‘Buyers can have a little more confidence’: New research into radiographic lesions

10 min read
Following the publication of new research into what radiographic lesions in thoroughbred yearlings are significant in limiting future racing performance, we spoke to Dr Brodie Argue, Equine Sports Medicine and Rehabilitation Resident at the University of Queensland, to discuss the key findings and potential implications for industry participants.

The research, which looked at thoroughbred yearling sales across Australia to include a wide range of genetics and geographic locations, aimed to provide improved clarity about the potential impact of radiographic lesions on the future athletic performance of thoroughbred yearlings.

Researchers investigated a range of lesions (an abnormality or an area of damage, change, or disease) in over 8600 radiographic reports, making it the biggest study of its kind carried out in Australia. The project was delivered by AgriFutures Australia in conjunction with the University of Queensland and funded by industry-paid levies through the AgriFutures Thoroughbred Horses Program.

The research was broken down into two clear areas of study. As part of the first study, three specialist equine surgeons reviewed 30 radiographic series for the presence of lesions and graded them as low, moderate or high, based on their likelihood of limiting future racing performance.

Dr Brodie Argue

The second study comprised of thoroughbred yearlings radiographed between 2014 and 2018, with approximately 8660 radiographic reports from yearlings presented for sale collected and analysed. Yearlings with radiographic lesions were compared with yearlings completely free of radiographic lesions, and a statistical analysis was performed to determine whether there were differences between the career performances of these yearlings.

Dr Brodie Argue, who is currently studying for his specialty in sports medicine and rehabilitation, worked on the research alongside his supervisor at the University of Queensland, Professor Ben Ahern, with further assistance provided by Dr Angus Adkins, Dr Christopher O’Sullivan, Dr Steven Hance and Dr Chris Lawler.

Positive initial response

Having won the Best Clinical Paper at The Australian Veterinary Association's Bain Fallon Memorial Lectures, as well as Argue winning the Young Speaker Abstract Award at National Science Week, the study has been very well received in the research field thus far.

Much to Argue’s delight, the feedback he has received to date from trainers and their farriers has also been overwhelmingly positive, suggesting an early willingness from industry participants to get engage with the findings.

“From a welfare perspective it shows that we as an industry are constantly trying to evolve and provide the best care possible for horses,” Argue said.

“From a welfare perspective it shows that we as an industry are constantly trying to evolve and provide the best care possible for horses.” - Dr Brodie Argue

“We’ve now seen that some changes are not as significant as what we may have previously deemed, so we may not need to go in surgically on those, and the research has also provided a great steppingstone to ensure that we are medicating these horses or altering their training programs so that they don’t have any negative side effects from these lesions.

“Ultimately, this research can help provide us with the knowledge as an industry of how to manage these horses once they come into training, which is what really pushed me towards this research in the first instance.

“I’d really like to thank AgriFutures and thoroughbred breeders for providing the opportunity to conduct this research. We really hope that it has the positive benefits on the industry that we are after.”

Pleasant surprises and increasing consistency

Having worked at racetracks and thoroughbred sales as well as a resident stud vet, Argue has experience working from a number of different perspectives within the industry, and hopes this research can not only improve industry confidence when it comes to buying and selling yearlings, but also help identify and manage the effect of lesions on future athletic performance once a yearling enters training.

Yearlings in the pre-parade ring at Magic Millions

Of the most significant findings, Argue said that the results in relation to one particular lesion, sesamoiditis, is a prime example of how increasing knowledge can help manage the impacts of certain lesions.

“The most common radiographic change in our study was sesamoiditis, but what we found with this study is that we have become better over time at managing it,” he revealed to The Thoroughbred Report.

“Historically in some populations sesamoiditis can be performance limiting, so we have previously started to delay the training of those affected, etc., but here we found that when it occurred in the forelimbs, it didn’t affect the horses as much as in the hind limbs.

“Historically in some populations sesamoiditis can be performance limiting, so we have previously started to delay the training of those affected, but here we found that when it occurred in the forelimbs, it didn’t affect the horses as much as in the hind limbs.” - Dr Brodie Argue

“Sesamoiditis was the most common finding, followed probably by arthritic changes in the carpus and then lucencies in the stifle. There were some lesions, like fragments in the back of fetlocks, which we thought might have influenced performance more, but they had very little effect on performance, which was quite interesting.”

A number of different factors were used to measure the subsequent performance of yearlings, with their ability to start in a race, place in a race, win a race and earn prizemoney all included in the data.

The study also obtained the performance index of the horse from The Rating Bureau, which Argue said is a relatively new tool in comparing performance in this research sphere.

“I think we’re one of the first studies to use that performance index for analysis in yearlings, and we found that the weight-for-age rating actually had a good correlation with some of these changes that did affect performance,” Argue revealed.

“It trended that those horses, say with a fragment in the carpal joint, had less starts, wins and places, but they also had a lower peak career rating as well.”

“It trended that those horses, say with a fragment in the carpal joint, had less starts, wins and places, but they also had a lower peak career rating as well.” - Dr Brodie Argue

Several radiographic lesions were found to negatively affect the long-term athletic performance of yearlings, including lesions in the fore feet, pastern, fore and hind fetlocks, proximal sesamoid bone, carpus, hock and stifle.

Another key finding from the research identified that veterinarians are very consistently detecting radiographic lesions, with an impressive 97.1 per cent agreement in the detection/non-detection of lesions in the study. That figure is a marked improvement from when radiographs were first introduced according to Argue, and is helping to eliminate the potential for observer bias when it comes to interpreting a set of yearling radiographs.

DMPLO Hock LTR OCD

“That finding provides confidence that if we as a vet say there is a radiographic change, that opinion is going to be very consistent among vets,” Argue said. “Likewise, if we say that there is no change in a joint, there is confidence that there is very little observer bias between those observers.

“It also shows that we are getting more consistent in identifying whether a lesion is low, moderate or high.

“When we first started looking at x-rays, there would have been a big difference between what one vet said was a high risk versus what another vet said was a moderate risk. We are now seeing that we are all becoming closer with those classifications.”

“When we first started looking at x-rays, there would have been a big difference between what one vet said was a high risk versus what another vet said was a moderate risk. We are now seeing that we are all becoming closer with those classifications.” - Dr Brodie Argue

Implications for the thoroughbred industry

Argue feels that improved buyer confidence at the yearling sales, more proactive intervention of radiographic lesions and more tailored training regimes to help reduce the potential effects of certain radiographic changes are among the almost limitless implications of this research for the thoroughbred industry - all with the overarching aim of improving a horse’s long-term welfare.

“The implications that we want for buyers when looking at this research is that they can have a little bit more confidence in what a certain radiographic change is going to mean for their horse in terms of future performance,” Argue said.

“The implications that we want for buyers when looking at this research is that they can have a little bit more confidence in what a certain radiographic change is going to mean for their horse in terms of future performance.” - Dr Brodie Argue

“It’s also going to allow more proactive management practices to be in place by the trainers and their respective vets for whenever a yearling does have a radiographic change, which in turn hopefully increases the longevity of those horses’ careers in training.

“That’s what we are hoping is going to be a big takeaway - that we can be more proactive about changes, particularly arthritic ones, and more proactive in medicating those, providing joint supplements or altering their training more towards water treadmills and things like that.”

Negative palmar angles in the feet is a prime example of the sort of proactive intervention Argue makes reference to, with the research having identified an opportunity to limit the effects of one of the lesions found to have a more profound impact on a yearling’s future performance.

The palmar angle is shown in purple | Image courtesy of The Equine Documnetalist

“We now have certain fragments that we might want to remove prior to increasing exercise levels, particularly those fragments in the carpus,” Argue added.

“Then there are some changes in the foot, like a negative palmar balance, that we might also be proactive about establishing a normal to positive palmar balance prior to increasing exercise.

“We know that specific change can be very performance-limiting when a horse is in full work, but when we saw it in a yearling it really affected a horse’s ability to win a race. So If we can correct that prior to training, hopefully that change won’t have as much of a significant effect long term.”

As well as the implications for buyers and sellers of yearlings, Argue also feels that this research has the potential to be a great tool for young veterinarians of the future, particularly those who don’t have experience with particular lesions and may have previously graded one higher as a result of that unfamiliarity.

A yearling in the ring at Inglis' Oaklands sale complex

In addition to a full document on the research, Argue and his colleagues plan to produce a condensed, summarised handout that can be used as a quick sheet to look at what scale a lesion affects performance when working through the x-ray repository of a yearling sale.

With a ‘significant’ data set of over 8600 yearling radiographs at their disposal, the scope for future study is huge, and having established which lesions have the most profound effect on future performance, Argue revealed to The Thoroughbred Report that the next area for investigation is identifying why that is the case.

“This study is just a big blanket study that has looked at the lesions as a whole, and now we plan to go back and look at specific lesions in more depth,” he said.

“It has allowed us to provide more information on some of the more uncommon radiographic changes, but it has also provided us with a great steppingstone. Now that we have seen which changes really affect performance, we can zero in on that particular lesion and work out whether it was the presence of sclerosis or the size of the fragment that had the bigger effect, for example.

“Now that we have seen which changes really affect performance, we can zero in on that particular lesion and work out whether it was the presence of sclerosis or the size of the fragment that had the bigger effect, for example.” - Dr Brodie Argue

“It has provided us with building blocks for the future.”

AgriFutures
Dr Brodie Argue
University of Queensland
Radiographs
Lesions
X-rays
Yearlings