Cover image courtesy of The Image Is Everything
Racing NSW has responded to the appalling footage of So You Are's remains in a skip bin with a familiar solution: more rules.
By the end of November, we're told, there will be new obligations governing the handling of deceased racehorses. Body bags will be provided, death notification forms expanded, chains of custody documented and industry participants educated about the standards expected of them.
Some of these sound like sensible changes, albeit a little too late.
However, the contractor engaged to transport So You Are's remains was not licensed by any racing regulator. So, unless there’s an intention to license every operator transporting horses, dead or alive, it leads me to a fundamental question: How can rules alone ensure deceased horses are disposed of with dignity if the infrastructure isn't there to support it?
So You Are | Image courtesy of The Image Is Everything
So You Are (So You Think {NZ}) was rushed to Randwick Equine Centre after suffering severe colic. His colon had reportedly ruptured, and the veterinary team made the decision to euthanise him under anaesthesia.
His remains were collected by a specialist contractor and transported to a licensed landfill facility at Lucas Heights, a disposal method recommended under NSW Government guidance for horses euthanised with barbiturates.
Speaking to Gareth Hall on SEN's Giddy Up on Thursday, Hinton acknowledged that the veterinary practice had followed the disposal recommendation.
Graeme Hinton | Image courtesy of Racing NSW
"One of those recommendations is that a horse that has been euthanised that has barbiturates in its bloodstream from that process should, should be sent to a licensed landfill," he said.
"But where they've let us down and let the horse down is that they haven't maintained a process of dignity and respect through that, and they've just allowed the horse to be abandoned there."
It's worth clarifying that So You Are's body had not been abandoned. It was reportedly awaiting transfer to the designated animal burial area after the contractor's vehicle was unable to access the tipping face.
The circumstances that led to So You Are being placed in a skip bin remain under investigation and Hinton confirmed that the contractor had yet to be interviewed. Nevertheless, he was unequivocal about where he believed responsibility lay.
"It wasn't a trainer or an owner that's done the wrong thing here. It was one of our vets," he said.
"It wasn't a trainer or an owner that's done the wrong thing here. It was one of our vets." - Graeme Hinton
The statement issued by Jonathan Lumsden on behalf of Randwick Equine Centre was remarkably gracious, accepting responsibility for what had happened without seeking to shift the blame elsewhere.
But let's remember what veterinary hospitals are there to do. Their job is to save our horses, and when that isn't possible, to ensure they have a humane end. They aren't equipped to store the bodies of 500kg animals indefinitely.
REC engaged a specialist contractor to collect So You Are's remains and transport them to a licensed facility - it followed the recommended disposal process.
That’s why I think we’re missing the much bigger point.
Jonathan Lumsden | Image courtesy of REC Equine Specialist
REC, other equine veterinary hospitals, race clubs, spelling farms and trainers all must work with the disposal facilities and services available to them near a major city. If those facilities or contractors are inadequate, introducing more rules for the people who rely on them isn’t going to fix the problem.
So why are we sending deceased Thoroughbreds to commercial landfill facilities in the first place? Anyone who has had to arrange the disposal of a deceased horse knows how difficult it can be.
A horse weighs around half a tonne, requiring either a tractor or a winch to move. Burial requires suitable land, machinery and compliance with environmental requirements. Cremation is restricted to privately-owned facilities after the Sydney University incinerator broke down, so it is expensive, capacity is limited and specialist transport must be arranged.
When a horse has suffered a catastrophic injury or illness and needs to be euthanised urgently, those decisions must be made quickly, often by people who are already devastated.
So, I find it difficult to accept that the solution is to educate people about treating their horses with dignity, then penalise them if the solution isn't adequate.
The overwhelming majority of people who work with horses don't need a rulebook to tell them how to treat them with respect - they need somewhere appropriate to take the body and trusted transport to do so.
A national solution from Britain
In Britain, specialist collection services and approved animal by-product facilities provide established options for dealing with deceased horses.
Its National Fallen Stock Scheme was established in 2003 through a partnership between the UK Government and the agricultural industry, following changes to the regulations governing the disposal of dead livestock.
Today, the National Fallen Stock Company operates as an industry-led, not-for-profit organisation, coordinating a nationwide network of approximately 100 collectors who handle deceased farm animals and horses. Horse owners can register for free, identify approved collectors servicing their area, compare collection charges and arrange for the animal to be transported to an appropriate disposal facility. Owners pay for the service, with collection records and centralised billing handled through the scheme.
The British Government provides the regulatory requirements, while the industry operates the collection system. The scheme gives horse owners access to an established network of specialist operators, rather than leaving each veterinary clinic, farm or trainer to find its own solution.
It's a model worth considering for Australia. Racing Australia wouldn't necessarily need to build and operate every facility itself, but it could work with government, veterinary practices and existing disposal businesses to establish a coordinated collection service with agreed standards, reliable access to suitable facilities and financial assistance for owners who need it.
New Zealand also found a proper solution
New Zealand also offers an interesting example of what can be achieved when motivated people decide to take action on a problem, proactively.
TTR spoke with Justine Sclater, former chief executive of the New Zealand Thoroughbred Breeders’ Association and former Head of Thoroughbred Welfare and Sustainability at New Zealand Thoroughbred Racing, who was instrumental in establishing the country's equine crematorium alongside trustees Ivan Bridge and Andrew Fisher.
The project began in 2019, prompted by concerns about body disposal - designed to prevent a situation that has precisely unfolded with So You Are.
Justine Sclater | Image courtesy of New Zealand Thoroughbred Racing
"There were multiple factors," Sclater told TTR. "All sorts of things motivated the project, from race day fatalities to biosecurity, to providing a solution for aged horses, across all equine fraternities. We needed a better environmental solution."
The facility took years to establish with environmental consents, emissions, fuel requirements, waste management and building specifications all having to be addressed.
Sclater estimates the total establishment cost was around NZ$1 million, much of it contributed by trustees and donors. Bridge and Fisher personally funded the UK-manufactured incinerator.
"Ivan Bridge and Andrew Fisher have been amazing. They contributed personally and financially to getting this off the ground," Sclater said.
"It's just really cool, because it's a group of like-minded forward-thinking people getting it done."
Gallery: Image courtesy of Rural Guardian
The crematorium operates through a charitable trust, with its trustees working voluntarily. Any profits are directed back into equine research, and the facility has a post-mortem examination area on site.
It also has a specialist collection service, something Sclater considers essential.
"I've always felt that a horse euthanised in his own paddock, in his own property is the best and most dignified end," she said.
"I've always felt that a horse euthanised in his own paddock, in his own property is the best and most dignified end." - Justine Sclater
"We have the most amazing guy that comes and he deals with it all. He's very compassionate. He knows exactly what he's doing."
The facility has its limitations. Located in the Waikato, it is accessible to many of New Zealand's major training and breeding operations, but much less practical for horses in the South Island. Rising fuel costs have also put considerable pressure on its finances.
The website lists cremation at NZ$950 plus GST, although Sclater estimates the actual cost of providing the service is now closer to NZ$1,800.
That is a considerable expense for an individual horse owner. But in the context of Thoroughbred racing, with single races almost every week exceeding $1 million in prizemoney running in Sydney, is it really beyond the industry's capacity to support and subsidise a service like this?
There is also an opportunity to provide an industry-funded cremation subsidy that follows a Thoroughbred throughout its life, including after retirement.
Rural Guardian cremation facility | Image courtesy of Rural Guardian
Sclater believes such a scheme is entirely achievable.
"It's not insurmountable for industry bodies. The money that could be spent on this would prevent any situation like what's just happened."
"The money that could be spent on this would prevent any situation like what's just happened." - Justine Sclater
Perhaps the most telling thing Sclater said was how she felt when the crematorium finally opened.
"When we opened the crematorium, I thought, 'for once we have done something, we have made this idea happen and now it is up and running'."
There are stories that illustrate what that investment has meant to the people who love these horses.
When champion New Zealand steeplechaser West Coast (NZ) (Mettre En Jeu {NZ}) died, his remains were cremated and his ashes returned to be buried with his late owner.
Rules are only part of the answer
Hinton has confirmed that he has spoken with NZTR's leadership about the crematorium model and wouldn’t rule it out.
"At this point, I would say everything's on the table."
He acknowledged that cremation was considerably more expensive than other disposal methods, adding that "there's no perfect solution".
He confirmed with TTR that Racing NSW would examine the New Zealand model in more detail and consult with the industry over the coming weeks. However, he also made clear that his immediate priority was implementing the new rules.
"We will continue our process of reviewing all current industry practices before determining what, if any, additional steps need to be taken," he wrote.
"We will continue our process of reviewing all current industry practices before determining what, if any, additional steps need to be taken." - Graeme Hinton
Hinton confirmed to TTR that Racing NSW would source and fund body bags for deceased horses, although how this will work in practice remains unclear.
Finding a suitable biodegradable bag for a 500kg animal is one challenge. Ensuring it can withstand being winched onto a transport vehicle without tearing is another. Whether such a product is available, how it will be provided urgently and if it will be accepted by disposal facilities is yet to be confirmed.
Making sure it never happens again
It's clear that the current standards governing the handling of deceased horses are inadequate. Establishing a clear record of where a horse goes and who is responsible for its disposal is a sensible place to start.
But recording the name of a contractor on a death notification form does little to improve a system that lacks appropriate infrastructure. Requiring a body bag may prevent the public from seeing a deceased horse, but it doesn't necessarily change how that horse is handled once it reaches its destination.
If the existing facilities and disposal arrangements are inadequate, addressing that will require investment, potentially in partnership with government and the veterinary industry.
Hinton told TTR the new rules would establish "enforceable standards set to protect the 99% that do the right thing against the 1% that don't".
The issue exposed by So You Are wasn't caused by anyone's intention to do the wrong thing, but an inadequate system that left those responsible for his remains relying on the limited options available.
Perhaps industry leaders should be equally focused on ensuring 100% have access to the facilities and services they need to do the right thing by their horses, right through to the end of their lives.