In Part 1, we saw little change in the top order from last year, identifying Frankel (GB) and Dubawi (Ire) as the world’s joint-most-expensive stallions. As we look at Australasia, Europe and North America, it’s the latter two that dominate in terms of stud fees, with Australasia represented just once in the combined top 10.
According to Rounsefell, who has extensive experience of buying, selling, importing and managing stock of all ages in each of our jurisdictions, this is something of a misnomer.
Craig Rounsefell | Image courtesy of The Image Is Everything
“In my opinion you need to look at the prices in the currency they are listed to get the best reflection as breeders are paying those services fees and then selling the stock in that currency,” he told The Thoroughbred Report.
“Obviously, with the weakness of the Australian dollar, when you do the conversions our top stallions come in lower than those in the USA and Europe, although comparatively they are solidly priced.
“In addition, the prices Australian breeders can access these high-priced stallions on Southern Hemisphere covers in Europe and the US is a good comparison of where they slot in against our top-priced stallions in Australia.”
“... the prices Australian breeders can access these high-priced stallions on Southern Hemisphere covers in Europe and the US is a good comparison of where they slot in against our top-priced stallions in Australia.” - Craig Rounsefell
Publicly, the most expensive of these known to TTR AusNZ is Juddmonte Farms’ Frankel, whose £125,000 (AU$240,000) Southern Hemisphere fee in 2023 was less than half his local fee of £350,000 (AU$673,000). The price reduction is even more stark for Three Chimneys Farm’s US sensation Gun Runner (USA) at US$65,000 (AU$92,300) compared to US$250,000 (AU$385,000).
Also in the global top 10 and available this year on Southern Hemisphere time was the Aga Khan Studs' Siyouni (Fr), with his usual €200,000 (AU$333,000) reduced to €60,000 (AU$100,000) for out-of-season covers.
Stakes-producing superstars
However, when they are made available on Southern Hemisphere time, the scope of out-of-season books for these superstars is regularly described by their respective studmaster with words like ‘limited’ and ‘selective’.
That’s unsurprising, given the prepotence of the elite, as they are managed with a view to balance increasing their international profiles against protecting them physically, ensuring they have a proper rest each year.
“There are quite a few rags to riches stories on this list,” Rounsefell noted. “From Into Mischief in the US to I Am Invincible in Australia and Wootton Bassett in Europe, although these are all quite exposed now.”
Unlike last year, this year’s analysis sees a shuttler amongst the global top 10, as Wootton Bassett’s (GB) €200,000 (AU$333,000) fee puts him in joint sixth alongside Sea The Stars (Ire) and Siyouni. In general though, shuttling is not common amongst the best of the best.
Wootton Bassett (GB) | Standing at Coolmore
With his first Southern Hemisphere yearling crop yet to hit the sales, Wootton Bassett’s influence in future years may well see him eclipse his competitors on accumulated results in both hemispheres, though Rounsefell cautions against expecting instant results.
“I very much look forward to seeing his stock at the yearling sales next year and like many of these great shuttle stallions that come to Australia, if the Aussie buyers can have some patience with them, it is entirely possible he will succeed here too,” he said.
For now, though there are, like last year, two clear winners when it comes to producing elite horses.
| Frankel | Juddmonte Farms' Banstead Manor Stud (GB) | $673,000 | 39 | 11 |
| Dubawi | Darley's Dalham Hall Stud (GB) | $673,000 | 38 | 8 |
| Into Mischief | Spendthrift Farm (USA) | $385,000 | 26 | 6 |
| Gun Runner | Three Chimneys Farm (USA) | $385,000 | 15 | 3 |
| Curlin | Hill 'n' Dale (USA) | $385,000 | 14 | 5 |
| Sea The Stars | Aga Khan Studs' Gilltown Stud (Ire) | $333,000 | 24 | 4 |
| Wootton Bassett | Coolmore (Ire) | $333,000 | 12 | 3 |
| Siyouni | Aga Khan Studs' Haras de Bonneval (Fr) | $333,000 | 10 | 3 |
| Quality Road | Lane's End (USA) | $308,000 | 17 | 1 |
| I Am Invincible | Yarraman Park Stud (AUS) | $275,000 | 22 | 2 |
Table: Top 10 with stakes winners for 2023
This year, Dubawi went one better than last as he saw eight individual Group 1 winners in 2023, and for the second year in a row he will be joined by another of his sons on the Darley roster. Modern Games (Ire) finally won at the elite level in his home nation this year, having taken Group 1-mile races at the Breeders’ Cup (twice), in France and in Canada, and he now settles into life alongside his father at Dalham Hall Stud.
Astoundingly, Frankel produced 11 Group 1 winners in 2023, and as mentioned in Part 1, he has six sons beginning stud careers next year. Three of those, Chaldean (GB), Triple Time (Ire) and Mostahdaf (Ire), make short journeys in and around Newmarket. A fourth, G1 Irish Derby winner Westover (GB), moves to Japan, as does another son of Frankel, Godolphin’s 2021 G1 Epsom Derby winner Adayar (Ire), whilst Onesto (Ire) was announced for Haras d’Etreham in France.
Gallery: Frankel's (GB) six sons beginning stud careers next year
Tied on 39 stakes winners apiece this year, and at 10.8 and 10.5 per cent stakes winners-to-runners respectively, Dubawi and Frankel are outstripping the rest. For comparison, the most expensive sire in the US, Into Mischief (USA), was responsible for six individual Group 1 winners in 2023, amongst a total of 26 stakes winners (5.3 per cent stakes winners-to-runners), and with even more runners (close to 500 so far this year compared to fewer than 400 for his European peers).
Last year, we concluded that what boosted Frankel and Dubawi to dominance on stakes winners was a combination of willingness to travel, poor local prizemoney and ample international turf opportunities.
“I would say that is a fair call,” Rounsefell said. “But I’d also add that their progeny are very versatile when it comes to ground, distance ranges and that they continue to improve with age and appear very sound animals.
“Exceptional stallions, such as Frankel, still represent value in my opinion, as your chances of producing a superior racehorse are significantly higher.
“Exceptional stallions, such as Frankel, still represent value in my opinion, as your chances of producing a superior racehorse are significantly higher.” - Craig Rounsefell
“It is a large sum for breeders to find although if they have the right mare then it is worth it as stallions such as Frankel are very rare. As Mr Hancock always tells me, ‘A good bull is half your herd and a bad bull is all of it.’
“I understand Frankel has served a full book of mares this season Southern Hemisphere time, so we will be seeing plenty of his progeny at the yearling sales in Australia in the years to come.”
Elite sales results
With the major yearling sales done and dusted for 2023, we’ve taken a look at how the global elite fare in the sales ring. Although the progeny discussed may have been conceived off a different fee, we’ve used the most recent fee (2023 for Southern Hemisphere and 2024 for Northern Hemisphere) as it's a good indicator of how stallion values were influenced by the yearling markets of 2023.
Zoustar | Standing at Widden Stud
It shouldn’t be a surprise to see that Zoustar, who is the only shuttler amongst the global elite to have had yearlings sell in both hemispheres, is firmly on top, numbers wise. He had 130 yearlings sell in 2023 from 150 offered, for an aggregate of $36,236,943 and average of $278,745.
Now with three crops sold in the Northern Hemisphere, Zoustar’s numbers there were down from last year, from just north of $50 million and $305,000 for his 2022 aggregate and average respectively. With stakes winners on the board, he appears to be gaining traction there, but he’s still got a way to go to match some of the others.
| Into Mischief | Spendthrift Farm (USA) | $385,000 | 70 | $74,969,249 | $1,070,989 | 28 |
| I Am Invincible | Yarraman Park Stud (AUS) | $275,000 | 92 | $62,145,000 | $675,489 | 17 |
| Wootton Bassett | Coolmore (Ire) | $333,000 | 97 | $47,280,799 | $487,430 | 7 |
| Snitzel | Arrowfield Stud (AUS) | $225,000 | 76 | $39,405,000 | $518,486 | 10 |
| Uncle Mo | Coolmore (USA) | $231,000 | 75 | $38,116,840 | $508,224 | 8 |
| Zoustar | Widden Stud (AUS and GB) | $200,000 | 130 | $36,236,943 | $278,745 | 7 |
| Gun Runner | Three Chimneys Farm (USA) | $385,000 | 63 | $35,397,989 | $561,872 | 10 |
| Curlin | Hill 'n' Dale (USA) | $385,000 | 39 | $32,355,259 | $829,622 | 10 |
| Frankel | Juddmonte Farms' Banstead Manor Stud (GB) | $673,000 | 30 | $30,763,315 | $1,025,443 | 9 |
| Constitution | WinStar Farm (USA) | $169,000 | 68 | $28,422,210 | $417,973 | 7 |
Table: Top 10 sires by aggregate yearling sales
Like last year, ahead on aggregate is Spendthrift Farm’s Into Mischief, whose 70 yearlings to sell totalled $74,969,249. Up eight from last year, those included a mighty 28 seven-figure lots (when converted to AUD), and were headed by a half-brother to young sire Outwork (USA) who sold at the Keeneland September Yearling Sale for US$3 million (AU$4.86 million).
In second is Yarraman Park’s I Am Invincible, who led the aggregate totals two years ago and broke $60 million for the first time this year. Averaging $675,489 across his 92 sold, he also sits fifth by that measure, behind Curlin (USA) in fourth with $829,622.
I Am Invincible | Standing at Yarraman Park Stud
The only three to have average yearling sales of over $1 million are Dubawi, Into Mischief and Frankel. Into Mischief is the odd one out here, with both Frankel and Dubawi close to the bottom by numbers of yearlings sold in 2023 (30 and 21 sold respectively) - leading to an obvious conclusion, according to Rounsefell.
“The breeders in Europe visiting these stallions are owner/breeders that are breeding to race and for the most part, are not for the commercial market,” he said.
“I guess like every industry, supply and demand dictate price and in Europe there is a much larger number of owner/breeders that have developed such deep families over generations and are always looking to continue that development with the best stallions possible.
“Whereas in Australia most breeders sell their stock at the yearling sales each year, which puts higher pressure on service fees and getting a return for their investment, particularly when it comes to the stallions at the higher end of the service fee spectrum.”
“... in Australia most breeders sell their stock at the yearling sales each year, which puts higher pressure on service fees and getting a return for their investment...” - Craig Rounsefell
The numbers certainly back that up. By region, the number of yearlings sold amongst the top 10 averaged 56 in the US, 55 in Europe and 68 in Australasia. The difference would be even starker but for Extreme Choice who, with his known early career fertility issue, had just 26 yearling sell in 2023.
As we saw last year, Australia features more prominently by this measure than any other, so it appears that our yearling market is remaining the most open and accessible of these three jurisdictions.
Hopefully that’s some minor comfort to any TTR AusNZ readers who need some hope heading into Christmas and Magic Millions in the new year.