The real Easter hunt: finding value at Australia’s most elite yearling sale

6 min read
Featuring yearlings with impeccable pedigrees from the top echelons of the studbook, it's no wonder that the Inglis Australian Easter Yearling sale consistently commands the highest prices in Australasia. However, with over 35 per cent of stakes-winning graduates fetching less than $200,000 in the last decade, there remains ample potential for bargain hunters to uncover valuable opportunities.

Cover image courtesy of Inglis

While buyers often require substantial financial resources to participate, buyers can expect heightened returns on investments given the sale represents over 300 stakes-winning graduates at a strike rate of over seven per cent.

Cost of stakes-winning graduates is on the rise

Stakes-winning graduates from the Inglis Australian Easter Yearling Sale exhibit a wide range of prices, spanning from as low as $15,000 to as high as $2,300,000.

While there is a discernible trend indicating a decline in the availability of lower-priced Inglis Easter graduates, value can still be found.

In 2013, there were 13 individual stakes-winning graduates sold for $200,000 or less.

Fast forward a decade to 2023, and the median price for a stakes-winning graduate soared to $875,000, exceeding three times the overall sales median.

While these graduates are merely 3-years-old, examining the results from 2022 and 2021 further supports the notion that stakes-winning graduates are becoming pricier, with median costs of $525,000 and $400,000 respectively.

2013$230,000$200,000
2014$190,000$180,000
2015$190,000$200,000
2016$240,000$160,000
2017$280,000$260,000
2018$380,000$250,000
2019$500,000$260,000
2020$300,000$250,000
2021$400,000$280,000
2022$525,000$300,000
2023$875,000$280,000

The impact of catalogue refinement

Well-respected industry figure Louis Mihalyka of Laurel Oak Bloodstock highlighted a potential significant factor behind the notable increase in the median price of stakes-winning Inglis Easter graduates.

“I think one of the most telling reasons for that figure will be that up until three or four years ago, the sale went for three days. When the sale went for three days, the bottom third of the horses who now go to Magic Millions or Classic, were readily bought in the $150,000 to $250,0000 type range.”

Louis Mihalyka | Image courtesy of The Image Is Everything

In 2019, Inglis made a significant change by consolidating the Easter catalogue to two days instead of three, resulting in a shorter catalogue by around 100 horses.

Reflecting on the final year of the three-day format, Mihalyka mentioned, "It was the year we purchased Pancho. That year, every time we put our hand up, they gave us a horse. We bought five or six yearlings that year, which is totally unheard of for us."

Pancho (Dissident) became a stakes winner accumulated over $780,000 in prize-money and became his sire’s leading earner in Australia.

Unearthing hidden gems

Despite the reduction in size, which has potentially eliminated a significant portion of yearlings that savvy shoppers might typically target, Mihalyka observed that contrary to the prevailing norm, there are still opportunities to uncover value, particularly if one is willing to explore offerings from lesser-known stallions.

While this can pose a challenge at a prestigious event like Inglis Easter, which attracts top-tier stallions, Mihalyka pointed out that sales companies finalise their catalogues months prior to auction day, leaving ample time for a sire to make a notable impact.

“They (sales companies) make their decisions in November for cataloguing and there might have been stallions that have gone the wrong way, which is probably more like where we're going to be able to buy,” Mihalyka stated.

An instance of this occurred in 2016 when Mihalyka acquired four yearlings by Sepoy, who was represented at the sale by his second-crop of yearlings.

"Sepoy, approaching his second season, was on the nose. He was expected to be a good stallion. A lot of people sent good mares to Sepoy in their second season because he was such a good 2-year-old. But by the time the sale came out in April, he had barely had a winner."

Remaining steadfast in his convictions, Mihalyka's belief in his breeding theories paid off handsomely, with all four yearlings proving to be profitable investments. Sweet Scandal (Sepoy) emerged as a Group 3 winner with nearly $500,000 in earnings, while Acqume (Sepoy) and Impasse (Sepoy) secured valuable black-type placings, and Tarabai (Sepoy) achieved metropolitan success.

Identifying the less obvious

Two-time Golden Slipper-winning trainer Gary Portelli, possesses a knack for discovering talent at affordable prices. When discussing his approach to purchasing at high-end sales such as Inglis Easter, Portelli stressed the importance of striking a balance between identifying horses that may not be immediately obvious choices but are appealing to clientele.

“I've got to really identify horses of pedigree that I know that obviously aren't going to be the big end of town. I predominantly like to train young horses. I don't like stayers, so you put a line through the horses that might take time and might need further. That's already half your catalogue sorted,” Portelli explained.

Gary Portelli | Image courtesy of Ashlea Brennan

“Then I've got to find horses by stallions that I know my clientele will know and respect and look for families that work and often have pedigrees that are similar to horses that I've trained before and that I've had success with.”

“... I've got to find horses by stallions that I know my clientele will know and respect and look for families that work and often have pedigrees that are similar to horses that I've trained before and that I've had success with.” - Gary Portelli

Two years ago, Portelli made a significant investment of $200,000 for a Capitalist colt from the Newhaven Park draft. That colt, named Encap, went on to achieve success by winning the G3 Ming Dynasty and finishing as the runner-up in the G1 Golden Rose S. this season.

“When it came to buying Encap, I loved him as a type. He was a real sprinting-type, not overly big but I knew he'd grow into a nice horse without being too big. He was by a Golden Slipper winner out of a mare that was by a Golden Slipper winner in Stratum.

Encap | Image courtesy of Ashlea Brennan

“There was a lot of 2-year-old speed in the family, and I just thought this would be a no-brainer for my crew. The fact he was a little on the smaller side probably brought his price point back a bit. If he was a big strong colt, he may have a lot more money.”

Big not always best

In the realm of purchasing prospective racehorses, Portelli emphasised the importance of ensuring the horse possesses balance above all else. He noted that appearances can be deceiving, cautioning that those horses that appear as though they are already fully developed aren't necessarily the best long-term investments.

“I find that when you go to Easter, the horse is a little bit more mature than the other sales you've seen. With horses that come on a lot you've got to be careful because sometimes they’re so big you can't get them going because they just don't cope with the workload. But people often see them and they get excited because they look like they're ready to go.”

“I find that when you go to (Inglis) Easter, the horse is a little bit more mature than the other (yearling) sales you've seen. With horses that come on a lot you've got to be careful... But people often see them and they get excited because they look like they're ready to go.” - Gary Portelli

The Inglis Easter Yearling Sale continues to serve as a beacon for the global racing industry, attracting discerning buyers and showcasing the best of Australian bloodstock.

Asthe market evolves, so too do the strategies employed by industry insiders to secure success. By remaining vigilant and adaptable, buyers can continue to unearth future racetrack stars at affordable prices.

Gary Portelli
Louis Mihalyka
Laurel Oak Bloodstock
Inglis