To sell or not to sell? Sandown debate takes over the MRC election

8 min read
Rarely have the elections of a racing club committee attracted as much attention as the current voting being undertaken for three new people to sit on the Executive Committee of the Melbourne Racing Club.

Cover image courtesy of The Image Is Everything

Why the publicity? Well, that's due to one burning issue - the future of Sandown, with three candidates, Tim Johnston, Chris Fox and Caitrin Kelly standing for election firmly in the 'Save Sandown' camp.

The Thoroughbred Report had a chat with Australian Trainers Association committee member (“though my views are my own”) Pat Carey who has concerns regarding not only Sandown, but how racing is currently being run in Victoria.

Pat Carey | Image courtesy of Racing Photos

“When Racing Victoria Limited was established to replace the Victoria Racing Club as the state's peak body the understanding was that the racing clubs would sit underneath them.

“But what we have now is a disorganised structure that sees racing clubs running off doing their own things which has led to a fragmentation of the whole industry. I think we need to put all the chains back into place.”

“... what we have now is a disorganised structure that sees racing clubs running off doing their own things which has led to a fragmentation of the whole industry.” - Pat Carey

A gift from history

Carey recalls that “Sandown was gifted to the VATC” by John Wren and the now defunct Williamstown Racing Club which later merged with the Victorian Trotting And Racing Association, a merger that took place with members voting to do so in the hope of saving Wiliamstown Racecourse which was soon gone.

He noted that it was a gift much appreciated by the then VATC (now MRC) committee members who were “enthusiastic breeders and racehorse owners.”

“I think the likes of (former VATC committee member) Tom Trevaskis would be devasted by even the idea of Sandown being sold.”

Sandown Racecourse

Pat Carey was one of the forty or so trainers who had to relocate from Epsom when it was sold off in the late 1990s and he recalls that the promise at the time was “that the money raised would be spent on the Caulfield training facilities.”

He is now firmly established at Mornington which is one of the many training areas serviced by Sandown, a course Carey describes as “a purpose-built racecourse essential for Victorian racing.”

“It is a beautiful design, a safe, spacious track that owners want to race their horse at, where trainers want to race, where jockeys want to ride... I have not come across a single racing participant who wants Sandown sold.

“It is a beautiful design, a safe, spacious track that owners want to race their horse at, where trainers want to race, where jockeys want to ride... I have not come across a single racing participant who wants Sandown sold.” - Pat Carey

“Victoria needs a quality track for our quality horses and Sandown is best for that purpose,” he said, adding that Sandown is, "A strategically important piece of land.”

“It acted as an important hub during COVID and has given the car racing crowd a home in Melbourne. It is serviced by a train station and it has access to the main freeway system whilst also being a green lung in the area.”

Cain vocal about positives around selling

MRC Chairman Matt Cain has been interviewed a number of times this week in print and on radio with his main concerns centering more on the future of the club's other - and main - track, Caulfield.

Works have been underway for some time regarding the redevelopment of that inner city course; most of the old stalling area has been demolished in preparation for the relocation of the mounting yard which will be overlooked by a new grandstand to replace the current one built 30 years ago.

Matt Cain | Image courtesy of Melbourne Racing Club

The $300 million masterplan - due to be completed by the spring of 2026 - has Cain excited about what will be on offer for racegoers and the public.

“The grandstand will feature incredible views over the racecourse and Dandenongs and also feature a rooftop bar and restaurants,” it was reported on Racing.com with Cain noting that, “Nearly 80 per cent of members want a new world-class facility at Caulfield.”

And he was keen to note that the redevelopment of Caulfield (including a new inner track) - which regularly attracts greater patronage (higher figures of member and public attendance, dining revenue and turnover) than Sandown - is not actually dependent on the end of Sandown.

“We don't have to sell Sandown to complete our master plan,” he told Racing.com.

“So, if 80 per cent of our members want us to build a world-class racing and all-year-round grandstand pavilion facility, we can fund that with debt.”

“We don't have to sell Sandown to complete our master plan (at Caulfield). So, if 80 per cent of our members want us to build a world-class racing and all-year-round grandstand pavilion facility, we can fund that with debt.” - Matt Cain

Or with other fund-raising measures such as “rezoning and revaluing some of our freehold land portfolios” or “increasing member subsidies, they might need to be closer to a $1000 than $400.”

He continued along this vein in an interview with Matthew Stewart on RSN on Tuesday morning.

“The purpose of the vision of the MRC is to provide world-class racing and entertainment for our members and the public,” he said, describing, “the largest mounting yard in the Southern Hemisphere which will accommodate 900 connections and owners as well as our subterranean day stalls - and a fantastic 270-degree grand pavilion which can be utilised year round.

“Funding has always been at the forefront of our minds,” he continued, adding that there are a number of other options including the partial redevelopment of Sandown... “We are currently employing consultants re utilizing that land if the rezoning application is approved next year.”

An artist’s impression of the 'Grand Pavillion' proposed for Caulfield Racecourse

Plus, there is still land at Caulfield with Cain telling RSN that, “The relocation of trainers has freed up a huge amount of freehold land and we are currently in the process of examining how we rezone that land for future residential development - the value of that land can contribute significantly to the Caulfield master plan.

“And we are only two-thirds through the Caulfield Village development on the site of the old members' carpark and again there is considerable value to be had out of that in the next three to four years.”

Able to submit Sandown plans before the Victorian government's new windfall tax kicked in, the MRC will fare well out of the redevelopment of the area - “Rezoning will improve our balance sheet considerably,” Cain said.

And he is excited that those funds can improve the racing experience - “We have seen in other sports that new grandstands and facilities have attracted new crowds,” he enthused.

Cain is keen to point out that whilst MRC members do not have authority over how the Sandown space is redeveloped, the future of racing at the track is definitely up to them.

“It is an absolute requirement in club rules that the cessation of racing at Sandown has to be voted in by a majority of members - they are in complete control.”

“It is an absolute requirement in club rules that the cessation of racing at Sandown has to be voted in by a majority of members - they are in complete control.” - Matt Cain

Oliver keen for creative solutions

RSN discussed the Sandown conundrum with Damien Oliver, who described it as “such a great track in a great location.”

“Racing is getting pushed further and further out already and we don't want to lose a parcel of land in such a great area - once it's gone, you can never get it back.

“Racing is getting pushed further and further out already and we don't want to lose a parcel of land (Sandown) in such a great area - once it's gone, you can never get it back.” - Damien Oliver

“The perfect scenario should be, with such a huge block of land, to keep the existing track and develop around it - that would make really good money anyway. The area could be developed in such a way to make it a more attractive place to go.”

Carey is aware of the financial aspects of the sport but argues that trainers are “at the forefront of investment."

“As a group, trainers invest hundreds of millions of dollars into land, staff and stock - we are the entrepreneurs of racing, and we need Sandown to sell our product.”

Carey is pleased that redevelopment of the Sandown site whilst retaining the course is an option but wants to hear more about it.

“There has been mixed messaging and I don't think that these plans should be discussed before members even vote on it,” he said, adding that he would like greater transparency re any voting processes.

“I would like to know how the voting would be conducted; I think we should be shown the methods that will be in place so that we can go on from there. And any rezoning should not take place until we all get a clear picture.”

“I would like to know how the voting would be conducted; I think we should be shown the methods that will be in place so that we can go on from there. And any rezoning should not take place until we all get a clear picture.” - Pat Carey

Carey also expressed concern that RVL have been “conspicuously silent” about the Sandown issue, noting that he is one of many who would like to hear more about the peak body's ideas about retaining - or not retaining - a major metropolitan racecourse.

MRC election
Sandown
Caulfield