Cover image courtesy of Coolmore
With Book 1 of the Magic Millions Gold Coast Yearling Sale now enshrined in history, one of the most fascinating elements of the five days of selling was the eagerness of the market to get behind the first-season sires, with a number of highly respected buyers eager to secure some of the first available progeny of former stars of the turf.
It was a particularly strong group of stallions in this class, with no fewer than four of the first-crop yearlings cracking seven-figure prices, including the sale-topper, the filly by Wootton Bassett (GB) out of the elite racemare Avantage (Fastnet Rock), who commanded $2.1 million early into the third day of selling.
Lot 454 - Wootton Bassett (GB) x Avantage (filly) | Image courtesy of Magic Millions
Wootton’s iron-grip
First-season sires from the 2024 catalogue simply cannot be talked about without Wootton Bassett, the Coolmore Australia shuttle-stallion who, in a relative rarity, arrived in Australia with a pre-made reputation as an elite stallion.
Only one of his 33 Book 1 lots, a filly out of Moonlight Waltz (Fastnet Rock) failed to sell, falling just $5000 short of the $125,000 reserve set. None of his progeny sold for less than his debut Southern Hemisphere service fee of $71,500 (inc GST), with all but two achieving at least double the service fee as a sale price.
His impact was felt right at the top of the market, with the filly out of Avantage shattering the previous record held by Sepoy, who had War Hero sell for $1.6 million at the Inglis Australian Easter Yearling Sale. For those playing along at home, War Hero would win two races from 18 starts, earning $82,585 in prizemoney.
Wootton Bassett (GB) | Standing at Coolmore
Two of his yearlings comfortably cleared $1 million, with Tom Magnier going to $1.6 million to purchase his colt out of Fiera Vista (Exceed And Excel). In total, five of his lots cleared his service fee 10 times over, giving him a very healthy suite of statistical accomplishments in his first Southern Hemisphere yearling sale.
Given his elevated profile, and runs on the board, this is where we will leave Wootton Bassett for the purpose of analysis, to draw a more direct comparison with stallions who are yet to have runenrs, given his circumstances are such a rarity.
Averaging it out
One key element to assessing a first-season sire is the average price paid for their Book 1 yearlings, especially when looking over the stallions at the upper-echelon of the market.
The top-three debuting stallions from the last four classes have averaged no worse than $168,000, with nine clearing $200,000.
| The Autumn Sun | 28 | 2022 | $383,929 |
| Blue Point | 16 | 2023 | $378,125 |
| Farnan | 29 | 2024 | $309,483 |
| Justify | 23 | 2022 | $300,000 |
| Too Darn Hot | 14 | 2023 | $276,786 |
| Trapeze Artist | 27 | 2022 | $263,519 |
| Pierata | 27 | 2023 | $255,000 |
| Merchant Navy | 20 | 2021 | $207,500 |
| Ole Kirk | 25 | 2024 | $206,300 |
| Anders | 10 | 2024 | $194,000 |
| Hellbent | 30 | 2021 | $185,333 |
| Russian Revolution | 25 | 2021 | $168,200 |
Table: First-season sires by average
The consistency of Farnan was reflected by his placement in the table above, with 29 yearlings being knocked down at an average of $309,483 being good enough for third overall by first-season sire average at sales since 2020.
Ole Kirk, who had a total of 25 yearlings find buyers throughout Book 1, enjoyed a very respectable average of $206,300. Punching enormously above his weight was Anders, who clocked in with an average of $194,000 from 10 yearlings to sell.
In the 2023 iteration, it was Darley Australia’s shuttle stallions Blue Point (Ire) and Too Darn Hot (GB) who commanded the best averages of a first-season sire, with the former going at $378,125 across 16 lots, while the latter achieved an average of $276,786 across 14 transactions.
Third-best for the freshman class of 12 months ago was Pierata, with a collection of 27 yearlings commanding an average price of $255,000.
Gallery: Top three first-season sires by average at this year's Magic Millions Gold Coast Yearling Sale
The Autumn Sun shone brightest in 2022 for first-season sires, averaging $383,929 from 28 to sell, one of the strongest figures in recent years from stallions making their Southern Hemisphere yearling debut at this sale.
Also well-represented by averages from that crop was Justify (USA), who saw his average sit at a neat $300,000 from 23 to sell, while Trapeze Artist had an average of $263,519, in a marketplace that showed an eagerness to invest in new stallions, much like what has been seen some 24 months later.
For the 2021 crop, which as previously identified didn’t set historical highs at their debut yearling sale, Merchant Navy was the highest achiever of the group, averaging $207,500 from 25 to sell, while Hellbent went at an average sale price of $185,333 from his 30.
Further down is Russian Revolution, arguably now the most successful stallion of his class, who saw 25 sell at an average of $168,200.
Big returns for supportive breeders
One noticeable characteristic within the results of first-season sires is the number of six-figure returns for yearlings, relative to their 2021 service fee, from some of the top-end freshman stallions.
But what about the return offered to breeders, as a dollar value, for sending their mares to a first-season sire? We take a look below, with all service fees being considered without a GST component.
| Farnan | $50,000 | 29 | 25 | 13 | 86% | 44% |
| Anders | $15,000 | 10 | 8 | 4 | 80% | 40% |
| Ole Kirk | $50,000 | 25 | 17 | 7 | 68% | 28% |
Table: 2024 first-season sires by returns
Ole Kirk achieved 17 progeny selling for at least $155,000, a $105,000 profit (before mare value and expenses, and not considering tax implications) on his first-season service fee, which was set at $50,000. Of those, seven would go on to achieve a sale price $200,000 higher than the corresponding service fee, representing 68 per cent and 28 per cent of his first crop to sell respectively.
Another freshman stallion to elicit attention throughout Book 1 was Farnan, who stood for the same amount as Ole Kirk, scaling to even stronger results than his counterpart. In total, 25 of his offering went for at least $155,000 (86 per cent), while 13 went for more than $255,000 (45 per cent).
Perhaps a ‘roughie’ to finish in the top-three stallions by average in 2024 was Anders, who batted well above his service fee to deliver one of the most stellar results from a stallion with a sub-$20,000 initial fee in recent times.
It’s not like he did it all off of one lot either, eight of his 10 yearlings to sell in Book 1 made over $100,000 more than his initial service fee of $15,000, with a further four making more than $200,000. Delivering 80 per cent of sales at more than $100,000 than the initial fee, and 40 per cent at $200,000 more, is incredibly impressive from a stallion that wasn’t widely discussed as a sire to watch heading into the Gold Coast mega-sale.
| Blue Point | $40,000 | 16 | 15 | 11 | 93% | 68% |
| Too Darn Hot | $40,000 | 14 | 11 | 7 | 79% | 50% |
| Pierata | $40,000 | 27 | 17 | 9 | 62% | 33% |
Table: 2023 first-season sires by returns
Comparing those metrics to the 2023 group; Blue Point achieved exceptional results some 12 months ago, from his 16 yearlings to sell, 15 cleared $100,000 more of his service fee of $40,000, a strike rate of 93 per cent. He had 11 of those go onto sell at $200,000 more than his service fee, or 68 per cent of his total Book 1 offering, the highest percentage over the last four years.
Fellow shuttler Too Darn Hot enjoyed a strong set of numbers as well, with 11 and seven of his 14 yearlings going for $100,000 and $200,000 more respectively than his initial fee of $40,000. Those percentages of 79 per cent and 50 per cent put him right amongst the better performing debut stallions in recent times, in terms of providing maximum returns to breeders.
Pierata joined in the fun with 17 eclipsing $100,000 more than his service fee of $40,000, which provided a unique coincidence in that all top-three stallions of the class had the same service fee.
The 62 per cent of lots clearing $100,000 of the fee is joined by 33 per cent of lots clearing $200,000, of which there were nine.
| The Autumn Sun | $70,000 | 28 | 27 | 17 | 96% | 60% |
| Justify | $60,000 | 23 | 18 | 10 | 78% | 43% |
| Trapeze Artist | $80,000 | 27 | 14 | 9 | 51% | 33% |
Table: 2022 first-season sires by returns (note - Justify's fee is what he stood at in his second season as first season was listed as POA)
Plenty of faith was shown in The Autumn Sun when his first yearlings were offered in 2022, who even at the relatively high introductory fee of $70,000, rode a groundswell of support at the famous Bundall auction to be the best six-figure returner of a debuting stallion in the last four years.
Only one of his 28 Book 1 sales sold for less than $100,000 more than his fee, representing 96 per cent of his draft, while 17 of those would go on to eclipse $200,000, a 60 per cent total. While Blue Point beats him for the percentage of his lots clearing the latter, his strength in the former, particularly when considering his number of lots being offered is one the highest of the 12 stallions covered here, is almost untouchable.
Current boom stallion Justify did not have his first-season fee advertised, so his second-season fee of $60,000 has been substituted in. On those numbers, 78 per cent of his first crop provided a minimum of a $100,000 return, or 18 of his 23 yearlings, while 10 of those would be knocked down for at least $200,000 more, or 43 per cent.
Interestingly, the highest-priced stallion by service fee of the dozen, Trapeze Artist, ends up a fair way down the overall rankings when considering percentage of six-figure returns, with 51 per cent of his first crop clearing $100,000 more than his introductory fee of $80,000, which places him 11th overall.
He does fare better in results above $200,000 more than his service fee, with nine of his 27, or 33 per cent, of his Book 1 yearlings exceeding a purchase price of $288,000.
| Merchant Navy | $50,000 | 20 | 15 | 6 | 75% | 30% |
| Hellbent | $25,000 | 30 | 22 | 7 | 73% | 23% |
| Russian Revolution | $50,000 | 25 | 11 | 5 | 44% | 20% |
Table: 2021 first-season sires by returns, fees
As for the class of 2021, Merchant Navy had 20 lots sold, of which 15 went for at least $100,000 more than his initial fee of $50,500, providing him a strike rate of 75 per cent at returning a six-figure profit in his debut crop. A further six of those, or 30 per cent, went on to make at least $200,000 more than the service fee for the crop.
Hellbent, one of the cheapest stallions represented here with an introductory fee of $25,000, saw 22 of his first 30 progeny, or 73 per cent, go for $100,000 more than the service fee, with seven, or 23 per cent, clearing $200,000.
Russian Revolution, who was introduced at $50,000, his group of 25 first-crop yearlings saw 11 achieve a sale price higher than $150,000, at 44 per cent, while five made at least $255,000, which represents 20 per cent of his Book 1 crop. Both are the lowest percentage figures of the dozen.
Who has faith in the new kids?
With all these dollar figures being banded around, it’s worth taking stock of who exactly is willing to invest this heavily in unproven stallions, at this end of the market.
There are a number of names that appear with an enthusiastic presence over the last four years, Ciaron Maher is never far away, neither are the usual buyers of promising colts, China Horse Club, in collaboration with Newgate Farm and Trilogy Racing.
One name that stands head and shoulders above the rest, as she does in many facets of racing, is Gai Waterhouse, who alongside co-trainer Adrian Bott and a host of partners, have shown a great level of belief in new stallions over recent years.
Gai Waterhouse and Adrian Bott | Image courtesy of Magic Millions
They were one of the first major supporters locally of Justify, buying three of his debut crop in 2022, with the pair continuing on to buy one of the most exciting juveniles seen in modern racing, Storm Boy, by the stallion in 2023.
Some 12 months ago, they thrust their faith behind Too Darn Hot, purchasing two of his first Southern Hemisphere crop, including a $1 million filly by the name of Too Darn Lizzie, who alongside Storm Boy (and others) gives the training powerhouse a hand full of aces heading into the pinnacle of 2-year-old racing.
Perhaps unsurprisingly, they also got behind their G1 Golden Slipper winning star Farnan, buying three of his first-crop, including a $1.2 million colt out of the star racemare I Am Excited (Snitzel).