper hero Canny Lad.
When the hammer went down the buyer, along with a handful of associates and friends, stood and cheered. He did not bring the Oaklands auditorium down by any means, but it was certainly noticeable that this was one very happy owner.
Sri Lankan businessman Muzaffar Ali Yaseen didn't have a history of long-time involvement with thoroughbreds but as a regular visitor to Melbourne for work, he would sometimes pop into the TAB or head to the track.
Shantha's Choice | Image courtesy of Arrowfield Stud
And at some stage, he decided that he would like to buy a horse. His first few were ordinary so he decided that next time he would buy not just any horse, but the best one at the sale.
“We were there to buy one filly,” Yaseen's bloodstock manager Iris O'Farrell recalled, “it was as simple as that.”
There were just 63 members of that first crop of Canny Lad's and the bay filly foaled on October 28, 1992, was undoubtedly the best bred of them. Her imported dam Dancing Show (USA) by the great Nijinsky II (Can) had enjoyed a sizeable page upgrade just a week before the sale - her son Hurricane Sky winning the G1 Blue Diamond S.
Hurricane Sky (yellow cap) | Image courtesy of Sportpix
Though her pedigree already read well, her other son Umatilla (NZ) was also a Group 1 winner - of the Karrakatta Plate - four years previously. And three years before the sale her half-brother Great Regent (Can) had won the G1 Woodbine Cup And Saucer S. in Canada.
This was a family taking off internationally, Dancing Show (brought to Australia on the advice of pedigree analyst Ken McLean by Norman Carlyon after sending her to Miswaki {USA} with Umatilla the result) being a granddaughter of the G3 Comely S. winner Best In Show (USA) (Traffic Judge {USA}) - an acclaimed matriarch who would enjoy some of her greatest influence in this part of the world.
Thanks mainly to Dancing Show's Canny Lad filly who would be christened Shantha's Choice.
So how did she come to be?
Shantha's Choice was bred in Victoria by a small group of investors led by Robert Roulston. Now a well-known bloodstock agent, he was an investment banker at the time and spurred by the tax breaks on offer he was able to get some mates together to set up breeding syndicates.
“It was me, the future Racing NSW board member Tony Hodgson and a few mates - several of them were not racing people - they were involved as investors.”
Dancing Show, purchased from Norman Carlyon, was one of those chosen for one of those groups, the Evening Star Breeding Venture.
She was in foal with Umatilla at the time, a horse sold at a loss (just $18,000 at the 1990 Dalgety Premier Yearling Sale) due to his unattractive legs. A better profit margin was to be had for her next foal - the unraced Discoteque (Bletchingly) fetching $210,000 at the 1992 Inglis Easter Yearling Sale.
Hurricane Sky - sold to David Moodie via Adrian Hancock for $75,000 at the 1993 Inglis Easter Sale - was next and then along came Shantha's Choice who Robert Roulston remembers as being 'a small to medium-sized mare' who threw more to her sire than to her dam.
“Dancing Show was one of those big, scopey Nijinsky mares,” he recalled, “whilst Canny Lad was more compact. Shantha's Choice looked more like him than her.”
“Dancing Show was one of those big, scopey Nijinsky mares. Whilst Canny Lad was more compact. Shantha's Choice looked more like him than her.” - Robert Roulston
Sent by Yaseen to the stables of Lee Freedman, the bay made her debut on a heavy track at Seymour in July 1995 - racing away to an easy victory before heading to town, protesting unsuccessfully after finishing a close second as favourite in a Sandown mid-weeker.
It would be the final time Shantha's Choice would be seen at the races with injury bringing an early end to her career. Yaseen had never really thought about breeding and she was placed on the market - but the offers were not high enough.
The next chapter
A horse called Danehill (USA) was making his mark at the time, at that stage sons from his first two crops winning the Golden Slipper; Danzero and Flying Spur. The size of his book was increasing as was his service fee - as was respect for this G1 Sprint Cup-winning son of Danzig (USA) from the family of Northern Dancer (Can).
And so he was chosen to be the first of Shantha's Choice's mates.
On August 15, 1996, Shantha's Choice produced her first foal - an imposing bay colt who would be amongst the very first youngsters branded with the Coolmore 'C' when that stud took over the Jerrys Plains property that year.
Danehill (USA) | Image courtesy of Arrowfield Stud
And he was, as Andrew Perryman - foaling area manager at the time - recalls, amongst the first group of yearlings raised at the stud.
Shantha's Choice was amongst a very well-related group of mares Perryman spent time with and he remembers her as being “a very easygoing mare. She was straightforward, no trouble at all.”
“And she had everything you need in a broodmare - she was not a heavy sprinting type, she was more athletic and refined.”
At one stage Ali Yaseen considered selling Shantha's Choice's first colt but a change of heart ensued and the robust, early-maturing colt was placed under the care of Caulfield trainer Rick Hore-Lacy.
“And she (Shantha's Choice) had everything you need in a broodmare - she was not a heavy sprinting type, she was more athletic and refined.” - Andrew Perryman
The horse was, of course, Redoute's Choice who strolled around the Caulfield mounting yard at his debut in a Listed juvenile contest as though nothing in the world could faze him.
“He was such a gorgeous horse,” O'Farrell said - “my kids loved to pat him, he was so gentle with them.”
That was February 20, 1999, and he made a winning debut - catching the eye of Arrowfield Stud's John Messara who was on the lookout for an heir to Danehill and who had been one of the underbidders on Shantha's Choice at the Inglis Premier.
Redoute's Choice | Image courtesy of Arrowfield Stud
“You just had to love her pedigree,” he recalled, “and after we were unsuccessful in buying her I sought out who had bought her and was able to meet Ali Yaseen through Lee Freedman - and from thereon, I followed her with interest.
“I was owning my own business one day when a phone call came through - could I fit Shantha's Choice into Danehill... of course I could!!”
The Shantha's Choice legacy
Fast forward to Redoute's Choice's debut and Messara was watching. He remembers ringing Hore-Lacy a day or two after to see what the plans were and he admits to some disbelief at being told that the horse would be backing up in the G1 Blue Diamond S. that coming Saturday.
“Rick just said, 'He is a very tough horse who has pulled up very well' and of course the rest is history, Redoute's Choice defeating Testa Rossa in that memorable race.”
And he beat that same tough campaigner in another particularly memorable Group 1 contest - the 1999 Caulfield Guineas. Messara was overseas at the time, but he remembers getting up in the wee hours to listen in - “After that I thought I better get home and try to secure this horse.”
John Messara | Image courtesy of Arrowfield
Meeting Yaseen at Crown Casino, Messara came to an agreement that saw Arrowfield purchase a half share in Redoute's Choice for $5 million. It was on a handshake, nothing was signed on the day and though Yaseen was later offered more, he stuck to his promise.
“And that was the beginning of a great long-term relationship,” Messara said, happy to acknowledge Shantha's Choice's son as the horse on which Arrowfield's success was built.
Whilst her firstborn son was her crowning achievement (earning three Champion Sire titles with his 182 stakes winners inclusive of 39 Group 1 winners), Shantha's Choice was no one-hit-wonder.
Iris O'Farrell remembers her second foal Choice Song - a son of Unbridled's Song (USA) - also showing ability only to break down badly after recording his third win from just seven starts. Next up was Redoute's Choice's full brother Platinum Scissors who put his talent on display winning the 2002 G1 Spring Champion S.
Plagued by fertility issues, he sired just 49 foals during his five seasons at stud; represented by 15 winners from 33 runners with the best of those being the Listed winner Finishing Card. His stakes-placed full brother Superior Sateen also had issues and had just five foals from his sole season at stud. All but one raced and all were winners including the stakes placed The Annihilator.
Shantha's Choice's ninth foal was Manhattan Rain (Encosta de Lago), the G1 AJC Sires' Produce S. winner who is now a resident of Geisel Park in Western Australia.
Manhattan Rain | Standing at Geisel Park
Whilst not rising to the heights of his half-brother, he has been a consistent source of winners and 18 of his sons and daughters are stakes winners including the Golden Slipper heroine She Will Reign.
He is one of two of Shantha's Choice's sons still at stud, the other being his Listed Port Adelaide Guineas winning full brother Echoes Of Heaven (sire of two stakes winners) at Norwegian Park in New Zealand.
She is also nicely represented by her Swettenham Stud-based grandson Rubick, a dual Group-winning sire of nine stakes winners - two of whom are now at stud; Widden Stud's G1 Golden Rose and G1 CF Orr S. winner Jacquinot and Coolmore's Everest hero Yes Yes Yes.
Rubick | Standing at Swettenham Stud
Coolmore is justifiably proud to stand Yes Yes Yes - Colm Santry enjoying the links to their bit of Shantha's Choice history and looking to the future as they set out to tap into her considerable influence by line-breeding to her.
A decent percentage of the mares visiting Yes Yes Yes are members of the Redoute's Choice sireline and that has Santry excited.
“Redoute's Choice is Jacquinot's second damsire and the Shantha's Choice duplication is still very much in its infancy - we are confident that it will be a cross of the future,” said Santry
“You are line-breeding to one of the best families in the Stud Book, one of the great stallion-making families,” he said, noting that Coolmore is another stud grateful for “the Shantha's Choice legacy.”
“You are line-breeding to one of the best families in the Stud Book, one of the great stallion-making families.” - Colm Santry
One which is also felt strongly at Arrowfield, home to one of Shantha's Choice's 17 stakes-winning descendants - her triple Group 1-winning granddaughter Shoals (Fastnet Rock).
Also calling Arrowfield home is Shoals' metropolitan-winning full sister Tides and their city-winning dam The Broken Shore (Hussonet {USA}) who produced a couple of Written Tycoon colts before being served last spring by Maurice (Jpn).
And both Arrowfield and Coolmore stand descendants of Redoute's Choice; Showtime, Snitzel and The Autumn Sun calling the former home whilst the latter have Best Of Bordeaux and King's Legacy.
So, whilst Ali Yaseen's racing and breeding arm Teeley Assets has been wound up (dispersed at a Magic Millions sale in 2014) his very first mare (who died in April 2012) is still making her presence well and truly felt and she can also be considered a foundation mare of sorts for both Coolmore and Arrowfield - two of Australia's biggest studs.